It's not a 2006 thing. It's broader.
Could Howe have broken 894 if he had his rejuvenation in the NHL instead of the WHA? Absolutely. If Howe is born 5 years later and peaks in a higher scoring era he beats 894.
Was Lemieux skilled enough to best 894? Absolutely. He hit 690 while missing half his prime.
Could Bossy or Hull beaten it in different circumstances? Possibly. Bossy didn't play his back half. Hull scored over 900 major pro regular season goals.
That Gretzky held the record was a testament to peaking in a high scoring era and having circumstances not go the competition's way.
No one was beating Gretzky's assist record. Give Howe a high scoring ers he doesn't do it. Give Lemieux perfect health he doesn't do it.
Look at it on a per 20 year basis.
Goals: 45 goals a year does it. This total is bested every year, but no one (until Ovechkin) had the longevity.
Assists: 98 assists per year. Only Gretzky, Lemieux, and Orr ever hit this in a single year let alone 20 years in a row.
Points: 143 points. McDavid was the first to hit this number in 27 years. Only 9 players have even hit this in a season.
The fact that Ovechkin is going to beat it while spending half his career in a low scoring era is testament to it.
Howe hit 800 despite peaking in one of the lowest scoring eras ever. Jagr hit 766 despite his Capitals whining tour/jumping ship to the KHL.
Look at it this way. Jagr scored 85% as many goals as Gretzky. But only 67% as many points or 58% as many assists.
It's an all time record. Of course it's not easy. But it should have never been viewed as unbreakable.
You’re making massive assumptions about many many things.
1st, is that you’re tying this to era as if Gretzky wasn’t the driving force in his own era and its scoring. Without Gretzky, there is no ‘high scoring era’ in the 80’s.
People who push era adjusted stats or reference ‘high scoring era’s’ don’t seem to understand this.
Compare the 60’s to today.
The high scoring 80’s started and ended with Gretzky’s career.
The other biggest assumption you’re making is ‘what if’. Similar to era arguments, but different.
‘What if bossy scored 50 goals 19 years in a row?’ Well, he didn’t even comes close. He got about half way there.
‘What if Lemieux was healthy?’ Well, he wasn’t. That’s part of it. How can you stay healthy for 20 years and score like Gretzky?
Gretzky couldn’t even stay healthy, but he was scoring at such an incredible pace for the first half of his career, that a pedestrian back half doesn’t matter to his stats.
If Ovechkin had a second half of his career in goal scoring like Gretzky did, we wouldn’t even be talking about him.
None of this is appropriate to be massaging or pointing at ‘what if’.
No one thinks Matthews is going to be able to catch Gretzky, because the idea is literally crazy. No one thought Ovechkin would get this close, because that was crazy.
Let me play the game you’re playing. ‘What if Gretzky was healthy and kept scoring like the front half of his career?’
Well? What if? Does Gretzky get the same massaging that you’re giving bossy, or Lemieux? Are you ready to give Gretzky 70 goal seasons that he didn’t score?
Of course not. Because the only reason era adjusting stats even exist is to try to make sense of Gretzky.
So if you’re going to do ‘what if’ try to be consistent and give all players the same allowances. Or just don’t do that, you don’t have to.
Longevity and health is how Ovechkin has gotten this close to begin with, something That Gretzky wasn’t blessed with.
But no one says ‘well, if Gretzky was healthy he would have score 1,200 goals’. But you’ll say ‘if bossy was healthy…..’
Ovechkin didn’t score 70, 80, 90 goals in a season. But he’s had more consistency with much lower peaks that Gretzky did. Due to health and longevity.
That’s part of the feat. Catching Gretzky in career goals was never thought to be anything less than unbreakable, because it’s something that would take 20 years to do. How many players have 20 year careers in the NHL? How many players score at almost a 1.0 gpg pace for 13 straight years? How many players score 40 or 50 goal season in their late 30’s or early 40’s?
No one.
That’s why it’s unbreakable.
18 years of 50 goal seasons, or 15 years of 60, 70, 80, 90 goal seasons is the only way to do it.
Neither is or ever has been thought to be ‘doable’
We have the real, actual numbers. There is no reason not to use them