Your all time team, starting in 1990, for your favorite team

[GreeningOil]

Missing B. Mironov, who was tremendous for a few years in the mid-to-late 90s.

I honestly never have heard of him! Good add

 

[glenngineer]

Landeskog - MacKinnon - Rantanen
Tanguay - Stastny - Hejduk
Deadmarsh- O'Reilly - Nolan
Duchene - Drury- Vrbata

Byram - Makar
Boychuk - Barrie
Liles - Shattenkirk

Thibault
Aebischer

Forward group is amazing, defense and goaltending are embarrassing

Pair them with Nashville and you have a complete roster.

 

[BrickNHL]

Lindros.

Has to be developed by the team too

 

[Chet Manley]

Fan of team founded in 1990 arbitrarily selects starting in 1990.

 

[Chainshot]

The hang-up on "developed by" makes a few guys leave the list since they moved on before finishing their development (Brandon Hagel, Cory Sarich, Dennis Wideman, Zack Kassian come to mind).

So... instead, just going with who was there:




Thomas Vanek - Jack Eichel - Sam Reinhart
Tyler Ennis - Derek Roy - Jason Pominville
Marcus Foligno - Casey Mittelstadt - Drew Stafford
Danny Paille - Dylan Cousins - Victor Olofsson
Spare: Paul Gaustad -

Rasmus Dahlin - Tyler Myers
Jay McKee - Rasmus Ristolainen
Henrik Tallinder -
Jake McCabe

Ryan Miller
Linus Ullmark
Martin Biron

 

[Golden_Jet]

Fan of team founded in 1990 arbitrarily selects starting in 1990.

Tbf , there was a lot of teams added in the 90’s, not to mention they started 2-3 years later. 92/93 on ice.
This gives a more equal footing for all the new teams, rather than picking Maurice Richard, Bobby Hull and Gordie Howe. Who were ages ago.

Sure you can pick any parameters you want,
Poster went with drafted players this time instead of the played for team option.

Start a new poll, with whatever starting year you would like then.

 

[The Great Mighty Poo]

Jake Guentzel- Sidney Crosby-Jaromir Jagr
Martin Straka-Evgeni Malkin-Bryan Rust
Markus Naslund-Jordan Staal-Alexsei Morozov
Shawn McEachren-Max Talbot-Colby Armstrong

(Oskar Sundqvist,Ryan Malone)

Olli Maata-Kris Letang
Chris Tamer-Michal Rozival
Joe Melichar-Robert Bortuzzo

(Alex Goligoski, Ryan Whitney)

MAF
Matt Murray

 

[Golden_Jet]

As a Pens fan, so many ways this can go and not have a wrong answer, And do a fantasy lineup all day but my stab:

Mario Lemieux-Ron Francis- Jaromir Jagr
Jake Guentzel-Sidney Crosby-Evgeni Malkin
Kevin Stevens-Jordan Staal-Patrik Hornqvist
Bob Errey-Bryan Trottier-Joey Mullen

(The extra forward is a wild crap shoot since we had so many to pick from its almost impossible to pick 2 and at best it'll come off as popularity contest)

Paul Coffey-Larry Murphy
Ulf Samuelsson-Kris Letang
Sergi Gonchar-Darrius Kasparaitis
(Brooks Orpik, Brian Dumoulin)

Tom Barrasso
Ken Wregget
(MAF)

some weren’t Pens draft picks.

 

[PensandCaps]

Guentzel-Crosby-Jagr
Naslund-Malkin-Rust
Malone-Straka-Morozov
Armstrong-Staal-Kennedy

Scuderi-Letang
Orpik-Goligoski
Whitney-Bortuzzo

Fleury
Murray

Pretty spot on, probably swap out Bortz for Rozsival.

 

[bambamcam4ever]

Not cool crafting the rules so I can't include Lindros, despite him not playing an NHL game for another team before joining the Flyers.

Also, it's not an all-time team if it doesn't include the entire franchise's history, which again cuts out a ton of names that actually belong here.

That said:

Giroux-Forsberg-Gagne
van Riemsdyk-Couturier-Konecny
Farabee-Carter-Renberg
Laughton-Richards-Williams
Lindblom

Sanheim-Yushkevich
Provorov-Gostisbehere
York-Therien
Niinimaa


I refuse to consider the player who should go here on talent alone, so
Cechmanek
Boucher

This is a nightmare for the Flyers, who have the patience of a magpie and rarely have a full draft. Most of our best picks only played for us for about 3 years before we traded them off. I'm limiting myself to people who played at least 150 NHL games, and at least 100 for the Flyers. (Forsberg is here on a technicality; he played exactly 100 games as a Flyer, though later in his career. If I can't get Lindros, I'm taking him.)

Forsberg was not developed by the Flyers

Guentzel-Crosby-Jagr
Naslund-Malkin-Rust
Malone-Straka-Morozov
Armstrong-Staal-Kennedy

Scuderi-Letang
Orpik-Goligoski
Whitney-Bortuzzo

Fleury
Murray

Maatta should be over Bortuzzo certainly

 

[The Great Mighty Poo]

some weren’t Pens draft picks.

Yeah, miss read it, edited it now

 

[MarotteMarauder]

They have to be drafted no earlier than 1990, and by your team.

You have guys that break both rules.

