Murray has been our best Dman, Smith looks good, and Kulikov is in my opinion essential for making it a little tougher for the opposing team in our zone. I don't see how Butch gets back in without injuries.
Devils 2020-21 team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - part XIV
- Thread starter JK3
- Start date
- Status
Murray has been our best Dman, Smith looks good, and Kulikov is in my opinion essential for making it a little tougher for the opposing team in our zone. I don't see how Butch gets back in without injuries.
ChicksDigTheTrap
No quick fixes, no cutting corners and no cheating
Lineup decisions tend to get talked about when you are losing. When the first losing streak happens it will come up. Note posters were disappointed Merkley did not make the team. They have 5 out of 6 points and posters no longer mention him.
AfroThunder396
[citation needed]
Butcher and Smith both played on their off side extensively in college/junior. Not what you want to ask your rookie to be doing, but Butcher should be able to handle it.
I don't disagree. It just seems a bit surprising we haven't really heard from Butcher or Ruff about him not playing. Certainly not complaining about this not being a bigger issue though. Butcher has essentially dropped from a top 4 defenseman coming into this season (not league wide, but projected for our lineup) to 8th on the depth chart once Vatanen arrives.
I still think he can be very very good in a sheltered role. We just don’t have the personnel to shelter him right now
The best sign of improvement in the NJ defense is if Butcher cannot beat out anyone for a top four spot and does not significantly outplay Smith for a spot on the third pairing. NJ does not have the correct partner for Butcher and while he'd be a good third pairing PP guy on a better team, NJ has a plethora of developmental defenders who are going to need protected minutes over the next couple of years and those minutes should not be given to a defender who cannot potentially use them as a springboard to the top two pairs.
It the games I've seen Butcher play on the right side, I'd say he was actually BETTER on the right than the left That was quite a while ago though.
SteveCangialosi123
Registered User
JK3
Go Easy-Step Lightly-Stay Free
Ruff was asked about Butcher not playing in the post game presser after game one. He said "Really just based on camp, for me I thought Smith had a better camp. I don't think Smith had a better last game in camp but for me the overall camp. I said we're going to compete here for ice time, we're going to compete to play. We have 8 or 9 defensemen that we really like and there's a couple of young kids that really showed well in camp also...so it just felt that Ty should be in the lineup".
Auto Pilot
Registered User
- Sep 7, 2019
- 3,909
- 3,794
So against the Rangers he was once again an outstanding acquirer of the puck.
In the 850 seconds of 5v5 ice time he touched the puck 31 times. This one puck per 27 seconds rate is elite. It’s comparable to the McDavids, Matthews and MacKinnons of the world.
Hughes is also now executing plays at a high success rate on those touches. On 31 attempts he amassed 25 completed passes and shots at net for an 80.6% success rate.
The last time he consistently completed plays at an 80% rate, he averaged over two points per game against USHL competition.
Jack Hughes, Year 2
In the 850 seconds of 5v5 ice time he touched the puck 31 times. This one puck per 27 seconds rate is elite. It’s comparable to the McDavids, Matthews and MacKinnons of the world.
Hughes is also now executing plays at a high success rate on those touches. On 31 attempts he amassed 25 completed passes and shots at net for an 80.6% success rate.
The last time he consistently completed plays at an 80% rate, he averaged over two points per game against USHL competition.
Jack Hughes, Year 2
Better Call Sal
Salnalysis
Clam Jensen
Registered User
Blender
Registered User
- Dec 2, 2009
- 52,638
- 46,400
TrufleShufle
Registered User
- Aug 31, 2012
- 8,445
- 14,090
Hughes and Palms blow my mind, if you were to describe these two players strengths and play style it would be insane to think anything other than perfect synergy.
I mean Hughes is doing his part, but it didn’t really work last year either when both were playing well. I know it’s not as simple as sniper with playmaker, but still, crazy how it just doesn’t work as well as it should.
I mean Hughes is doing his part, but it didn’t really work last year either when both were playing well. I know it’s not as simple as sniper with playmaker, but still, crazy how it just doesn’t work as well as it should.
Still too early. I mean Palms had a breakaway in each game one and two and didn’t finish on them. It’s not like they’ve generated nothing. Palms also had a brutal preseason last year and without a preseason this year and 10 months off it could just be taking time for him to get back to speed
RangerDoggo
The Devils have a culture of failure
Some fans are clamoring for Butcher to get back into the lineup. I’m just thankful we have a coach who doesn’t make rash roster shuffling at the drop of a hat.
Who are these fans - because I haven't seen any on these boards.
TrufleShufle
Registered User
- Aug 31, 2012
- 8,445
- 14,090
Not really putting a lot of thought into this year about it, I’m just talking in general, neither benefits from the other in the way you would expect.
ninetyeight
Registered User
I personally was more worried about giving him away before we get to see what his ceiling is, than not making the team.
But I agree with your earlier point, we're definitely gonna hit trouble waters sooner or later and I expect all of our defence to get heavy criticism when we do.
I'd be more than happy to see Butcher get a shot, there's a lot of talent there, he just needs to refine and adjust his game to his weaker skating. He was great in his first season, but then kinda lost his way, but I do believe it's entirely possible for him to bounce back. I feel like the best defencemen hit their prime at their late 20s / early 30s.
- Dec 20, 2018
- 22,774
- 50,935
Players do get injured during the season, it’s not limited to pre-season Switzerland. “We‘ll have way too many forwards when Nico gets back!” is only problem when 1) Nico actually back 2) somehow no other forward is injured. Players are dropping like flies on some teams, trading depth away is not good idea.
I don’t have no issue with Boqvist playing minutes with Bing either. It’s not the worst thing for him.
Bratt’s coming so that’s a real question. I’m waiting for Sami’s paperwork and Nico’s foot to force the other decisions.
ThePrideofStockholm
Registered User
So with Bratt back is the war against Sweden off?
Last edited:
Darkauron
Registered User
We can still go after finland for Sami!
- Dec 20, 2018
- 22,774
- 50,935
Ask the Russians how well that went for them in 1940.
- Status
