Who are all the guys that Crosby turned into 75 point wingers? I'll give you a hint. It's zero.
Eberle played a fair amount with McDavid last season and he never hit career highs and was eventually moved off both the first line and first unit on the PP.
I think guys score the amount of points that they are capable of scoring.
That's pretty fair and I think its generally true.
Are you sure you meant to quote me? Crosby has nothing to do with how bad the non-Draisaitl Oiler wingers are. Eberle has been steadily declining for three years and he was the # 3 scorer. My point was that if you replace a 70 point winger with a 50 point guy, the center's numbers are inevitably going to suffer. If you put an 8 point guy beside that center then the numbers get worse.
So any time CM wasn't with Drai he was with a player that wasn't very good, and that the statistical variance for McDavid with and without Draisaitl was unavoidable because the other guys don't belong on a top line. I was responding to the below stats being used as an arguement for anything given the talent drop to Ebs, then Jesse, then whoever else.
McDavid GF% without Drai: 62%
McDavid GF% with Drai: 64%
McDavid CF% without Drai: 52%
McDavid CF% with Drai: 53%
There are probably better stats out there to support Draisaitls value then these is all. FWIW I don't think Crosby ever managed to give a Maroon season to a winger, never mind 75pts.