Combined Goalie Discussion thread

[zeke]

Leafs Goaltending Last Year: 89.97sv%
Murray + Samsonov Last Yr: 89.97sv%

 

[ToneDog]

Leafs Goaltending Last Year: 89.97sv%
Murray + Samsonov Last Yr: 89.97sv%

How much can we attribute to Pistol Pete and Kalgren ??

Time to see how it plays out. Let's hope Samsonov can carry his share of the load so that Murray is healthy come playoff time.

 

[Havoc]

A healthy Murray smokes Campbell

/thread

 

[hotpaws]

Leafs Goaltending Last Year: 89.97sv%
Murray + Samsonov Last Yr: 89.97sv%

and your boi is spending more this year to get the same sub par results he got last year , lol


no wonder he didn't get extended and is about to get kicked to the curb

 

[zeke]

and your boi is spending more this year to get the same sub par results he got last year , lol


no wonder he didn't get extended and is about to get kicked to the curb

what purpose does this post serve, do you think?

 

[hotpaws]

what purpose does this post serve, do you think?

what purpose did your post serve other than to show Dubas is spending more to get the same poor results

and here i thought you were a fan of the guy

 

[zeke]

what purpose did your post serve other than to show Dubas is spending more to get the same poor results

and here i thought you were a fan of the guy

my post served the purpose of comparing last year's goaltending to this year's goaltending on the goaltending thread.

what purpose did yours serve?

 

[hotpaws]

my post served the purpose of comparing last year's goaltending to this year's goaltending on the goaltending thread.

what purpose did yours serve?

my post served to show both are sub par just like your post did but this years tandem is more expensive

 

[zeke]

my post served to show both are sub par just like your post did but this years tandem is more expensive

Most the post was talking about other things.

 

[Dekes For Days]

Too bad you did not tell Holland who paid Soup 5x5 but luckily you never told Dorion or he would not have paid Dubas to take Murray.
It is ironic how early last year you said you do not need to pay for good goaltending but have shit on the Soup since the playoffs ended and it was apparent Leafs we going in a different direction. Are you forgetting, Soup gave up less goals than Vasi in round #1 ?

Obviously, contracts are about more than just a player's performance in the most recent season.
Not sure what discussion last year you're referring to, but no, you don't have to pay massive amounts to get good goaltending, and paying more for goaltending often doesn't provide an equivalent benefit.
I haven't dumped on Campbell at all. Just acknowledged the basic facts about his season when other people have made false statements in order to dismiss our current tandem.
Neither Campbell or Vasilevsky had a particularly great 1st round. Vasilevsky gave up one more goal than Campbell, but also faced more shots against.

 

[andora]

Wasnt pittsburgh a top team when murray had his best?

If anything there can be confidence for murray playing on a good team with good support

 

[ToneDog]

my post served to show both are sub par just like your post did but this years tandem is more expensive

If the rest of the team played above their pay grade as Soup did, Dubas would not be in the hot seat he is in today. Perhaps somebody can find a stat that links SV% to $$. Pretty sure Soup blows Murray, Mrazek, and Samsonov out of the water.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Does the team played for and games played have anything to do with it?

Is everything OK? You never, ever have a single positive word to say about a 115 point team that was within one goal of eliminating the 2 time cup champs.

Perhaps you need to take time off to gain a little perspective?

Maybe, that was the year Penguins won the cup.

 

[Leaf Fans]

and your boi is spending more this year to get the same sub par results he got last year , lol


no wonder he didn't get extended and is about to get kicked to the curb

Does "about to get kicked to the curb" mean that he might fufill his contract and not be offered a new one?

 

[Namikaze Minato]

 

[Gallagbi]

Campbell gave the Leafs 49 games 31 wins 2.64 GAA and .914 sv% & 5 Shutouts. - Record: 31 - 9 - 6 = 68 points
vs.
Murray career best Pens 49 games 32 wins 2.41 GAA and .923 sv% & 4 Shutouts. - Record: 32 -10 - 4 = 68 points

Matt Murray will need to match his career best season of 2016-17 to give the Leafs what Campbell did last year.

You think Matt Murray's 2016-2017 season is the same as what Campbell gave us last year?

 

[as Pure as Evil]

those are fabulous

 

[Martin Skoula]

You think Matt Murray's 2016-2017 season is the same as what Campbell gave us last year?

Playoffs are the only thing that matters until that becomes an inconvenient argument, then it's whatever range of stats make the point he has already decided is correct.

 

[Stringer Bell]

Can someone please rank all of our goalies for me including MacKay, Petruzelli, Peksa, etc?

 

[Namikaze Minato]

 

[kb]

If the rest of the team played above their pay grade as Soup did, Dubas would not be in the hot seat he is in today. Perhaps somebody can find a stat that links SV% to $$. Pretty sure Soup blows Murray, Mrazek, and Samsonov out of the water.

Murray is the 23rd highest paid starting goalie.

So if they get even middle of the pack goaltending, then

A) he outperformed his salary, and
B) he outperformed the near league worst goaltending the Leafs got after Christmas, no matter how little they paid. They got what they paid for.

Prove me wrong on any of this. Go ahead. Please.

 

[hotpaws]

Murray is the 23rd highest paid starting goalie.

So if they get even middle of the pack goaltending, then

A) he outperformed his salary, and
B) he outperformed the near league worst goaltending the Leafs got after Christmas, no matter how little they paid. They got what they paid for.

Prove me wrong on any of this. Go ahead. Please.

Murray's 6.25m aav salary makes him the 5th highest paid goalie according to spotrac,

 

[Dekes For Days]

Murray's 6.25m aav salary makes him the 5th highest paid goalie according to spotrac,

We are paying Murray just under 4.7m, not 6.25m.

 

[kb]

We are paying Murray just under 4.7m, not 6.25m.

Exactly. That retained cap hit for the Leafs places him as the 23rd highest AAV. The bar isn't high for him to outperform his cap hit.

 

[The Iceman]

Is Murray 100% healthy?

Didn't play yesterday and is not listed as the starter for either of the next 2 exhibition games...