Yeah, originally that scouting report had me wanting him (depending on who was left). But between the lowered minutes and the Russian factor, he might be a guy that drops. Hopefully if we pick up another 1st (and the scouting staff believes he can get to that elite level), they can move up for him or he falls to the other 1st... I doubt he lasts too long though because of that size.
Prospect Info: 2024 NHL Entry Draft (Ducks pick #3, They didn’t drop! OMG It’s a Miracle!)
- Thread starter WhatTheDuck
- Start date
-
Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
- Status
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
I said it before and I think he is a bit of a trap pick…. He’ll be a nhl player but I think closer to myers than hedman.
Some team is gunna pick him top 5 and regret it.
Russian orgs drop ice time when they want to strongarm a prospect into signing for another year to stay in Russia or change his mind about leaving early despite agreements. Also the later he gets picked the more likely he spends more time there. This is nothing new. Just because his TOI dropped doesn't necessarily mean anything. Just watch him or listen to scouts that do.
I'd take a gamble on him, but not with our 1st (unless we go on a huge run and the pick is a lot worse than we think). If we can trade up for him for a reasonable price, I'd take a swing and hope that there is more to him. As I said, I don't think he'll be there that late. I don't think he goes top 5, but probably in the back half of the top 10.
Oh ok, I didn't know that. If he does drop, I'd take a swing at him if the Ducks add another first and can move up for him, I don't know if I pick him with the Ducks pick considering how many good D there are this draft. End of the day, I trust the Ducks scouting staff with defense.
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
Ya if your picking a little later than top 5 it’s prob an alright pick/risk but I don’t like the risk in top 5
Rasp
Registered User
- Apr 9, 2019
- 1,386
- 2,000
All I know for sure is that if we take a D with our first pick he is going to be awesome
Last edited:
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
There is a lot of good dmen in this draft, I won’t be shocked if we find a couple good ones
Rasp
Registered User
- Apr 9, 2019
- 1,386
- 2,000
Dobber Prospects latest ranking is wildly different from the consensus.
1. Celebrini
2. Demidov
3. Catton
4. Lindstrom
5. Buium
6. Parekh
7. Dickinson
8. Helenius
9. Levshunov
10. Chernyshov
12. Silayev
16. Eiserman
22. Jiricek
24. Yakemchuk
Mckeen's latest ranking is more in line with others.
1. Celebrini
2. Dickinson
3. Demidov
4. Silayev
5. Lindstrom
6. Catton
7. Levshunov
8. Helenius
9. Eiserman
10. Parekh
11. Yakemchuk
15. Buium
17. Jiricek
1. Celebrini
2. Demidov
3. Catton
4. Lindstrom
5. Buium
6. Parekh
7. Dickinson
8. Helenius
9. Levshunov
10. Chernyshov
12. Silayev
16. Eiserman
22. Jiricek
24. Yakemchuk
DobberProspects’ Mid-Season Top 64 for the 2024 NHL Draft
It's finally here. After much deliberation, a two-hour-long meeting and hundreds of cumulative viewings, the DobberProspects scouting team is ready to reveal our top 64 prospects for the 2024 NHL Draft. Between the World Juniors, the U18 Five Nations tournament, and lots and lots of league...
dobberprospects.com
Mckeen's latest ranking is more in line with others.
1. Celebrini
2. Dickinson
3. Demidov
4. Silayev
5. Lindstrom
6. Catton
7. Levshunov
8. Helenius
9. Eiserman
10. Parekh
11. Yakemchuk
15. Buium
17. Jiricek
2024 NHL DRAFT: MCKEEN'S MID-SEASON TOP 32 - Celebrini sits comfortably on top - Demidov and Parekh among risers in ranking - Strong defense group defines this draft class
McKeen's Hockey releases its top 32 ranking for the 2024 NHL Draft.
www.mckeenshockey.com
Last edited:
I think this year the drop off after Celebrini, Lindstrom and Demidov to Eiserman, Catton, Connelly is large enough for there to be a reason to pick Demidov ahead of, likely Catton. Although we still have all of the most important club games left so we'll see.
Catton and Demidov are both rising their stocks. Lindstrom injured and Eiserman is what he is. Myself I'd argue that the order as it stands is:
Celebrini
Demidov
Catton
Lindstrom
Connelly
Eiserman
Then there's development to consider, guys going to NCAA:
Celebrini, while a college prospect looks like he will turn pro after just this season due to performance.
Eiserman is joining NCAA BU after decommitting earlier commitment to Minnesota. I admire his commitment.
And Connelly who is committed to NCAA Providence and to me it seems likely he will spend 2 years there.
The Russian factor:
Demidov is under contract for another year in KHL, which carries added risk regarding treatment from KHL club or simply Demidov's own will.
The simple junior route, "the sure thing":
Lindstrom and Catton who look like they will turn pro or return to juniors in WHL.
