This team gets outplayed 70% of their games. Goaltending has masked an avg. team.
Unfortunately the Islanders aren't an average team, there what I like to refer to as a "nice team".
They'll win their share of games, beat good teams, lose to bad team, borderline playoff team. They might sneak in, based on the play of other teams around them, they might just miss the playoffs. The problem with "nice teams" is that, although they're competitive and they give fans some fun moments, they end up drafting somewhere around 12-16 every year, so they never really become a real serious top tier team.
IMO, the Islanders really need to be sellers this year at the trade deadline. They have the worst prospect pool in the NHL and they're not getting any younger. The Isles need to have a few drafts where they have early 1st round picks. The current team past their expiration date last year, arguably the year before.
The Isles need a rebuild. There's no question in my mind. This is a stale team.