Will Ovi breaking Gretzky's goalscoring record change or influence his legacy?

PaulD

71,73,76,77,78,79,86,93
Feb 4, 2016
31,469
18,532
Dundas
Also didn't Gretzky notably say something along the lines of, paraphrased, being bored scoring, and he changed his game to be more of the guy that setup the plays?

Like Gretzky purposefully tried to stop scoring as many goals himself to become a better playmaker.

Maybe I'm misremembering the quote, but I felt like he said something like that. Someone please correct me here.

(not diminishing what any other player has done, but Gretzky was definitely something else)
Gretz went into the 85-86 season thinking he could "average two assists a game, but my goals will drop". That season he recorded 163 assists. Goal scoring dropped from 73 to 52.
 

saffronleaf

Registered User
May 17, 2011
26,392
28,797
Toronto, ON
His legacy will already be that he is the greatest goal scorer ever.

Beating Gretzky's record would more just cement the legacy, rather than change anything about it.

I think this is true of everyone who watched Ovechkin play.

But a few generations from now, when there's nobody alive who watched him play, there will be greater weight placed on the numbers and records.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drakon

Hockey 4 Life

Registered User
Feb 10, 2012
6,272
3,260
People have been saying this for the last 5 years and he has always turned it around throughout the season. It will eventually happen but we will see. Elite goal scorers are streaky. They go ice cold and then get a bunch.
Certainly very possible but the way that ovi and the caps currently look it doesn't look good. Ovi looks done. Hope I'm wrong cause I like ovi.
 

Calderon

Registered User
Mar 24, 2006
1,198
812
Certainly a slow start for a player that has had several very hot starts. I read somewhere recently that Ovi has had multiple starts of 10 goals in first 11 games. Granted, he could still reach those very numbers if he'll heat up fast.

This season marks only the second time Ovi's gone goalless thru the first three games (2012-13). How'd it progress back then? Rocket and Hart.
 

Ms Maggie

Registered User
Apr 11, 2017
2,764
1,888
Crosby is a great player but, outside of pens fans remembering his cups, what is so memorable about his career? Any significant records? Not really. 2 rosses which has been done by many players including his own team mate. 2 rockets is nothing memorable. 2 harts equalled/surpassed by many players including OV in his own era. There have been many "legacies" like Crosby: great captain, won individual trophies, won cups, best player in the game for a few years, etc. Happened many times before, will happen again. OV on the other hand will have the most goals ever, most rockets ever, most 50/45/40/30 goal seasons ever, most PPG goals ever, etc. That's a way bigger and more memorable legacy than whatever it is Crosby did.
The whole point is to win cups. The WHOLE point. You queer for individual records? Follow tennis or golf.

If you had a choice--Caps win one more Cup before O retires, or he breaks the goal record--which do you choose?
 
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm

Alexander the Gr8

Registered User
May 2, 2013
32,036
13,762
Toronto
The whole point is to win cups. The WHOLE point. You queer for individual records? Follow tennis or golf.

If you had a choice--Caps win one more Cup before O retires, or he breaks the goal record--which do you choose?

My choice, why not both? The two aren’t mutually exclusive.
 

YippieKaey

How you gonna do hockey like that?
Apr 2, 2012
3,022
2,563
Stockholm Sweden
I never thought of it like that and I think it kinda gets lost...I mean, look at the stats and Gretz is STILL 114 goals ahead?? If things stay linear (they don't), he will have needed to take 1859 more shots than Gretzky merely to tie him.

Flip things around and keeping all things equal (we don't deal in hyperbole at HF do we ;)), in the shots it "would" take OV to get to 894 (6947) , Gretzky "could" have scored 1220.


View attachment 592515

This is not how statistical analysis is done. This is cherrypicking stats. In Gretzkys days, scoring was way easier due to, amongst other things, much smaller goalies, hence there were less shots required for scoring a goal. If you want to call this analysis you need to include a "shots neeeded per game" and "goals per game per team" criteria. Otherwise, you're willfully omitting statistics that will change the picture you are trying to present which would get you an F in statistics class:)
 

SoundAndFury

Registered User
May 28, 2012
11,899
5,936
The whole point is to win cups. The WHOLE point. You queer for individual records? Follow tennis or golf.
Yes, just imagine acknowledging individual greatness in team sports. Appalling. WHOLY POINTLESS, even.

I would take 2 TIME STANLEY CUP CHAMPION Colin Fraser over Ovi any time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drakon

Calderon

Registered User
Mar 24, 2006
1,198
812
The whole point is to win cups. The WHOLE point. You queer for individual records? Follow tennis or golf.

If you had a choice--Caps win one more Cup before O retires, or he breaks the goal record--which do you choose?
Ok then, imagine being an NHL player. Would you rather win 4 Cups as a 2nd or 3rd liner and win no individual awards or win 2 Cups as a franchise player, maybe one Smythe and a humble assortment of individual awards? With these career arcs there are bound to be certain salary implications which you can count in or ignore as per your wish. Sure the choice changes drastically if the franchise player doesn't end up winning any cups, but if winning cups is the WHOLE point, there's no way you'd choose the latter career, right? After all, 4 is twice the amount of 2, a whole 100 % more. Call me crazy but I have some ambition and alike qualities and would choose the franchise player arc 100 times out of 100.

And just to clarify, I'm not talking about Ovi here at all.
 

Ms Maggie

Registered User
Apr 11, 2017
2,764
1,888
Ok then, imagine being an NHL player. Would you rather win 4 Cups as a 2nd or 3rd liner and win no individual awards or win 2 Cups as a franchise player, maybe one Smythe and a humble assortment of individual awards? With these career arcs there are bound to be certain salary implications which you can count in or ignore as per your wish. Sure the choice changes drastically if the franchise player doesn't end up winning any cups, but if winning cups is the WHOLE point, there's no way you'd choose the latter career, right? After all, 4 is twice the amount of 2, a whole 100 % more. Call me crazy but I have some ambition and alike qualities and would choose the franchise player arc 100 times out of 100.

And just to clarify, I'm not talking about Ovi here at all.
As the player, sure.

As a fan? No contest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm

Ms Maggie

Registered User
Apr 11, 2017
2,764
1,888
Yes, just imagine acknowledging individual greatness in team sports. Appalling. WHOLY POINTLESS, even.

I would take 2 TIME STANLEY CUP CHAMPION Colin Fraser over Ovi any time.
Of course individual achievement matters.

I don't understand why Ovi breaking Gretzky's record diminishes Gretzky. Or Crosby for that matter, which is weirdly tangential. Which was the essence of the post to which I responded.

And individual achievement minus team accomplishment I still maintain is less than in tandem with it. Ask Dan Marino.
 

wetcoast

Registered User
Nov 20, 2018
24,825
11,665
Certainly a slow start for a player that has had several very hot starts. I read somewhere recently that Ovi has had multiple starts of 10 goals in first 11 games. Granted, he could still reach those very numbers if he'll heat up fast.

This season marks only the second time Ovi's gone goalless thru the first three games (2012-13). How'd it progress back then? Rocket and Hart.

He is getting extreme optimal opportunity with 92% offensive zone starts at ES and 89% overall and 6 MPG on the PP, he will get his goals but he is done as an elite player 5 on 5 or heck even as a good one really.

This has been a trend with a slight blip to start last season for several seasons now.

My guess is that he will stick around for the goal record but the way he gets it isn't going to help his legacy at all it's already set as a top 15ish forward of all time with an argument for a little lower/higher depending on POV.
 

Ad

Ad

Ad