Which makes the point surely, they were not at their very best and we didn’t win. Both are elite, franchise players and that’s the difference between elite and generational. The generational guys are consistently at the top of their games, every season. The elite players, all have the occasional dips in play.
Doughty and Kopitar (& Quick) were the players that took us over the top in 2012/14. Of course other players had great moments but their consistent elite level throughout both runs means the highlights from Carter, Richard, Williams etc were match winning contributions rather than consolatory highlights.
I don’t believe you can’t see that, as you generally seem to understand the game. I can only conclude that you're deliberately underselling their contributions, I’m just not sure if it’s to win the argument or some other bias against them.