monitoring_string = "358c248ada348a047a4b9bb27a146148"
Rumor: - All Purpose Trade Proposals, Speculation and Rumours - 2023/24 | Page 24 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
  • Xenforo Cloud upgraded our forum to XenForo version 2.3.4. This update has created styling issues to our current templates, this is just a temporary look. We will continue to work on clearing up these issues for the next few days and restore the site to it's more familiar look, but please report any other issues you may experience so we can look into. Thanks for your patience and understanding.

Rumor: All Purpose Trade Proposals, Speculation and Rumours - 2023/24

Status
Not open for further replies.
I just don't see a road where we are better without them and if we plan on competing, which judging by the PLD trade, we pretty much have to now. We are a worse team without them and there is no way in hell we replace them soon enough by trading them.

There's two roads right now. One involves keeping them and just clinging to a bit of hope, the other involves trading them and being a bubble team for the foreseeable future.

I think the big kicker is that our division doesn't look to be particularly strong. There are really only two elite teams if that. Dallas manged to turn the corner largely due to a crop of young talent blossoming. We have some good young talent that hopefully will grow into good players that can push the team forward.

I can see a scenario where we get a seeded position and can make some noise over the next few seasons provided we keep Mark and Helle.
 
I just don't see a road where we are better without them and if we plan on competing, which judging by the PLD trade, we pretty much have to now. We are a worse team without them and there is no way in hell we replace them soon enough by trading them.

There's two roads right now. One involves keeping them and just clinging to a bit of hope, the other involves trading them and being a bubble team for the foreseeable future.
Are we even a bubble team without them though? That would be a team that scraped 95 points suddenly losing its #1 and #2C, its Vezina finalist goaltender, and its #5 point getter. Remove them from our team last year, and I'd be surprised if we break 80. Are we really expecting to be better next year? If so, why?
 
Coming in peace as a rangers fan. I need to know what Blake Wheeler is at this point. Thanks
v good play-maker and passer & is still an adept point producer as a top-6er. he's not as great of a puck-carrier/rush offense guy as he used to be. i think you pair him w/ Chytil and another shooter and you'll have a solid top-9 line.
 
Could see Domi being interested in signing here but not sure we have a need for him.
 
Are we even a bubble team without them though? That would be a team that scraped 95 points suddenly losing its #1 and #2C, its Vezina finalist goaltender, and its #5 point getter. Remove them from our team last year, and I'd be surprised if we break 80. Are we really expecting to be better next year? If so, why?
yeah this is why i have not been sold on this "retool", "restructure", "reconfigure" whatever buzz word posters like to use.

can the Jets do a NYI-type turnaround when they lost Tavares, brought in Trotz and were making ECFs :dunno:
 
Oh I know but we have to hope he changes his mind or we are f***ed. This team will spin it's tires for the foreseeable future even worse than it has been.
I mean, we are far from f***ed.

we can still be competitve without a top 5 goalie.

we have enough talent to be a top 8 team in the league with a top goalie or a top coach (not Bowness)
 
Are we even a bubble team without them though? That would be a team that scraped 95 points suddenly losing its #1 and #2C, its Vezina finalist goaltender, and its #5 point getter. Remove them from our team last year, and I'd be surprised if we break 80. Are we really expecting to be better next year? If so, why?

Arizona got 70. You think this team even without those players is only capable of 5 more wins than last years Arizona squad?

I think the big kicker is that our division doesn't look to be particularly strong. There are really only two elite teams if that. Dallas manged to turn the corner largely due to a crop of young talent blossoming. We have some good young talent that hopefully will grow into good players that can push the team forward.

I can see a scenario where we get a seeded position and can make some noise over the next few seasons provided we keep Mark and Helle.

Yeah I think we can easily make the playoffs with those 2. Without them I think we are probably a 10-16 draft spot team.
 
Are we even a bubble team without them though? That would be a team that scraped 95 points suddenly losing its #1 and #2C, its Vezina finalist goaltender, and its #5 point getter. Remove them from our team last year, and I'd be surprised if we break 80. Are we really expecting to be better next year? If so, why?
Vilardi is still going to get better. We have Nino and Iaffalo for a full season and they are productive. We should be tougher to play against, hopefully more buy in defensively. I think if we replace Helly with a good tandem going forward we’d be okay, but we don’t have anyone to replace Scheif unfortunately and may need to extend him long term on a contract that won’t age well. But as far as next year the current roster we have has more depth.
 
