I think I've watched all the Disney era Star Wars films at least a half dozen times now...except TROS which I have not and have no desire to watch again. It was such a blatant attempt to apologize to the fans who hated TLJ that I think it just pissed off those who did actually enjoy TLJ (or at least half of it like I did). As much as I like Palpatine as a character, bringing him back was lazy and one of those "Hey isn't it cool" moments that we talked about earlier that did feel forced.
Bingo. It’s the combination of that and the ending that turned me off in a pretty visceral way.
There was just so much wrong with the development of it. Bringing back the guy notoriously shitty for endings. Bringing in the writer of BvS. Trying to appease people who likely never going to accept the movie after how they felt about TFA and TLJ while alienating the people who were actually big fans of the trilogy. Forcing them to complete the movie on a condensed timetable because Iger wouldn’t let them push it back which led to then releasing an unfinished movie. I remember the editors saying they worked up until Thanksgiving and just couldn’t continue working on the movie any longer because it was too close to release. Daisy said in an interview that even while they were filming she wasn’t sure if JJ was going to retcon her background or even what that retcon would be. It was an absolute mess from start to finish in production and to me that jumped out on screen as well
Last edited: