Epic Calder Battle in 2024-25 Season

Fraser28 · 2024-10-11T14:16:15-0400

Czechboy said:
I say Michkov however it's rarely the guy I think it is. Bedard didn't win it. McDavid never won it. Oilers have never had a rookie of the year and think of all the 1OV's that have gone through there.

Still, I say Michkov!

Bedard did win it lol. By a landslide.

Golden_Jet · 2024-10-11T14:22:30-0400

Czechboy said:
I say Michkov however it's rarely the guy I think it is. Bedard didn't win it. McDavid never won it. Oilers have never had a rookie of the year and think of all the 1OV's that have gone through there.

Still, I say Michkov!

Bedard did win it, who were you thinking won?

Hull Fan · 2024-10-11T14:41:18-0400

Alright I admit lap the field may not be the best euphuism. He won't double in points, but he will have a significant gap between him and everyone else. 15+ points in a Calder race is too substantial to ignore for most voters.

The one thing that could hold him back is total minutes on ice. DeBoer will run four lines and Stank will only average 15-16 minutes a night. Some of these other forwards, let alone defensemen are going to have 4+ minutes more per game. That's what makes this particular set of rookies interesting. We'll see but yeah Stankoven should be if not the favorite then 1B.

Breakers · 2024-10-11T14:42:15-0400

Fraser28 said:
Bedard did win it lol. By a landslide.

I think remember faber got over 20% of the first place votes.

Landslide to me is like 95% or higher of the first place votes.

Mrfenn92 · 2024-10-11T14:43:21-0400

Fun rookie class

Golden_Jet · 2024-10-11T14:46:02-0400

Breakers said:
I think remember faber got over 20% of the first place votes.

Landslide to me is like 95% or higher of the first place votes.

Yep

2023-24 NHL Awards Voting | Hockey-Reference.com

www.hockey-reference.com

Czechboy · 2024-10-11T14:47:54-0400

Golden_Jet said:
Bedard did win it, who were you thinking won?

Dumbass = me

FlyguyOX · 2024-10-11T14:48:56-0400

Celebrini and stankoven off to hot starts.

Michkov gonna have to come out guns blazing.

Ghost of Murph · 2024-10-11T15:31:29-0400

Celebrini, mainly because those SJ home sweaters are sharp as hell and he looks great in it. SJ might not win a ton of games this season but they will be fun to watch.

Fraser28 · 2024-10-11T15:37:49-0400

Breakers said:
I think remember faber got over 20% of the first place votes.

Landslide to me is like 95% or higher of the first place votes.

We have very different definitions of landslide then. Winning with 80% of the first place vote is a blowout. One of the biggest in recent times I think actually.

Breakers · 2024-10-11T15:46:02-0400

Fraser28 said:
We have very different definitions of landslide then. Winning with 80% of the first place vote is a blowout. One of the biggest in recent times I think actually.

Just checking
Both Beniers and Seider had higher amounts

FlyguyOX · 2024-10-11T15:47:16-0400

Welp, Celebrini being evaluated for a lower body injury

Silky Johnson · 2024-10-11T15:47:53-0400

Bouboumaster said:
Lane Hutson will win it in the end, if he doesn't get hurt

No, he will not.

Garbageyuk · 2024-10-11T16:37:58-0400

PlushMinus said:
wtf are you talking about?? It's a Calder discussion - they're all rookies. None of them are perennial anything in the NHL yet.

I can't see Stankoven winning it but he is no slouch either. And he's playing with very good linemates on a potential Cup winning team

This is why reading comprehension is important lmao.

Garbageyuk · 2024-10-11T16:42:34-0400

Dr Pepper said:
Ah yes, Gretzky.

The perfect name you could've used, in a discussion about Calder Trophy winners.

Well done.

Actually, it was a discussion about rookies and their point totals, in a thread about a wider topic (Calder Trophy race). I love it when someone tries to be snarky and falls flat on their face lmao. Well done.

Marioesque · 2024-10-11T16:44:22-0400

I haven't watched a game of Celebrini yet, but Hutson is thoroughly impressive and if he is allowed the PP1 spot he could definitely win calder.

Garbageyuk · 2024-10-11T16:54:45-0400

cneely said:
Selanne.

He had a big lead, but he didn’t “lap the field”, not even close.

cneely said:
Perennial 30 and 40 goal scorers? Gallagher has had 30 twice in 12 years. Debrincat has had 40 twice in 7 years.

I don't think perennial means what you think it means.

Gallagher paced for 30+ goals per season for like a 5 year stretch, and Debrincat scored 40 twice and had another season where he paced for it. You can have fun splitting hairs if you want to though. The point is that it’s ridiculous to act as if it’s an insult to Stankoven to be compared to them - he’s not that type of talent.

nbwingsfan said:
Depends on his definition but Seider had 170 1st place votes vs Zegras with 15

The discussion was about points, not votes.

Leksand said:
Ovechkin and Crosby did, but the same season due to the lockout. If Stankoven gets 106 points, he might be well ahead of anyone else.

So nobody lapped the field that year, got it. And you think Stankoven is getting 100+ points? Lmao.

Dr Pepper · 2024-10-11T17:07:25-0400

Garbageyuk said:
Actually, it was a discussion about rookies and their point totals, in a thread about a wider topic (Calder Trophy race). I love it when someone tries to be snarky and falls flat on their face lmao. Well done.

Uh huh.

You brought up Gretzky in a thread about who's going to win the Calder Trophy, not me. :dunno:

It's clear you're just going around trolling, so I'll leave you to it.

Garbageyuk · 2024-10-11T17:20:31-0400

Dr Pepper said:
Uh huh.

You brought up Gretzky in a thread about who's going to win the Calder Trophy, not me.

It's clear you're just going around trolling, so I'll leave you to it.

No, you butted into a conversation mid way through without bothering to read the context of the discussion. Now you’re doubling down on the stupid. You’re way off base here, and making a fool of yourself, so I’ll leave you to it.

Bouboumaster · 2024-10-11T17:47:39-0400

Silky Johnson said:
No, he will not.

Bad take

Try again

PlushMinus · 2024-10-11T19:10:43-0400

Garbageyuk said:
This is why reading comprehension is important lmao.

And you in here arguing with about five people and thinking you're winning :laugh:

Marioesque · 2024-10-11T19:17:52-0400

cneely said:
Selanne.

Juneau had over 100pts too so definitely not lapped.

Garbageyuk · 2024-10-11T19:20:21-0400

PlushMinus said:
And you in here arguing with about five people and thinking you're winning

Because this place is the pinnacle of honest arguments, impartiality, and users with high reading comprehension, right? :laugh:

thestonedkoala · 2024-10-11T19:43:01-0400

Regal said:
Runner up means he wasn’t even considered?

Nope. Most fans and most experts pretty much gave Bedard the award before the season started and most fans argued that Faber was good but it was Bedard's to lose and even with his injuries Bedard won even though Faber was the better player

Regal · 2024-10-11T20:22:44-0400

thestonedkoala said:
Nope. Most fans and most experts pretty much gave Bedard the award before the season started and most fans argued that Faber was good but it was Bedard's to lose and even with his injuries Bedard won even though Faber was the better player

Faber had 46 first place votes but ok

Epic Calder Battle in 2024-25 Season

Registered User

Registered User

The Future is Now

Make Mirrored Visors Legal Again

Proud to be American

Registered User

Češi do toho!

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Make Mirrored Visors Legal Again

Registered User

I wish you all the bad things in life.

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Going Dark

Registered User

Ad

Ad

Ad