I mean, we are far from f***ed.

we can still be competitve without a top 5 goalie.

we have enough talent to be a top 8 team in the league with a top goalie or a top coach (not Bowness)

I don't think without those 2 that we are better than Colorado, Dallas or likely even Minny.

We have to remember that Helle has not just been one of the busiest goalies in the entire league. He is the busiest goalie in the entire league. I fail to see how anyone can take on that load even in tandem. Our defence isn't just going to magically be better anytime soon.
 
Yeah I think we can easily make the playoffs with those 2. Without them I think we are probably a 10-16 draft spot team.
Agree with this, except for the proviso of it depends what comes back in the forward group and who is in net. (and who coaches after this season)

But yeah, either way, 10-20 draft spot team.

I don't think without those 2 that we are better than Colorado, Dallas or likely even Minny.

We have to remember that Helle has not just been one of the busiest goalies in the entire league. He is the busiest goalie in the entire league. I fail to see how anyone can take on that load even in tandem. Our defence isn't just going to magically be better anytime soon.
I don't think we're too off on our expectations - just maybe the tone. The fact that Helly has been one of the busiest goalies is an opportunity to improve with a lesser goalie. Shore up the quantity/quality of the chances and it mitigates some of the impact of losing him.
 
Oh I know but we have to hope he changes his mind or we are f***ed. This team will spin it's tires for the foreseeable future even worse than it has been.
Chevy usually comes out of tough situations much better than I think he will. I’m expecting (hoping) the same with Helle and to a lesser extent, Scheifele.
 
Arizona got 70. You think this team even without those players is only capable of 5 more wins than last years Arizona squad?
Kinda, yeah? The Capitals and Red Wings both finished with 80, and I don't think our team without those players stick out as better than them.

Our forwards last season without those players would have relied on the offensive output of Connor, Ehlers who missed half the season, and Perfetti who is 20 and missed half the season. Our D, while comparably a strength, has to be the most expensive completely unremarkable D this side of Vancouver. And without Helle, our goalies don't exist.

I think we've been Hellebuyck away from finishing in the bottom 10 multiple times the past few years. Removing him AND half our top 6? I think we stink, plain and simple. You're a lot more optimistic about this than I am. I think we are spinning our wheels with no hope right now.
 
Agree with this, except for the proviso of it depends what comes back in the forward group and who is in net. (and who coaches after this season)

But yeah, either way, 10-20 draft spot team.


I don't think we're too off on our expectations - just maybe the tone. The fact that Helly has been one of the busiest goalies is an opportunity to improve with a lesser goalie. Shore up the quantity/quality of the chances and it mitigates some of the impact of losing him.

We are unlikely to find a replacement 1C anywhere anytime soon. We may be able to find a middling starter with some upside in return for Helle. I just don't see this team having a chance of sniffing the playoffs without equal goaltending either by player or tandem.

The opportunity to improve means improving our defence which is an equally as tough a job as finding another 1C.
 
Vilardi is still going to get better. We have Nino and Iaffalo for a full season and they are productive. We should be tougher to play against, hopefully more buy in defensively. I think if we replace Helly with a good tandem going forward we’d be okay, but we don’t have anyone to replace Scheif unfortunately and may need to extend him long term on a contract that won’t age well. But as far as next year the current roster we have has more depth.
I was thinking last season. This season I see us as being basically the same, replacing PLD and Wheeler's production with that of Nino, Iaffalo and Vilardi. But that's the thing, us being basically the same isn't good. We made the playoffs by three points and got smoked. If the goal for the season is the revenue from 2 playoff home games, we might do that. But where does that get us next?
 
Are we even a bubble team without them though? That would be a team that scraped 95 points suddenly losing its #1 and #2C, its Vezina finalist goaltender, and its #5 point getter. Remove them from our team last year, and I'd be surprised if we break 80. Are we really expecting to be better next year? If so, why?
I dunno. Jets lost their #1C, #1D and #1W in the playoffs last year and many fans and pundits were still mad that they lost to Vegas in Round 1, so...
 
Well, planning to run back a 95 point team that has traded their #2C and bought out their 5th highest point producer is certainly an idea. Maybe we'll reach the playoffs, get stomped in the first round, and lose our self rentals for nothing. Sounds fun

I miss when it felt like this team had some kind of plan past the next April.

