Reminds me of this recent thread I wrote:
Link
Connor Hellebuyck has been a consistently elite workhorse goaltender for years now. He is a technical goalie who relies on positioning rather than the agile floppers, the latter type who degrade in their 30s.
The Winnipeg Jets had underperformed for a few years and Hellebuyck was adamant about playing for a serious Stanley Cup contender. It is extremely rare for an elite goaltender to be made available. Michael Russo of The Athletic said that the New Jersey Devils, alongside the Buffalo Sabres, were unwilling to pay the Winnipeg Jets the massive cost they were looking for in a potential Connor Hellebuyck trade. Was that the right choice?
Let's look at some of the potential goaltender needy teams from this offseason:
Buffalo Sabres
Buffalo is on a frightful drought of having missed the playoffs since their 2010-2011 season. Over recent years, they had accumulated some impressive young talent, some superstar quality, and were emerging. They were close to qualifying last season but their starting goaltender, Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen posted a 3.61 GAA and .891 save %. The only other competent goaltender was 41 year old Craig Anderson but he finally retired.
Should Buffalo have made the massive goaltending upgrade to break the drought and help propel this young, star studded team into the playoffs and Cup contention?
Buffalo fans were adamant that Devon Levi was The Chosen One and they had no need to spend assets on Hellebuyck. How is Levi doing this year? 3.66 GAA 0.879 save %. YIKES! No surprise that Buffalo is a sub .500 team.
Did Buffalo make a mistake passing on this opportunity?
New Jersey Devils
The Devils finished 3rd overall, powered by their many young stars. They were similar to Buffalo except their defense was stronger to carry its mediocre goaltenders (which eventually collapsed in the playoffs). New Jersey turned over their defense to younger players, adding more pressure on its sub-par goalies. Was that a winning decision to build on its massive prior season?
This season, Vanecek is posting a 3.44 GAA and .886 save %. Schmid is posting similar miserable numbers: 3.46 GAA and .885 save %. What was once an elite team has fallen to the second worst squad in the Eastern Conference.
Did New Jersey make a mistake passing on this opportunity?
Edmonton Oilers
The Oilers made a big bet with Jack Campbell and it blew up in their face last year. Fortunately, unproven Stuart Skinner saved their regular season but when it came to the playoffs, he flopped and was replaced in a few games by Campbell.
We have been told that 2023-24 season is "The Year" for the Oilers. Stanley Cup or Bust! But were they serious by going to war with Campbell and Skinner again?
Campbell has completely lost his game and has been banished to the AHL. Skinner has posted a 3.66 GAA and .865 save %. The Oilers have sunk to 5-12-1 and fired their head coach and are desperate to figure out how to salvage the season.
Did the Oilers make a mistake in not upgrading their goaltending this offseason?
Summary
Many fan bases said that you no longer need a solid #1 goaltender to be successful and they point out the success that Vegas had last season. If any of you actually watched the playoffs, Vegas just absolutely destroyed any opposition goaltender and they could have put a pilon in net and still be successful. It's not a formula that would have wide spread success.
To those fans that dismissed the notion of paying the cost to secure an elite goaltender, are you now reconsidering your stance given the blight of your seasons to date?