If we draft Marner, he can be easily complemented with larger wingers. I think size is a lot more important along the boards especially if we want to utilise a playmaking centre.
- Status
Well when Hanifin has been ranked #3 by scouts all year and Marner has been between 5-7, that should say something.
Size matters in today's NHL.
If we were discussing Hanifin vs Strome then yes there would be a logical debate.
But Hanifin vs Marner? Are you kidding me right now?
Marner has Kadri 2.0 written all over him.
I get Marner had 126 points in the regular season and has 16 points in 7 games so far in the playoffs But, just because you are an elite scorer In the OHL/AHL doesn't mean it will carry over to the NHL. Especially when you are undersized.
Like, seriously? How do you guys not get this?
If Leafs brass feel that Marner is the BPA amongst: Hanifin, Strome, and Marner and we pick Marner and convert him to C, we have to keep JVR. JVR would be that huge winger that could potentially complement someone like Marner.
Bernier the Boats
Formerly BBurke
- Aug 31, 2011
- 2,256
- 0
In Kadri's age 17 season he had LESS THAN HALF (65 points in 68 games) of Marner's points per game.
How can you have such a strong argument without watching these players play? Like, my mind is literally blown that you could care so much without actually knowing what you're talking about.
So Truculent
Da Real MVP
Nylanderthal
Registered User
- Jun 9, 2010
- 7,901
- 6,251
or just suck again next year and draft a guy like Puljujärvi 6'3 or Sokolov 6'2
With who's pick? Cause the Leafs pick will be used on Auston Matthews
We can't have Hanifin become the next Aki Berg who was taken 3rd overall in the 1995 draft and was a 6'3 defenseman, and we can't have Strome become the next Chad Kilger who was taken 4th overall in the 1995 draft and was projected to become a big 6'4 center.
Even though Iginia is 6'1, and is smaller than both Berg and Kilger, he was drafted later and become a better player than both Berg and Kilger.
I'm not advocating Marner, as I haven't watched any of: Hanifin, Strome, or Marner, but the Leafs really need to get this right.
Even though Iginia is 6'1, and is smaller than both Berg and Kilger, he was drafted later and become a better player than both Berg and Kilger.
I'm not advocating Marner, as I haven't watched any of: Hanifin, Strome, or Marner, but the Leafs really need to get this right.
socko
Registered User
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I'm literally dying so true, just seems like so many people on here are a bit over their heads when arguing with people who actually take the time to watch. I could't believe the comparison but when I realized he was probably 12 i cooled down
I think Fowler's offensive instincts were/are better but everything else is in Hanifin's favor
or Marner be the next Robbie Schremp. We are using ridiculous comparisons right?
So Truculent
Da Real MVP
With who's pick? Cause the Leafs pick will be used on Auston Matthews
we all know Edmonton has that locked up
Bernier the Boats
Formerly BBurke
- Aug 31, 2011
- 2,256
- 0
No, not really. Fowler is a lot more creative offensively and takes a lot more chances (and subsequently, makes more mistakes) than Hanifin does. Hanifin is just an extremely mobile player, great at closing gaps, doesn't get beaten, makes a solid first pass etc. He doesn't have Fowler's offensive game.
If I had to compare Hanifin to a player, I like the Bouwmeester comparison. I also think Vlasic would be a pretty good one. Again, this is based on my viewings of Hanifin.
ToneBone03
Trust the Shanaplan
If Hanifin is available at 4 we take him and it shouldn't even be a discussion. There's a reason he's the consensus #3 pick.
If he's the consensus #3 pick (I agree fwiw), why would he be available at #4?
Do I really need to respond to this? This size thing is so over blown it's ridiculous. He's not that small, in fact there's a very healthy list of star players around his height and projected weight. This myth that you need giants to win in this era is a little ridiculous
My point is we need to avoid those types of mistakes made by other teams in the 1995 draft. We need to be careful that they don't become the next Aki Berg, Chad Kilger, or Robbie Schremp.
I trust that the Leafs brass will put in the necessary time to select the right guy and BPA at 4.
So Truculent
Da Real MVP
Hanifin just lacks the wow factor for me to be this high.
Doughty wows me, Karlsson wows me, Subban wows me....Hanifin just is very vanilla.
I want wow with a pick this high, I want Marner
Doughty wows me, Karlsson wows me, Subban wows me....Hanifin just is very vanilla.
I want wow with a pick this high, I want Marner
Bernier the Boats
Formerly BBurke
- Aug 31, 2011
- 2,256
- 0
Good point, last year we should have taken Ritchie as well. He was the consensus 6th pick. Real stupid not to take him when he slipped to 8, right?
Peace Frog
“Go on, say your thing man”
- Jun 18, 2009
- 2,267
- 629
He may be the consensus #3 pick by the scouts, but maybe Arizona will have a different opinion of who they think is the 3rd best pick in this draft.
firstemperor
Registered User
- May 25, 2011
- 8,755
- 1,445
Neidermayer, Lidstrom didn't wow anyone and they are superior players to everyone you named. I see hockey a lot like soccer, you want to be dominating possession.
Bernier the Boats
Formerly BBurke
- Aug 31, 2011
- 2,256
- 0
ToneBone03
Trust the Shanaplan
Arizona is kind of a wildcard picking at 3. They have SO many good, mobile, young D and are starving for offense. Maybe the opportunity to take Strome (big #1C) or Marner (to reunite him with Domi & Dvorak) will be too great to pass up. That's my logic anyway.
- Status
