It has been a while since I commented or have read this thread. On that note Welcome all PEI parents - I see the island is strong and well!!! On the past discussions in regards to the prep schools, I think those that went to the US made a great decision in the end of the day. Of the Atlantic prep schools I like RNS. They are a strong team however you are reading too much into their wins against the Vitos and the Monctonian. In league play I expect they would be in the top 4 teams in U18, The Mount more middle of the pack. KES has a few good players as well, but are more of a mixed can. Prep schools I feel get the most potential out of a kid right now.
I'm not sure about the future - but you can't beat the regiment these kids go through. Scouts understand the differences and it's pretty easy to account for so I don't think draft wise it's a big factor. Prep schools are usually a family choice, busy parents, financially well off, sometimes it's a club choice as well where some clubs are not "great" from a development and character perspective and that tips the scale.
I do think kids get a lot of benefit from staying in a prep school for there entire high school. I hate seeing kids leave - there was a kid with a prep school last year that left this year to play in NS and I had him on the cusp of the Q Draft as a forward after they transitioned him last year and was expecting to recommend him as overager in the mid rounds this year, but he went back to his club team and has completely fallen off the radar and switched back to defense which made no sense given his attributes. His prep school had put him in a place to succeed I thought converting him to a forward and this basically put him to a Junior B plateau.
In regards to the U16 AAA league, I saw a few games. I think there are some good players. Was hoping to see the best of the best of the league in the East Coast Ice Jam. I don't think the roster was published but I did recall a discussion from December and hearing the names, Kerr, Jobes, Hickey, Pettipas, Lavoie, Dowden-Haines, Kerr, Johnson. Would like too see the full roster as these names are just the ones that are familiar to me that I could recall, not an indication of ranking. This roster would be the folks to watch for in late rounds/late birthday sleeper picks etc. Most of the times these kids have not had the same development time as the major players which leads to a bit more upside when playing the lottery as well.