Proposal: ANA-BOS-WPG three way trade

[SPV]

to Anaheim:

Ryan Spooner - C/LW
Joe Morrow - D
Malcolm Subban - G
Boston 2018 1st round pick

to Winnipeg:

Cam Fowler - D
Brandon Carlo - D

to Boston:

rights to Jacob Trouba


From everything I've read, Anaheim wants someone to play the left side in exchange for Fowler. Spooner is a young player that is more center, but has been transitioned to the left side in Boston for multiple spells. He's a young talented offensive player that is on a cheap contract this year, and still under team control next year. HF says that Anaheim's depth in net isn't deep, so Subban gives them another chip. Morrow is for depth, and they also get a 1st round pick, which if Boston doesn't improve has been in the mid-range the last two years.

Winnipeg fans have said they want a top end left-handed defender in exchange for Trouba. Fowler is just that. I've seen some debate about Fowler vs. Trouba; and most seem to agree Trouba is better. Bruins add a top defensive prospect in Carlo to balance it out; HF also says that Winnipeg doesn't have any high end defensive prospects, so there you go.

Boston gives up the most, but gets what they need the most. A top end right handed defenseman that can pair with Torey Krug and be the front end of their prospect pool in the years to come.

Flame away!

Click to read more...

 

[wintersej]

Too many minor parts going to Anaheim. And I don't think that Trouba has that much more value than Fowler, to be honest. Fowler is a better player that will make less money the next two years.

ANA: Spooner + Senyshyn
BOS: Trouba
WPG: Fowler + EDM 2nd (from Boston)

 

[Jeti]

If the Jets are getting Fowler, then it's Myers, not Trouba, that's going the other way. If Trouba is moved in a deal with Anaheim, Lindholm better be coming back.

Do we really need to say that in a dozen threads?

 

[WaveRaven]

No thanks from me Fowler is downgrade from Trouba. Lindholm is a better comparable.

 

[wintersej]

Lindholm is clearly better than Trouba.

 

[SPV]

I think I said that the consensus was that Trouba was better, hence the addition of a top end defensive prospect to the trade proposal. HF says that your defensive pool lacks high end depth; Carlo fills that void.

 

[WaveRaven]

Lindholm is clearly better than Trouba.

In some areas not in others.

 

[GoJetsGo55]

What do we do when Fowler walks in 2 years?

 

[SPV]

What do we do when Fowler walks in 2 years?

why can't you re-sign him? and you still have Carlo two years along in development at that point.

 

[SanDogBrewin]

The Bruins would give up everything in the OPs proposal but not Carlo.

 

[Pongs21]

I don't hate it.

 

[GoJetsGo55]

why can't you re-sign him? and you still have Carlo two years along in development at that point.

If we re-sign him, great. What do we do when he walks in 2 years?

 

[Pongs21]

Just realized that is a lot for BOS to give up - I don't see them signing off on this

 

[Gabe Kupari]

Jets easily pass. Like no doubt about it pass. Our LHD needs aren't as bad as ppl make it out to be.

Boston fans... just stop. Only way for you to get trouba is via offer sheet

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

to Anaheim:

Ryan Spooner - C/LW
Joe Morrow - D
Malcolm Subban - G
Boston 2018 1st round pick

to Winnipeg:

Cam Fowler - D
Brandon Carlo - D

to Boston:

rights to Jacob Trouba


From everything I've read, Anaheim wants someone to play the left side in exchange for Fowler. Spooner is a young player that is more center, but has been transitioned to the left side in Boston for multiple spells. He's a young talented offensive player that is on a cheap contract this year, and still under team control next year. HF says that Anaheim's depth in net isn't deep, so Subban gives them another chip. Morrow is for depth, and they also get a 1st round pick, which if Boston doesn't improve has been in the mid-range the last two years.

Winnipeg fans have said they want a top end left-handed defender in exchange for Trouba. Fowler is just that. I've seen some debate about Fowler vs. Trouba; and most seem to agree Trouba is better. Bruins add a top defensive prospect in Carlo to balance it out; HF also says that Winnipeg doesn't have any high end defensive prospects, so there you go.

Boston gives up the most, but gets what they need the most. A top end right handed defenseman that can pair with Torey Krug and be the front end of their prospect pool in the years to come.

Flame away!

Good luck with this, No way is Cheveldayoff surrendering 4 years of Trouba for 2 years of Fowler this has already been beaten to death. Trouba better then Fowler if Trouba is going to Boston then most like Krug will be going to Winnipeg in a swap and right now Krug is better and cheaper then Trouba. This wont end well.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

why can't you re-sign him? and you still have Carlo two years along in development at that point.