Catton and Demidov are both rising their stocks. Lindstrom injured and Eiserman is what he is. Myself I'd argue that the order as it stands is:
Celebrini
Demidov
Catton
Lindstrom
Connelly
Eiserman
Then there's development to consider, guys going to NCAA:
Celebrini, while a college prospect looks like he will turn pro after just this season due to performance.
Eiserman is joining NCAA BU after decommitting earlier commitment to Minnesota. I admire his commitment.
And Connelly who is committed to NCAA Providence and to me it seems likely he will spend 2 years there.
The Russian factor:
Demidov is under contract for another year in KHL, which carries added risk regarding treatment from KHL club or simply Demidov's own will.
The simple junior route, "the sure thing":
Lindstrom and Catton who look like they will turn pro or return to juniors in WHL.
Rasp
Registered User
- Apr 9, 2019
- 1,386
- 2,000
Demidov is top 5 in talent for sure but an undersized Russian winger will probably mean he drops below the big boys like Lindstrom.
Lots of talk about Catton being the 2nd best C available but Lindstron being 6'3 will mean he gets picked before Catton purely based on that size upside.
Connelly and Eiserman aren't in my top 10. I think we will find a lot of teams will have wildly different draft lists from each other. Bob Mckenzies final ranking is going to be very interesting this year.
IMO the players you listed will be drafted
Celebrini
Lindstrom
Catton
Demidov
Eiserman
Connelly
We will probably only see 5 forwards taken in the top 10 this year based on how many intriguing defenders there are.
I don't know, seems like the forwards are consensus wise in mostly the same order. The defense is what mixes a lot of things up.
I agree Lindstrom probably is currently ahead to most teams because of potential and position. I still find it likely Demidov is the better NHLer and a fit for the Ducks despite draft tendencies size and nationality wise pointing elsewhere.
Also yes, Eiserman especially seems like he will fall outside top 10, I merely listed them to point out how big of a drop off there is.
I still find it very unlikely the Ducks look for RHD, unless it's like Levshunov at 5 or something, obviously without the top 3 forwards there.
WhatTheDuck
9 - 20 - 8
I really think Iginla is trending in the right direction to jump over at least some of those names by draft day
I won't be shocked if he ends up as the 3rd-5th F off the board, somewhere in the 5-10 range. The development track (they call him perhaps the most improved prospect in this class over the last two seasons) and bloodlines will greatly appeal to most teams. Plus a lot of his strengths are what are considered pro traits, the ability to use contact to create separation, IQ and ability to generate/score below the dots.
The talk around him is reading quite similar to McTavish from his draft year, not directly in terms of playing style but by the way things are trending with their stock. I won't be surprised if we see a similar jump by draft day here
Last edited:
I think Tij will be a star. He plays like Minty. Relentless. I hope we draft him if we don’t pick in the top 2. I only have Celi & Demi ahead.
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
Im curious how high he jumps, I wouldn’t mind trading down for him if celebrini and levshunov are off the board…. But I also feel like he’ll randomly be takin higher than expected
Like let’s say Montreal pick lands 9 and we land 3, celebrini and levshunov go 1+2.
Montreal offers us
9th overall + Winnipeg 1st
For
3rd overall + middle 2nd pick
Do you take it?
Personally I wouldn’t. Unless we get Hutson/ Roy on top of that then we can talk
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
Ya I don’t think the difference between the guy at 3 and 9 is huge, but you also give up the opportunity to pick your guy. Not sure what the value difference between 3 and 9 is in a draft like this years
I do think with a big center like lindstrom or big dmen like saliyev teams might really love to get that 3rd pick and pay more
As negligible as it, there’s always that one team willing to give it all to get their guy. Let’s hope it’s to our benefit lol
Hockey Duckie
Registered User
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
MMC
Global Moderator
I would be pretty upset if we took Lindstrom over Demidov
Hockey Duckie
Registered User
That's fair. Picks 2-10 seemingly vary from media scouting to fans. Lindstrom's upside, especially if he plays wing with the Ducks is a huge plus. Byfield didn't look great at center, but at wing, he's higly productive now with the Kings.
Hockey Duckie
Registered User
Conflate that with the Ivan Fedotov situation, then that's taking a huge gamble with a top-5 pick on a Russian despite how good Demidov looks. Michkov, whose talent was behind Bedard and ahead of Carlsson-Fantilli, fell to 7th overall in last year's draft; five other teams passed on a Russian, six teams passed on Michkov.
IIHF says Flyers G Ivan Fedotov, CSKA Moscow violated sanctions
Russian goaltender Ivan Fedotov and the CSKA Moscow have violated sanctions imposed by the IIHF after Fedotov played the first regular season game for CSKA on Sept. 1 despite being suspended from national and international play.
Zegs2sendhelp
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 44,109
- 41,757
I think you’re hoping for a poor man’s byfield with lindstrom… but I don’t think he has anywhere near the talent or athleticism that byfield had.
That being said I don’t really see man superstar potential players in this draft and if lindstrom became a top 6 winger that would be huge given his size and style.
- Status
