I will say overall scouting actually seems to be a bit overpowered at times. That's not to say MY scouts won't royall **** up and rate a guy 5* that has like a 120PA, or a give a potential all-star a lower ranking, but generally speaking, in the draft high PA guys get taken early and low PA sometimes go undrafted, regardless of their ranking. This sounds logical obviously, but it goes to an extreme sometimes.
EXAMPLE: A guy playing in like the CZE-5 or some super-low league, most attributes in the 1-5 range, nothing stand-out about his game, terrible stats, half the time my scouts don't even SEE the guy because he's in such a low league. He'll be unranked and get drafted in the middle of the 1st round. Go to the editor and he'll have a CA of like 27, but a PA of 180. So he's drafted where his PA has him, BUT let's be honest, with that low of a CA NO SCOUT is ever going to know he's going to become an all-star caliber player. At best he should be an Aho/Barzal/Kuch type that gets drafted a bit later. Realistically he should probably be more like a Panarin type, undrafted late-bloomer who becomes an all-star UDFA. Somehow, scouts in the game must be "seeing" this PA despite the fact that nobody would ever be able to realistically tell...that's like watching a 9 yo kid and saying "yep, future Crosby, guarantee it!" Maybe there needs to be a delta-limit of what kind of gap scouts "see"...like 75 pts above CA?
Additionally, if you don't get a goalie in the top 45, you're likely never getting a starter, maybe not even a decent backup. In real life, sure some of the best goalies go early (Vasy, Otter), but then you have plenty that go later rounds (Sorokin, Shesty, Swayman, Ullmark, Helly), or even UDFA (Logan Thompson). In real-life, goalies are voodoo. In EHM2007, I loved finding goalies in later rounds! In this version, I can't even remember the last time a drafted starting goalie wasn't a 1st/2nd rounder. And again, the above example has applied to goalies, low stats, not even playing in a lower-league, 1st round pick!
EDIT: I'll also add a few of those times those guys never developed, they never even hit 100CA or retired bc they weren't playing, which makes them being taken 1st round even more outlandish