Gardner McKay
RIP, Jimmy.
Don't know why NYR would be his choice looking at it form any angle.
They are a team that doesn't score a lot (which won't bode well for his point totals/next contract)
Their cap situation isn't great with Staal and Girardi wasting lots of space for a long time coming
They rely heavily on a goalie who is starting to get up there in years and will have a rough go of it if/when he slows down.
I get it from a city perspective, to be young in New York would be fun, but from a hockey perspective it makes no sense.
We were only tied for 7th in goals scored during the regular season.
We have plenty of cap space after moving Brassard (and Nash with his 7.8 million is likely gone soon).
Considering Lundqvist had a pretty poor year and we still managed 101 points, your third point is also false.
If you are going to give reasons as to why a player shouldn't go somewhere you may want to conduct even a TINY bit of research before hand.