It is kind of crazy to look back at just how dominant of a run that was and yet you still had some doom and gloom during it.
I think it’s messed with the idea/expectation of a contender as well. Avs we’re probably done being on that level after the cup unless they got lucky with a few players. Cap simply makes it very hard to have that dominant of a cup team. If we win again it’ll be far more up and down.
Yea there's a LOT of sementic intertwined in this whole never-ending dispute about window/cup contender status/objective vs realist vs pessimist vs rosy glasses, etc...
At one extreme, for a select few, the bar seems set very high. The Avs need to be a top 2-3 team in the league, with no glaring weakness and very little uncertainty at important positions in order to meet the bar, otherwise the window is possibly already closed and the team is at risk of sinking fast. This group usually views itself as objective and realist.
At the other end. the bar is very low. As long as we have MacKinnon + Makar + Rantanen we will be contenders and the window will be open. They are usually calle dthe homers / rosy glasses.
And then +90% of this board is somewhere in between... fighting on semantics like "window closing", "Cup contender status", etc...
This has taken so much room that you now see takes that are very Dater-like : I like what the Avs did, they can easily be a top 3 team in the league and win the Cup, but there are risks, and they could very well miss the playoffs and realize that their window has already closed... I believe that this is a bit extreme, but not completely crazy at all. I think the floor is higher than that, as demonstrated last year when all hell broke lose yet we still won the division. But that's where sementics kicks-in again. What were we last year? We won the division but lost in the first round. Were we a cup contender or a team with a closed window. If we have a progression but a smallish one this year in the regular season. Meaning division champ again but with consistency issues with RyJo and Drouin for example. What will we be ? Without hindsight based on the playoff performance ?