The only issue with that is you're relying on fans/fanboys to objectively value one of their long time players. You're always going to overvalue what you have especially if you drafted and developed the player.Based solely on this poll, his new contract is fair value.
Learn the truth at www.MorganRiellyPsyOps.orgHe's a CIA agent working undercover.
Yes, let's judge our offensive dman by goals instead of points... makes sense! FYI there are only 15 defensemen with double digit goals (aka rare).Rielly was absolutely atrocious last night while so much blame is being placed on Holl. At least Holl threw a couple of big hits. Rielly has absolutely no understanding how to play D and his game is regressing. He brings down whichever partner he is paired with.
I just can’t comprehend how so many here consider him a top pairing quality D. Please explain this to me. There is no debate he is way way below average defensively. He brings nothing offensively. In fact, every other D on the team has more goals than him and they are not gifted PP minutes. The only minus player on the team too.
It is no coincidence this team was unstoppable while he was injured and now they are a .500 team. He needs to sit in the press box. I truly believe he is a black hole and the team is better without him. I cringe at the thought of having to watch this plug for another 7 years.
Yes, let's judge our offensive dman by goals instead of points... makes sense! FYI there are only 15 defensemen with double digit goals (aka rare).
He's having a down season and is still top 30 in points per game (aka low-tier #1Dman offensive production during a bad year). While he does get the most powerplay time for Leafs defense, he's #30th league wide per game among defensemen so its not like he's getting a ridiculous amount of PP time.
Plus/minus is a silly stat. JT and Kampf are having good seasons and are both +1. Most people think Kerfoots having a terrible season and he's +11.
Bolded is factually incorrect:
- Rielly, Timmins, Holl, Brodie, and McCabe each have 2g, Liljegren and Giordano with 5/4.
- The Leafs are 15-9-2 since his return (101pt pace). Not nearly as drastic as this 50-50 you're pushing.
- ZAR is a -6.
There's a difference between he's having a down year/poor stretch and what some people are throwing around in this thread.
Why does everybody need to use so many exaggerations? Ridiculous when you'll all jump back onto the next whipping boy once Riellys production returns to his normal.
I'll keep reiterating this until it's untrue, he has always been better in the playoffs than regular season and that's what the Leafs need more than anything else. You'd think people would rate playoff performances more than regular season for this team by now...
No matter how you slice it Rielly is absolutely dreadful in the defensive end and has zero understanding how to play defence. He never wins board battles, is soft as they come and has a very low IQ. The team bleeds goals whenever he is on the ice and this has been a constant his entire career.Yes, let's judge our offensive dman by goals instead of points... makes sense! FYI there are only 15 defensemen with double digit goals (aka rare).
He's having a down season and is still top 30 in points per game (aka low-tier #1Dman offensive production during a bad year). While he does get the most powerplay time for Leafs defense, he's #30th league wide per game among defensemen so its not like he's getting a ridiculous amount of PP time.
Plus/minus is a silly stat. JT and Kampf are having good seasons and are both +1. Most people think Kerfoots having a terrible season and he's +11.
Bolded is factually incorrect:
- Rielly, Timmins, Holl, Brodie, and McCabe each have 2g, Liljegren and Giordano with 5/4.
- The Leafs are 15-9-2 since his return (101pt pace). Not nearly as drastic as this 50-50 you're pushing.
- ZAR is a -6.
There's a difference between he's having a down year/poor stretch and what some people are throwing around in this thread.
Why does everybody need to use so many exaggerations? Ridiculous when you'll all jump back onto the next whipping boy once Riellys production returns to his normal.
I'll keep reiterating this until it's untrue, he has always been better in the playoffs than regular season and that's what the Leafs need more than anything else. You'd think people would rate playoff performances more than regular season for this team by now...
As far as playoffs go I can't argue that. For as much as I shit on him this season it's always important to remember he can be the best player for us in the playoffs. We didn't choke against Montreal and Columbus because of him, if everyone showed up like him we win those series. But even you have to admit that it's frustrating seeing his horrible defensive lapses during the season.Yes, let's judge our offensive dman by goals instead of points... makes sense! FYI there are only 15 defensemen with double digit goals (aka rare).
He's having a down season and is still top 30 in points per game (aka low-tier #1Dman offensive production during a bad year). While he does get the most powerplay time for Leafs defense, he's #30th league wide per game among defensemen so its not like he's getting a ridiculous amount of PP time.
Plus/minus is a silly stat. JT and Kampf are having good seasons and are both +1. Most people think Kerfoots having a terrible season and he's +11.
Bolded is factually incorrect:
- Rielly, Timmins, Holl, Brodie, and McCabe each have 2g, Liljegren and Giordano with 5/4.
- The Leafs are 15-9-2 since his return (101pt pace). Not nearly as drastic as this 50-50 you're pushing.
- ZAR is a -6.
There's a difference between he's having a down year/poor stretch and what some people are throwing around in this thread.
Why does everybody need to use so many exaggerations? Ridiculous when you'll all jump back onto the next whipping boy once Riellys production returns to his normal.
I'll keep reiterating this until it's untrue, he has always been better in the playoffs than regular season and that's what the Leafs need more than anything else. You'd think people would rate playoff performances more than regular season for this team by now...
I think he's a huge liability out there. He is clueless on defense.