Value of: Carter Hart to Habs

[Garbageyuk]

He's really the only guy I wouldn't trade. I mean it only took Philly 4 decades to find a goalie, why trade him?

A goalie with a .905 sv% and a losing record the last two years.

But I’m sure Flyers fans have a whole spiel to tell how and why that’s actually a good thing lmao.

 

[Garbageyuk]

We'll see if we're a bubble team or not next year, if we get Duboua this summer...

A mediocre 2C is going to make all the difference.

 

[not quite yoda]

I'd rather wait fir Devon Levi to be a UFA in 1 year....

 

[26Mats]

A mediocre 2C is going to make all the difference.

I mean we're only talking moving up to being a bubble team.

Mediocre means not very good, not middle of the road. I don't agree that Dubois is a not very good 2c.

 

[1865]

But but I thought that this guy was Carey Price 2.0?

Such a stupid stupid post. Jesus Christ. Hart is great, the Flyers are utter trash.

As a Habs fan, I’d love to get Hart. I believe he will be a legit#1 Star Goalie. Here is what I would offer.

Habs 2024 1st Unprotected+ Hoffman (cap dump)+Allen for Hart and Provov.

Hart could be Price’s replacement and our goalie for the next decade.

My lord. No. No. No. No. No. We even get a cap dump!

 

[Habs Halifax]

Such a stupid stupid post. Jesus Christ. Hart is great, the Flyers are utter trash.



My lord. No. No. No. No. No. We even get a cap dump!

Would you be OK if the cap dump was Jesus Christ himself?

 

[pooch]

My lord. No. No. No. No. No. We even get a cap dump!

Good luck. I tried to tell him that was a garbage offer.

 

[1865]

Would you be OK if the cap dump was Jesus Christ himself?

No chance. Notorious for disappearing for long spells in April.

 

[Whalers Fan]

As a Habs fan, I’d love to get Hart. I believe he will be a legit#1 Star Goalie. Here is what I would offer.

Habs 2024 1st Unprotected+ Hoffman (cap dump)+Allen for Hart and Provov.

Hart could be Price’s replacement and our goalie for the next decade.

Um, no. Rebuilding teams should never trade unprotected first round picks.

 

[1865]

Um, no. Rebuilding teams should never trade unprotected first round picks.

Yeh, that pick could be anything. It could even be Carter Hart.

 

[junyab]

I still very much believe in Hart so I'd prefer him over our current tandem. But what do the Flyers want?

 

[Leon Lucius Black]

I'd definitely be interested in Hart as a Hab fan, but I am guessing the asking price would be pretty high.

I have only seen a few Flyer games this year and he looked solid, his stats aren't great but it doesn't help when you play behind Ristolainen and Tony Deangelo.

 

[Garbageyuk]

I mean we're only taking moving up to being a bubble team.

Mediocre means not very good, not middle of the road. I don't agree that Dubois is a not very good 2c.

Mediocre: “Of moderate quality; not very good.” Same thing. Pretty fair description of PLD. Nice try though.

 

[Columbus Hockey Dad]

I would trade Carter Hart for Montreal's 1st this year. Not sure they'd agree to that though.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

I would trade Carter Hart for Montreal's 1st this year. Not sure they'd agree to that though.

Cart is nowhere near worth a top 5 pick

 

[Columbus Hockey Dad]

Cart is nowhere near worth a top 5 pick

And therein lies the problem...Hart will likely be far more valuable to the Flyers than what can be acquired for him in a trade. So, not sure there's an upside for the Flyers.

 

[Habs 4 Life]

I would trade Carter Hart for Montreal's 1st this year. Not sure they'd agree to that though.

Not a chance, maybe the Florida pick but even at that I don't see Hughes going in that direction when it comes to Goaltending

 

[Cup or Bust]

I wouldn't trade him. He could still have another good 10-12 years left. Even if they rebuild, finding a reliable goalie is not always easy especially a guy with good number 1 potential. Just keep him and not have to worry about goaltending, fix the other areas of the team. You trade him and it just gives you another piece you need to use assets to go out and find again.

 

[Habs Halifax]

Not worth trading for Hart cause the Flyers hold him with high value. Flyers are not trading Hart for cheap because his numbers are meh. His potential is still there and the Flyers are going to hold onto that hope for a while yet. Don't blame them, I would do the same in their shoes.

 

[26Mats]

Mediocre: “Of moderate quality; not very good.” Same thing. Pretty fair description of PLD. Nice try though.

I've had this discussion before, in a non hockey conversation.

Whatever the definition of mediocre, I definitely wouldn't call Dubois a 2c who's "not ver good" or even "of moderate quality." A big point 2c who's scoring at a pace of 74 points per 82 games through 61 games at the age of 24 is very good.

How many 2c's have more points than him?

 

[Habs Halifax]

And therein lies the problem...Hart will likely be far more valuable to the Flyers than what can be acquired for him in a trade. So, not sure there's an upside for the Flyers.

This is true but Flyers fans holding Hart at top 5 pick value is a massive reach. I respect the Flyers holding onto hope and high value but top 5 pick? Come on man.

The only way I see the Flyers trading him is maybe for a guy close to his age and potential. Something like the Patrick for Glass type trade.

Habs will ride out our Allen/Monty/Primeau train for now. But I fear how big our fan base is and goaltender is one of our rebuilding needs to don't be surprised at more trade ideas like this.

 

[captainpaxil]

Cart is nowhere near worth a top 5 pick

Yeah I'd want mallioux too. There's not really a deal for a franchise goalie in his prime

 

[Garbageyuk]

I've had this discussion before, in a non hockey conversation.

Whatever the definition of mediocre, I definitely wouldn't call Dubois a 2c who's "not ver good" or even "of moderate quality." A big point 2c who's scoring at a pace of 74 points per 82 games through 61 games at the age of 24 is very good.

How many 2c's have more points than him?

Enough that I’m not going to bother listing them. He’s a middling 2C.

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

Yeah I'd want mallioux too. There's not really a deal for a franchise goalie in his prime

Hart is good but hes no where near a franchise goalie

 

[ottawa]

Carter Hart (48 games) will most likely play twice as many games then Samuel Montembeault (28 games) this season, that makes a difference, if Montembeault played in 48 games his numbers would probably be twice as worse.

That's not how it works lmao, goaltender stats are already averaged out. They don't just get "twice as worse" because he plays twice as many games.