"I'm not going to give you names, the people that have talked to me, talked to the league, said it was a nothing play," Tortorella said. "The point there is, and I'm glad the kid isn't hurt — a really good player, a young man in this league — but that's a problem in our league right now. Our players in this league do not put enough emphasis on making sure you're protecting yourself from hits like that, making sure you absorb hits like that.
"Because we've kind of tried to turn this league into a no-hit league. And now people aren't ready to be hit. I think it's a lost art in how you take hits. I do think, looking at the clip, I think [Hughes] thinks it's icing. A mistake was made. We've got good refs, we've got good linesmen, but a mistake was made last night. What bothers me is we had to suffer for that mistake — losing a player."
"I believe the league [is saying] it's a no-go, there is nothing wrong with the play," Tortorella said. "It shouldn't have even been a penalty. It screams to the athletes in our game: be prepared to be hit. Because big hits are allowed. Nowadays, I'm not so sure because everybody puts their arms up when there's a big hit. It makes me sick what goes on in the league here on big hits. That's part of the game.
"It's a fast game, which is fantastic. The skill in the game is fantastic. I think some of the rule changes we've made have improved the game. But I just don't think we should take the foundation of the National Hockey League out."
I don't think Torts is wrong by any means, but I don't think this play was black and white. Hughes clearly hasn't braced for the hit because he thought it was icing. The new icing rules put in place by the league was clearly to decrease the hard boarding hits that can turn into injuries where the D cannot brace for impact.
With that said, is Torts right in that it was a mistake by the refs not to calling it icing, and Philly shouldn't have been penalized for their mistake...? Not so black and white.
On an unrelated note, Hathaway has a very punch-able face like Bieksa.