I missed that part in the title, my bad

 

[FerrisRox]

No Brian Savage? Mark Streit?

Oh well, seems Savage was developed in Miami. But that would disqualify Koivu as well

Who would you remove to include Savage and Streit?

 

[bleedgreen]

Sanderson - Aho - Cole
Svech - Estaal - Kapanen
Skinner - Lindholm - Jarvis
Ladd - Vasicek - Necas


Pronger - Faulk
Slavin - Pesce
Hanifin - Mailk

Giguere
Ward

*fixed

 

[Golden_Jet]

Shanahan - Francis - Cole
Aho - RBA - Williams
Sanderson - Estaal - Svech
G Roberts - Primeau - Kapanen

Pronger - Coffey
Slavin - Pesce
Wesley - Hedican

Giguere
Burke
Ward

First post
Rules are the players must have been drafted and developed by your team

Earliest you can go back is 1990

 

[Chet Manley]

Tbf , there was a lot of teams added in the 90’s, not to mention they started 2-3 years later. 92/93 on ice.
This gives a more equal footing for all the new teams, rather than picking Maurice Richard, Bobby Hull and Gordie Howe. Who were ages ago.

Sure you can pick any parameters you want,
Poster went with drafted players this time instead of the played for team option.

Start a new poll, with whatever starting year you would like then.

I'm not going to start a poll structured in a way that adds restrictions meant to have zero affect on myself. Not that self-centred.

 

[Lazlo Hollyfeld]

Henrik Zetterberg - Pavel Datsyuk - Tomas Holmström
Johan Franzen - Dylan Larkin - Martin Lapointe
Slava Kozlov - Valtteri Filppula - Lucas Raymond
Tyler Bertuzzi - Keith Primeau - Darren McCarty

Jiri Fischer - Moritz Seider
Niklas Kronwall - Filip Hronek
Jonathan Ericsson - Mathieu Dandenault

Chris Osgood
Jimmy Howard

Zetterberg-Datsyuk-Raymond
Kozlov-Primeau-Franzen
Nyquist-Larkin-Bertuzzi
Lapointe-Helm-McCarty

Kronwall-Seider
Fischer-Hronek
Ericsson-Smith

Osgood
Howard


Hard to do with so many shit picks in 34 years.

Good lists. I'd probably go with Quincey over Smith or Dandenault.

 

[Beukeboom Fan]

Stutzle - Redden - Alfredson
Tkachuk - Yashin - Hossa
Stone - Bonk - Havlat
Demitra - Fisher - Neil

Sanderson - Karlsson
Phillips - Volchenkov
Sanderson - Chabot

Emery
Lehner

Edit - stupid on Chara and Redden.

FYI, but you have Sanderson listed twice.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Edit - stupid on Chara and Redden.

FYI, but you have Sanderson listed twice.

Wrf happened lol
I’ll fix that Redden should be Spezza
Sens didn’t draft Redden or Chara

Redden was traded for Berard, even though neither played for their drafted teams. So didn’t include Redden, even though first NHL game was for Sens,
If Reds can count, then I’d add him.

 

[dire wolf]

The hang-up on "developed by" makes a few guys leave the list since they moved on before finishing their development (Brandon Hagel, Cory Sarich, Dennis Wideman, Zack Kassian come to mind).

So... instead, just going with who was there:




Thomas Vanek - Jack Eichel - Sam Reinhart
Tyler Ennis - Derek Roy - Jason Pominville
Marcus Foligno - Casey Mittelstadt - Drew Stafford
Danny Paille - Dylan Cousins - Victor Olofsson
Spare: Paul Gaustad -

Rasmus Dahlin - Tyler Myers
Jay McKee - Rasmus Ristolainen
Henrik Tallinder -
Jake McCabe

Ryan Miller
Linus Ullmark
Martin Biron

Replace Paille and Olofsson with May and Barnaby (for more fun and excitement)
Extra spares: Afinogenov, CuBro

Replace Risto with Brian Campbell and add Smehlik to the D. Sekera as extra spare. I included Zadorov and McNabb on my list, but I could see the argument they weren't with Buffalo long enough.

 

[bleedgreen]

First post
Rules are the players must have been drafted and developed by your team

Earliest you can go back is 1990

Party pooper. I actually knew that when I got started but just got carried away.

Ps it’s fixed.

 

[Minnesota Knudsens]

I’m actually just here to enjoy the “rules” mistakes and controversy. It’s HF gold, Jerry!

 

[Mogo]

could add zach hyman in there

I only kept it as I think the OP intended. Players your team picked and who excelled with your team. Hyman didnt do shit here

 

[Beukeboom Fan]

Wrf happened lol
I’ll fix that Redden should be Spezza
Sens didn’t draft Redden or Chara

Redden was traded for Bedard, even though neither played for their drafted teams. So didn’t include Redden, even though first NHL game was for Sens,
If Reds can count, then I’d add him.

My edit was that I was totally stupid forgetting the Redden/Berard trade way back in the day, and that Chara was in the Yashin deal. One of those weird deals that makes this type of exercise more challenging. The Isle were such train-wreck back then I must be blocking those deals out of my mind! ;o)

 

[PaulD]

Habs ..... started this
The best 4 centerman "since 1990"
Koivu
Muller
Carbonneau
Suzuki ??

to sad and pointless to go on.