To elaborate on why I think the 3rd line is a problem, it's because they don't have a big enough impact AND due to their salaries we can't afford a #2C, especially if Landy comes back. In a vacuum I love what they bring, the issue is that they can't be elevated in the lineup even temporary.
IMO, a $4 mil #3C that plays 12-13 minutes a night is a luxury, and one we can't afford.
I really don't think so if we were balanced properly.
The problem IMO isn't spending too much money on 3C, it's spending too much money on #3/4/5 Dmen and on the wing in general(With Landy in the fold at least).
Particularly on Defense right now, $13.35M on your 3-5 Dmen is simply way to much. That number shouldn't be above $10M and honestly I'd prefer it closer to $8M especially with our top pairing being as strong as it is.
To me in a perfectly balanced roster where we keep our core guys you'd have:
$7M(Landy)- $12.6M(Mack) - $9.25M(Mikko)
$4.5M(Lehky) - $8M - $6M(Nuke)
$1.5M - $4M(Wood) - $1.5M
$0.8M - $0.8M - $0.8M
$7M(Toews) - $9M(Makar)
$3M - $3M
$1.5M - $0.8M
$3M
$1M
A roster with those constructions roughly would be about $85M next year, with $2.5M to fill out extra skaters or for some nuance on these guys(IE Nuke being $6.125M instead of $6M, Toews $7.25M, etc).
But they're simply spending too much money on middle pairing Dmen and overall too much money on the wings. It's a lot of spots where $500-$1M overpays start to add up quickly.