Appleyard
Registered User
Meh I'm not surprised. Too many defensive misreads that end up in the back of the net. Can't have that in tight checking games.
People always forget teams often win game 3-2, 2-1 in these tourneys. It's playoff style Hockey. That's why Canada generally takes its best defensive forwards. Guys like Bergeron, Carter, Getzlaf, Toews who maybe aren't elite talents offensively like Giroux or Hall, but they NEVER make bad reads. Put a team of 13 forwards and 7 D that do that and it's no wonder Canada is almost impossible to score on.
Guys like Hall and Giroux are more valuable to their NHL teams because the offense they provide is so essential. But Canada first and foremost wants to be basically perfect defensively. That's why team guys like Carter, Bergeron, Crosby, Toews, Getzlaf are there. That's Canada's M.O., I know HF doesn't like it, but it's not surprising.
Good luck scoring on Holtby/Price when Canada throw out the vast majority of the best two-way players in the world. That's their philosophy.
But Giroux IS a very good defensive player. And one of the best playoff performers amongst active NHLers. And has an excellent international record.
His CF% rel since 2013-14 would be the 2nd best on this team. (after Bergeron)
He has played arguably the 2nd toughest minutes of any of the forwards selected in that time. (after Bergeron... though Getzlaf has played similar to Giroux too.)
He is an excellent PKer.
He is not some offense only guy... in fact his defense is arguably better than all but ~2-3 of the guys selected so far!