Toggle sidebar

Transfer: 2023 Summer Transfer Rumors and Discussion - Closed Window Edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
al secord said:
Neither is size. So my wife tells me.

I can't believe D2D's ignorant attempt at humour made it this far in a transfer thread.
Click to expand...
Its not an attempt at humour. Pogba is a fancy boy, he's lived in France, Italy and the UK. He simply wouldnt give this up under the age of 30 to go play in Canada. This is a hockey board, you would think people understand that Canadian teams struggle to attract UFA talent now imagine comparing Miami to Toronto for a European that has no affiliation to Canada.

If you want to live in fantasy land have at it but there are plenty of other places Pogba would rather go to...
 
Duchene2MacKinnon said:
Its not an attempt at humour. Pogba is a fancy boy, he's lived in France, Italy and the UK. He simply wouldnt give this up under the age of 30 to go play in Canada. This is a hockey board, you would think people understand that Canadian teams struggle to attract UFA talent now imagine comparing Miami to Toronto for a European that has no affiliation to Canada.

If you want to live in fantasy land have at it but there are plenty of other places Pogba would rather go to...
Click to expand...
KJS14 said:
I'm not trying to trash Toronto or anything, and this is all just fantasy talk anyways.

Man United paid Pogba a lot of money to live there. I'm not saying he hated Manchester climate either, but I don't think TFC is going to be significantly outbidding / overpaying on wages compared to other MLS teams.
Click to expand...
You guys have no idea what you're talking about. Look at how much TFC has spent before posting.

You can argue about weather, taxes, marketability in North America, etc but when it comes to wages TFC has had the highest wage bill in MLS before. I'm guessing it's up there now as well with the team they have currently.
 
phisherman said:
You guys have no idea what you're talking about. Look at how much TFC has spent before posting.

You can argue about weather, taxes, marketability in North America, etc but when it comes to wages TFC has had the highest wage bill in MLS before. I'm guessing it's up there now as well with the team they have currently.
Click to expand...
I mean the whole basis of the argument was weather/climate I believe.

Doesn't matter if TFC pays the highest wages if its not a significant upgrade on other MLS teams. If Pogba wanted the highest possible wages, he's not going to the MLS.
 
phisherman said:
You guys have no idea what you're talking about. Look at how much TFC has spent before posting.

You can argue about weather, taxes, marketability in North America, etc but when it comes to wages TFC has had the highest wage bill in MLS before. I'm guessing it's up there now as well with the team they have currently.
Click to expand...
Where did I say anything about wages?

In the winter Canadians travel to Miami to ask the weather... no one in Miami is travelling to Canada.
 
phisherman said:
You make a comment about Canadian teams struggling to attract UFAs.

Canadian teams struggling to attract UFAs has to do with taxes. Not wages.
Click to expand...
That's all well and good but I didn't say otherwise. I merely said they struggle to attract players...
 
The weather didn’t stand in the way of Toronto getting Bernardeschi, Insigne, Giovinco who were used to beautiful Italian days. The weather didn’t stand in the way of Montreal getting Drogba or Nesta.

I don’t think that Pogba is going to come to MLS, but if he’s interested in that then I have no doubt Toronto will be a big player going for him. Toronto has historically been one of the bigger DP draws.

It’s not as if we’re talking about Winnipeg or Edmonton here.

Duchene2MacKinnon said:
Where did I say anything about wages?

In the winter Canadians travel to Miami to ask the weather... no one in Miami is travelling to Canada.
Click to expand...
This logic is bulletproof
 
Toronto is a meh city; great food scene and some stuff to do, but it comes across as boring for a major metropolitan city. If I was a player in Canada, Quebec City would be my choice of residence.
 
Duchene2MacKinnon said:
Where did I say anything about wages?

In the winter Canadians travel to Miami to ask the weather... no one in Miami is travelling to Canada.
Click to expand...

Who voluntarily travels to Manchester instead of London?

You're acting like Toronto is a third world city compared to Manchester, a place where Pogba has already chosen to live twice. Yes obviously wages had a lot to do with that, but if climate was the only thing he cared about he probably wouldn't have left France in the first place as a teenager or left Turin for Manchester.

Toronto is a solid international city. Yea the winter sucks, but he'd miss most of that and there's plenty of culture around to keep someone entertained.

Sure if he's exclusively looking for an early retirement team, Miami wins, but there hasn't really been anything to indicate that all he cares about is relaxing on the beach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jersey Fresh
You haven’t followed Pogba closely if you think he’s choosing Canada over Miami. Or LA for that matter.

If he comes to MLS, it won’t be for the work. Work will be part time, behind Pogba the brand.
 
East Coast Bias said:
You haven’t followed Pogba closely if you think he’s choosing Canada over Miami. Or LA for that matter.

If he comes to MLS, it won’t be for the work. Work will be part time, behind Pogba the brand.
Click to expand...

Wow. Pogba “the brand”. I guess the void left by Kmart had to be filled by somebody.
 
If Toronto was paying more, sure... he likely would go there. But if Pogba was coming (and once again, this is all stupid, because he's likely not) there are other clubs who would bid similar.


I don't even know how it's a debate that a 30 year old, black, millionaire, international athlete would prefer to go to Miami over Toronto. None the less a debate that's seemingly carrying on for multiple pages. Some Canadians are crazy pants if they think it's even a discussion. It has a lot less to do with how cold or not cold Toronto is. Miami has the beach and clubs. And no income tax. If the money is equal (and once again, this is all ridiculous), it's not a hard choice.
 
hatterson said:
I think it’s pretty clear the climate is better in Miami, but it’s not like Toronto is an arctic research station. Especially since he lived in Manchester for half a decade and that’s not a city known for its wonderful tropical climate.
Click to expand...
Yeah and it's not like Juve is rocking a Mediterranean climate either.
 
S E P H said:
Los Angeles is a perfect place for Auba and his bling lifestyle of rich and famous. Best and most favourite Arsenal player in the past fifteen years tied with Cazorla.
Click to expand...
Really eh? I definitely liked him @ Arsenal but don't think he would be in my top 10 favs of the last decade or so.
 
hatterson said:
Who voluntarily travels to Manchester instead of London?

You're acting like Toronto is a third world city compared to Manchester, a place where Pogba has already chosen to live twice. Yes obviously wages had a lot to do with that, but if climate was the only thing he cared about he probably wouldn't have left France in the first place as a teenager or left Turin for Manchester.

Toronto is a solid international city. Yea the winter sucks, but he'd miss most of that and there's plenty of culture around to keep someone entertained.

Sure if he's exclusively looking for an early retirement team, Miami wins, but there hasn't really been anything to indicate that all he cares about is relaxing on the beach.
Click to expand...
Manchester United is a huge football brand. TFC is in the grand scheme of things. That's a huge difference.

If Pogba comes to MLS, it is going to be Miami or LAFC.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom