I would expect Dumo to be around $3.25-$3.5m. Schultz will get around $4.25m-$4.75m in my books.
For me;
Guentzel-Crosby-Sheary
Rust-Malkin-Kessel
Hagelin-XXX-Hornqvist
Wilson-XXX-Reaves
Kuhnhackl/Rowney
I would make the 3C Jordan Weal and the 4th C either Rowney or, if possible, Boyle. Probably looking at $750k or so for Weal and $2m for Boyle. Would extend Sheary, Dumo and Schultz. We'd look like below;
FORWARDS (14)
Right wing: C. Sheary ($2,750,000) - P. Kessel ($6,800,000) - P. Hornqvist ($4,250,000) - R. Reaves ($1,125,000) - T. Kuhnhackl ($625,000)
Centre: S. Crosby ($8,700,000) - E. Malkin ($9,500,000) - J. Weal ($750,000) - B. Boyle ($2,000,000) - C. Rowney ($612,500)
Left wing: J. Guentzel ($734,167) - B. Rust ($640,000) - C. Hagelin ($4,000,000) - S. Wilson ($625,000)
DEFENSE (6)
Right: K. Letang ($7,250,000) - J. Schultz ($4,500,000) - C. Ruhwedel ($650,000)
Left: B. Dumoulin ($3,500,000) - O. Määttä ($4,083,333) - I. Cole ($2,100,000)
GOALTENDER (2)
M. Murray ($3,750,000) - T. Jarry ($630,833)
DETAILS
Roster Size: 22
NHL Salary Cap: $75,000,000
Cap Hit: $69,575,833
Cap Space: $5,424,167
For me;
Guentzel-Crosby-Sheary
Rust-Malkin-Kessel
Hagelin-XXX-Hornqvist
Wilson-XXX-Reaves
Kuhnhackl/Rowney
I would make the 3C Jordan Weal and the 4th C either Rowney or, if possible, Boyle. Probably looking at $750k or so for Weal and $2m for Boyle. Would extend Sheary, Dumo and Schultz. We'd look like below;
FORWARDS (14)
Right wing: C. Sheary ($2,750,000) - P. Kessel ($6,800,000) - P. Hornqvist ($4,250,000) - R. Reaves ($1,125,000) - T. Kuhnhackl ($625,000)
Centre: S. Crosby ($8,700,000) - E. Malkin ($9,500,000) - J. Weal ($750,000) - B. Boyle ($2,000,000) - C. Rowney ($612,500)
Left wing: J. Guentzel ($734,167) - B. Rust ($640,000) - C. Hagelin ($4,000,000) - S. Wilson ($625,000)
DEFENSE (6)
Right: K. Letang ($7,250,000) - J. Schultz ($4,500,000) - C. Ruhwedel ($650,000)
Left: B. Dumoulin ($3,500,000) - O. Määttä ($4,083,333) - I. Cole ($2,100,000)
GOALTENDER (2)
M. Murray ($3,750,000) - T. Jarry ($630,833)
DETAILS
Roster Size: 22
NHL Salary Cap: $75,000,000
Cap Hit: $69,575,833
Cap Space: $5,424,167