Living paycheque to paycheque.

It will be interesting to see what Chevy does with Scheifele and Helle challenge.
 
Kinda, yeah? The Capitals and Red Wings both finished with 80, and I don't think our team without those players stick out as better than them.

Our forwards last season without those players would have relied on the offensive output of Connor, Ehlers who missed half the season, and Perfetti who is 20 and missed half the season. Our D, while comparably a strength, has to be the most expensive completely unremarkable D this side of Vancouver. And without Helle, our goalies don't exist.

I think we've been Hellebuyck away from finishing in the bottom 10 multiple times the past few years. Removing him AND half our top 6? I think we stink, plain and simple. You're a lot more optimistic about this than I am. I think we are spinning our wheels with no hope right now.

The Caps and Wings also play in much tougher divisions. The top 3 of the Atlantic was basically decided by Halloween and the Metro was a bloodbath. This team is going to try and compete for better or worse so we might as well be better because I don't think we are as bad as the bottom 9. Anaheim, Arizona, Chicago, San Jose, Montreal, Philly, Vancouver, Nashville, Calgary are all worse IMO. Jury is out on whether CBJ, Chicago, Detroit and Buffalo can turn the corner. Who knows what the Caps look like next year.
 
I don't think without those 2 that we are better than Colorado, Dallas or likely even Minny.

We have to remember that Helle has not just been one of the busiest goalies in the entire league. He is the busiest goalie in the entire league. I fail to see how anyone can take on that load even in tandem. Our defence isn't just going to magically be better anytime soon.

He wasn't among the busiest last year though. We were an above average defensive team. If we improve on that and I think we will as our forwards have been augmented with better defensive forwards we may not need him or whoever to steal games like Helle had to circa 2020-2022.
 
I was thinking last season. This season I see us as being basically the same, replacing PLD and Wheeler's production with that of Nino, Iaffalo and Vilardi. But that's the thing, us being basically the same isn't good. We made the playoffs by three points and got smoked. If the goal for the season is the revenue from 2 playoff home games, we might do that. But where does that get us next?
The big improvement this year is probably with the two way play. With the forwards helping out a little bit more that probably improves us a bit. Maybe a more balanced lineup.
 
The Caps and Wings also play in much tougher divisions. The top 3 of the Atlantic was basically decided by Halloween and the Metro was a bloodbath. This team is going to try and compete for better or worse so we might as well be better because I don't think we are as bad as the bottom 9. Anaheim, Arizona, Chicago, San Jose, Montreal, Philly, Vancouver, Nashville, Calgary are all worse IMO. Jury is out on whether CBJ, Chicago, Detroit and Buffalo can turn the corner. Who knows what the Caps look like next year.
Could be. Could not be. Similarly though, are we anywhere near as good as the top 10 teams even if we keep all our players? I liked the PLD trade for value (though not really for direction). But Vilardi and Iaffalo were 7th and 9th in points for a team that, while better than us, weren't exactly setting the world on fire. Nino, similarly, is fine. All three should probably be middle 6ers.

Other than the off chance that Helle catches on fire for multiple rounds, do we have any chance at getting past the 2nd round? Do we even have a particularly good chance at getting past the 1st? We need to either be better than Dallas and Colorado (who presumably won't be crippled beyond recognition), or beat out the top team in the pacific as a wild card.
 
I was thinking last season. This season I see us as being basically the same, replacing PLD and Wheeler's production with that of Nino, Iaffalo and Vilardi. But that's the thing, us being basically the same isn't good. We made the playoffs by three points and got smoked. If the goal for the season is the revenue from 2 playoff home games, we might do that. But where does that get us next?
We are spinning our tires on that bubble playoff line no doubt. Would be best to suck for a year or two and rebuild but Chevy won’t have it.
 
We are spinning our tires on that bubble playoff line no doubt. Would be best to suck for a year or two and rebuild but Chevy won’t have it.
Rebuilds don’t take one or two years. They take seven or eight years.
 
Rebuilds don’t take one or two years. They take seven or eight years.
Maybe that’s the wrong word. I remember Tampa and Avs sucking there for a year getting a high pick, drafting a good player then getting on with things. And if I’m not mistaken supplemented their stock pile by trading duchene that became makar? Scheif or Helly could return something similar?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top
-->->