TMLAM34
Registered User
- Oct 15, 2020
- 5,547
- 6,665
Hollowell was actually a pleasant surprise. He played well. But it’s night and day difference between Hollowell and Timmins.
I agree with you here …GLGMarchment and Joshua were good prospects. Marchment went on to play 6 games in Florida's farm system before playing the next two seasons in the NHL. Joshua had a poor first year where he was developing? I guess and the next season he saw a bulk of NHL games and now he is full time. Within 2 seasons of trading Joshua he was in the NHL, but he wasn't even worth an ELC in Toronto,. Most of the players don't make it. He did but wasn't good enough for an ELC here. That's just poor scouting.
It made no sense not to like Marchment for Malgin for a lot of people as well. I'm guessing they have changed their tune.
I prejudged the deal because it fell in the line with how Dubas opperates. It was the final straw for me. I tried to support him through the Kadri trade and all the others. But, I simply don't like the way he assembles a hockey team. Even if Douglas doesn't make the NHL I no longer support his thought process of team assembly. He undervalues physicality and I like physical hockey. I don't like seeing our home grown Clarks and Tuckers shipped off for the softest players on other teams (Kerfoot+Barrie) and (Malgin).
I hear ya. Please put an end to this Kerfoot/Engvall style of bottom 6 already.I agree with you here …GLG
“He undervalues physicality and I like physical hockey. I don't like seeing our home grown Clarks and Tuckers shipped off for the softest players on other teams (Kerfoot+Barrie) and (Malgin).”
And also his inability to recognize this very glaring deficiency and not address this as well .
One very perplexing thing that is even more stunning is how Shanny doesn’t seem to recognize this as well ??? When every team he’s won with all had that balance and serious role players to offset the elite with , it puzzling to me .
I’m a fan of Dubas in so many other areas of his tenure except for this obvious downfall and necessity on this team ???
Other than a top 6 LWer
We do not need any more smoothies and “ the same type of offensive players “ big or small …
Our 3rd and 4th line centers in Kampf and Holmberg are terrific and give us the best 4 centers .
But after that it’s 4 players that are basically the same or two old to bring it or not gifted at all ..
We need another type of player to add to those centres , hitters , grinders , youthful or older but that can skate and is hungry and plays with an edge and hits at all turns , every time all the time .and tough as nails .
Also one tough hombre on Defense .
I disagree, the reason I see us cutting through the neutral zone better its usually Timmins first pass. I haven't seen the numbers but I'll bet our zone entries have been better when he's on the ice.Timmins can play a somewhat unremarkable game and yet somehow be a points monster.
Ya, good luck with all that.I agree with you here …GLG
“He undervalues physicality and I like physical hockey. I don't like seeing our home grown Clarks and Tuckers shipped off for the softest players on other teams (Kerfoot+Barrie) and (Malgin).”
And also his inability to recognize this very glaring deficiency and not address this as well .
One very perplexing thing that is even more stunning is how Shanny doesn’t seem to recognize this as well ??? When every team he’s won with all had that balance and serious role players to offset the elite with , it puzzling to me .
I’m a fan of Dubas in so many other areas of his tenure except for this obvious downfall and necessity on this team ???
Other than a top 6 LWer
We do not need any more smoothies and “ the same type of offensive players “ big or small …
Our 3rd and 4th line centers in Kampf and Holmberg are terrific and give us the best 4 centers .
But after that it’s 4 players that are basically the same or two old to bring it or not gifted at all ..
We need another type of player to add to those centres , hitters , grinders , youthful or older but that can skate and is hungry and plays with an edge and hits at all turns , every time all the time .and tough as nails .
Also one tough hombre on Defense .
The only problem I have with Timmins is not knowing how he's going to stand up to the grind of playing on a nightly basis, if that's what he ends up doing.
The only problem I have with Timmins is not knowing how he's going to stand up to the grind of playing on a nightly basis, if that's what he ends up doing.
I find myself agreeing with you a lot.No guarantee that any player will 'stand up' to that type of ice time, injury history or no.
So far the kid looks good IMO.
Fighting majors, as a methodology to rank most physical defenseman?
Is this serious?
FWIW.. Timmins has more hits per 60 than Rielly, Giordano, Hollowell, Holl.... who you've ranked ahead of him on your list. He's not settled into his role yet, and he's playing conservative. Hitting has very much been part of his game, but it doesn't make sense to go out of your way, when you are trying to establish yourself. Play safe, within yourself, don't take yourself out of the play... learn quiet defense first. Once that becomes second nature, feel free to flatten some people.
""
I wish I could find the video, where he flattened someone entering the zone.
Joshua? Are you talking about Leivo? WTF does Leivo have to do with anything? He's your textbook AAAA player... really good at the AHL level, barely NHL quality. 29 years old, and nothing more than a journeyman.
You keep mentioning Douglas, and "Producing like Leivo did with the farm team". This can't be serious can it? Leivo can skate... Douglas... his straight line speed was ok last year... it seems to have gone away this year, and his first few steps and edgework aren't good. You keep comparing him to Leivo, and Marchment, two guys who can skate, while he can't. If you can see Douglas working his way up the lineup, return your crystal ball for a refund.
Maybe get on the trade for Luke Schenn bandwagon.. he's leading the NHL D men, with FOUR fighting majors this year. That four fighting majors, is more than the number of games Douglas will ever play in the NHL. Personally, I'd sign him as a depth UFA next year, but I'm not trading a 2nd + prospect for him now.
Double the points he had with the Marlies in 6 less games.How has Douglas been, though?
I bet he's living up to the hype in Arizona
Double the points he had with the Marlies in 6 less games.
You should qualify that he only had one point with the Marlies.Double the points he had with the Marlies in 6 less games.
I should have, but I liked the obfuscation by not mentioning that, and by not even mentioning Timmins scoring in the NHL by comparison.You should qualify that he only had one point with the Marlies.