Because maybe Fowler doesn't want to resign with Winnipeg, And he could easily command around $5.5 per million to $6 million per long term maybe Cheveldayoff doesn't want to pay him that much.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Too many minor parts going to Anaheim. And I don't think that Trouba has that much more value than Fowler, to be honest. Fowler is a better player that will make less money the next two years.

ANA: Spooner + Senyshyn
BOS: Trouba
WPG: Fowler + EDM 2nd (from Boston)

Boston easily wins this one hands down, If Fowler is coming to Winnipeg then Myers will be the one out the door not Trouba. Fowler to Winnipeg and Trouba to Boston is a downgrade for Winnipeg no way they do this deal.

 

[Mortimer Snerd]

Lindholm is clearly better than Trouba.

Then Wpg will add - a little. Trouba is clearly much better than Fowler.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Then Wpg will add - a little. Trouba is clearly much better than Fowler.

Yeah this OP is ridiculously bad for Winnipeg, No way would Cheveldayoff ever do it.

 

[Mortimer Snerd]

to Anaheim:

Ryan Spooner - C/LW
Joe Morrow - D
Malcolm Subban - G
Boston 2018 1st round pick

to Winnipeg:

Cam Fowler - D
Brandon Carlo - D

to Boston:

rights to Jacob Trouba


From everything I've read, Anaheim wants someone to play the left side in exchange for Fowler. Spooner is a young player that is more center, but has been transitioned to the left side in Boston for multiple spells. He's a young talented offensive player that is on a cheap contract this year, and still under team control next year. HF says that Anaheim's depth in net isn't deep, so Subban gives them another chip. Morrow is for depth, and they also get a 1st round pick, which if Boston doesn't improve has been in the mid-range the last two years.

Winnipeg fans have said they want a top end left-handed defender in exchange for Trouba. Fowler is just that. I've seen some debate about Fowler vs. Trouba; and most seem to agree Trouba is better. Bruins add a top defensive prospect in Carlo to balance it out; HF also says that Winnipeg doesn't have any high end defensive prospects, so there you go.

Boston gives up the most, but gets what they need the most. A top end right handed defenseman that can pair with Torey Krug and be the front end of their prospect pool in the years to come.

Flame away!

Boston gives up quite a lot to get Trouba but it doesn't go to Wpg. It goes to Anaheim for Fowler. Anaheim gets a lot and only gives up Fowler.

 

[Maukkis]

This looks like one of the better three-way deals in a while. Everyone gets robbed in some way: Boston gives too much value, Anaheim doesn't get a player of Fowler's caliber back, and Winnipeg gives up the best asset from a position of need. But at the same time... Winnipeg gets a replacement for now, and then a good prospect for the future. Anaheim gets cheap talent back to fill a need in Spooner and Subban, and Boston gets a much-needed top pairing RHD.

As a Jets fan, I'd accept this deal if Trouba is bridged/can't reach an agreement with us, but if you change anything in this deal which works against us, it's a no. Trouba is still more important than Fowler to us, but getting Carlo with him offsets it just enough for me.

I don't think it's that bad of a deal to anyone, tbh. But then again, people see those negatives... and only them.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

The OP is pretty horrendous for Winnipeg, Boston sends far to much to Anaheim for Fowler. Winnipeg gets Fowler and a D prospects that's not nearly enough for Trouba quite a few teams could easily beat this offer. Edmonton to name one. Still think that if Boston wants Trouba then Krug needs to be going to Winnipeg. No need for Anaheim here as Fowler is a downgrade compared to Trouba. Boston easily wins this one hands down.

 

[Paul4587]

That's quite a haul coming to Anaheim, we would obviously say yes. Morrow is a bit redundant though.

Winnipeg definitely says no.

 

[HockeyHead21]

The OP is pretty horrendous for Winnipeg, Boston sends far to much to Anaheim for Fowler. Winnipeg gets Fowler and a D prospects that's not nearly enough for Trouba quite a few teams could easily beat this offer. Edmonton to name one. Still think that if Boston wants Trouba then Krug needs to be going to Winnipeg. No need for Anaheim here as Fowler is a downgrade compared to Trouba. Boston easily wins this one hands down.

What?

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Boston and Anaheim make out great, Winnipeg not so much. If Boston wants Trouba then i think that Krug has to go the other way to Winnipeg.