Drai has proved he can produce with McDavid and Hall. Both players are hard to develop chemistry with but Drai found away. I chalk that up to him being very intelligent and thinking the game at a very high level.
This is simply not true.
The only player McDavid ever struggled to find chemistry with was Hall himself. Hall really hit a wall with Nuge and McDavid, but for the most part was productive regardless of his linemates as long as they would deffer to him.
Even though you might point out that Jordan Eberle was moved from that line for failing to score goals, his numbers with McDavid were still much better than without and McDavid was never significantly harmed by ANY linemate. The year prior McDavid killed it with Eberle and Pouliot, for example.
So if Hall had 31 points in those 25 games, that means that he got 34 points in the other 57 games. Doesn't sound like "high-end offense" to me.
I suppose you have some fancy chart that will to show just how awful Draisaitl is when playing with scrubs like Pouliot, Purcell, Yakupov, Cagguila ect as opposed to Hall and McDavid, but you could say that about almost every player in the league. They play better with good players. Thats nothing to hold against him.
I don't need to.
Hall was a top-10 NHL scorer twice before McDavid touched the NHL. He was and remains one of the games elite LWers. Draisaitl is the player on that line that had something to prove. And until he's not playing with a dude who is clearly better than he is, I have a hard time seeing him as a player who would produce to this level on his own merit.
I view this contract the exact way I viewed Jake Voracek's contract: Too much to commit/risk on a player who has been complimentary for his all of his best periods.
He could very well be legit and this will be a non-issue. You just can't know until he's put into the position to show that.