Worst takes you've had on this site?

[ManofSteel55]

Its not Vancouver homerism, its the fact that he is no better than someone like Myers. He is a liability on defense and his offense is not that good either. If Nurse was a good top 4 dman then Oilers would not have that big of a problem on D.

It absolutely is Vancouver homerism. Or Oiler hate - it certainly isn't objective, you've proven that time and time again you can't be objective about the Oilers.

The Oilers didn't have a problem on D last year with Nurse anchoring the 2nd pair. The Oilers are sort of out a lot of systemic stuff right now, its not all on the defensemen, and certainly not on any one player. Tying it to Nurse alone is pretty ridiculous.

 

[jackjohnson]

It absolutely is Vancouver homerism. Or Oiler hate - it certainly isn't objective, you've proven that time and time again you can't be objective about the Oilers.

The Oilers didn't have a problem on D last year with Nurse anchoring the 2nd pair. The Oilers are sort of out a lot of systemic stuff right now, its not all on the defensemen, and certainly not on any one player. Tying it to Nurse alone is pretty ridiculous.

You can make a poll here and ask which dman is better? Nurse or Hronek. At least we will know for sure

 

[King Woodballs]

I haven’t had any bad takes. It’s everyone else’s that are no good

 

[stl76]

There was a point prior to 2019 I was doubling down on the idea that the Blues should trade Binnington and keep Copley. That seriously might be my worst.

 

[Aashir Mallik]

I thought Matthews was the 1B to Mcdavids 1A akin to Sid and Ovi after Matthews’s hart year

Boy was I wrong

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

That Wahlstrom was going to become a Stamkos.

 

[jackjohnson]

HFboard takes = No Good

 

[jackjohnson]

It absolutely is Vancouver homerism. Or Oiler hate - it certainly isn't objective, you've proven that time and time again you can't be objective about the Oilers.

The Oilers didn't have a problem on D last year with Nurse anchoring the 2nd pair. The Oilers are sort of out a lot of systemic stuff right now, its not all on the defensemen, and certainly not on any one player. Tying it to Nurse alone is pretty ridiculous.

Who is better as a dman? Hronek or Nurse?

So which of these dman would you take on your team if salaries were equal??

forums.hfboards.com

 

[NotCommitted]

I don't know if I ever voiced these out loud, but I thought Rantanen was overhyped and would become just another big bodied middle-six winger. On the other hand I thought Kakko was a sure pick, destined to be a very good 2nd liner at worst. Hellebuyck maybe becoming an average NHL starter with luck etc...

 

[ManofSteel55]

Who is better as a dman? Hronek or Nurse?

So which of these dman would you take on your team if salaries were equal??

forums.hfboards.com

Congratulations, you made a poll. That means nothing considering most HF'ers don't see either of these guys play more than a couple of times a year. Nurse might be overpaid, but he's not nearly as bad as most people think. Easily the most underrated player on HF.

You can make a poll here and ask which dman is better? Nurse or Hronek. At least we will know for sure

Why would we know for sure based on a poll of HF? The guy sheltered by the reigning Norris trophy winner getting prime offensive opportunities, or the the guy carrying #7 defensemen on his line getting a bulk of the defensive zone starts. Polls can be fun - but they aren't exactly evidence like you are claiming.

 

[jackjohnson]

Congratulations, you made a poll. That means nothing considering most HF'ers don't see either of these guys play more than a couple of times a year. Nurse might be overpaid, but he's not nearly as bad as most people think. Easily the most underrated player on HF.


Why would we know for sure based on a poll of HF? The guy sheltered by the reigning Norris trophy winner getting prime offensive opportunities, or the the guy carrying #7 defensemen on his line getting a bulk of the defensive zone starts. Polls can be fun - but they aren't exactly evidence like you are claiming.

You are so biased that its hard to argue with you. Nurse is worst than players like Soucy and even Myers. He is not a good dman.

 

[All Mod Cons]

The whole Laine vs Matthews thing has to be high up for many people.

 

[Bring Bak Damphousse]

Hated Draisaitl being picked over Bennet, thought he was going to bust.

Yeah, im never going to be gm,.

Oof, I was convinced we were missing out on a franchise center when we drafted Price over Brule.