W Beckett Sennecke - Oshawa Generals, OHL (2024, 3rd, ANA)

malcb33

Registered User
Apr 10, 2005
1,252
1,267
New Zealand
Stop fantasizing about the Sharks trading down from 14 to 27 for f***ing Jordan Harris. And please tell your fellow Habs fans to stop making horrible trade-up proposals. If you want to give us Reinbacher for 14+, we can talk. Otherwise, absolutely zero interest in trading down from 14 to 27.
I guess reading comprehension isn’t your friend, but I hope you can find away to keep up next time.
 

Leto

Registered User
Feb 16, 2023
1,019
2,173
It's possible if a team offers enough.

I think this year the cost to move up would be higher. There seems to be a steep drop off in the mid first.

I agree.

So are the Habs willing to offer four picks?

It depends on what you mean by ''four picks''. If MTL were to offer a package similar to what the Coyotes paid, it would be something like the following :
  • WPG 1st 2024 (~24-27 OV range)
  • MTL 2nd 2025
  • PIT 2nd 2025
I didn't include COL's 2nd 2024 (~57 OV range), as the expected value of that pick is closer to an early 3rd round pick than an early 2nd pick compared to MTL+PIT's 2025 2nd round picks. So a willing to trade down would have to take 2025 2nd rounders (assuming PIT/MTL are still bad next year), or a less valuable COL 2024 2nd rounder + one 2025 2nd rounder.

Truth be told, I don't see any obvious trading partner in the 10-15 range. :dunno:
 
Mar 31, 2005
1,723
48
East Coast
Reading between the lines on McKenzie's rankings teams are much higher on him than the public mock drafters - I'm thinking 10 to 14 range is more likely than 15 to 20 at this point.
 

BJCOLLINS

Registered User
Jul 7, 2003
2,838
1,316
Pirate Satellite
I agree.



It depends on what you mean by ''four picks''. If MTL were to offer a package similar to what the Coyotes paid, it would be something like the following :
  • WPG 1st 2024 (~24-27 OV range)
  • MTL 2nd 2025
  • PIT 2nd 2025
I didn't include COL's 2nd 2024 (~57 OV range), as the expected value of that pick is closer to an early 3rd round pick than an early 2nd pick compared to MTL+PIT's 2025 2nd round picks. So a willing to trade down would have to take 2025 2nd rounders (assuming PIT/MTL are still bad next year), or a less valuable COL 2024 2nd rounder + one 2025 2nd rounder.

Truth be told, I don't see any obvious trading partner in the 10-15 range. :dunno:
This whole discussion is just too subjective.

Who the Habs draft at #5 will have an enormous impact on their thinking as well as who they like that has fallen to 10-14……if it’s a player Bobby Mac had # 2-7 they should be all in however 25 other teams will have trade packages in as well.
 

TheBeard

He fixes the cable?
Jul 12, 2019
18,515
21,492
Vegass
Yes, aside from Bedard.. the same way that the Habs have Slafkovsky from their 1st OA (not comparing the two, obviously Bedard is leagues ahead).. just that it's not uncommon for teams after 2 drafts in a rebuild to still be looking for impact talent.
No doubt. Sharks have accumulated a fair amount of prospect talent over the last couple years including Celebrini and it’s safe to say no one on the sharks board feels confident enough that we have enough.
 

Intangir

Registered User
Aug 14, 2008
1,863
2,294
Montreal, QC
I see shades of Charlie Coyle from Sennecke.

He's big, strong on the puck, generally moves well, has some nice mitts, takes good decisions on the ice, is a pretty good shooter, great when it comes to puck possession, and just positions himself/reads plays well.

Then you look at his level of play from October to now, the quite frankly amazing learning curve since about January on combined with his physical gifts and skating, and it appears quite clearly that Sennecke has the potential to be a very good player in the NHL.

And one that is quite "safe" to boot given how much detail there is to his game, and how translatable his skillset/plays on the ice are.

The one real caveat that I have with Sennecke is a question about just how high-end his vision and decision-making are offensively. And also whether or not he has it in him to be a strong play-driving winger or if he ultimately ends up being more of a facilitator and complementary piece for higher-skilled players at the NHL level.

Oh, and I also think Sennecke could stand to get more agile on his skates and improve his edges too, as I found that he sometimes looked a bit lumbering while trying to weave his way through checking in the games that I did see.

So yeah, personally I don't quite see Sennecke in the top 10 but I still really like the player so if a team jumped the gun a bit for him then I would understand.

But I rate Tij Iginla slightly higher because from the viewings I've had his hockey sense seemed better to me, though he admittedly does not have the strength/reach advantage that Sennecke does, nor are his hands as good.
 
Last edited:

Garbageyuk

Registered User
Dec 19, 2016
6,577
6,423
And admits he may go even higher.

Noise around the Canadiens is that they really like this player, so if Lindstrom and Demidov are gone, I would not be surprised they go Sennecke over Iginla at this point.
Noise from who? If Lindstrom and Demidov are gone, they’ll go with one of the highly rated D. They may go with one even if the two forwards aren’t gone.
 

Dead Coyote

Registered User
Oct 10, 2017
2,810
3,366
In the grand scheme of things, 22 points in 16 games isn’t exactly lighting the world on fire for a draft eligible in the OHL, is it? From the way people are talking about him “dominating”, I kind of expected that he was at like 2+ PPG in the playoffs.
It's actually pretty good. Not amazing, but 2+ ppg would put him somewhere in the top 5-10 range all time for draft eligibles. There are exactly 19 draft eligibles who put up that kind of PPG in their draft year in the OHL, not even excluding players who only played a few games. Just everyone. And 3 of them did while 16, two of which did it more than once (Gretzky and Lindros)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: majormajor

Dead Coyote

Registered User
Oct 10, 2017
2,810
3,366
In 2010, Jeff Skinner was ranked 34th for NA skaters in central scouting final rankings.

Then he scored 20 goals in 20 playoff games.

On draft day he was selected 7th overall and has scored a ton of goals in the NHL.

Maybe a similar story is unfolding with Sennecke.
Little bit of a different situation here since Skinner broke the record for most PP goals that year and is 12th all time in goals,

2nd among draft eligibles all time in goals (only behind McDavid who had 1 more), 7th among draft eligibles all time in points and 21st in PPG (at least 10GP).

Bennett is 38th on the draft eligibles list in PPG, 41st in points and 26th in Goals.

What he's done has been very impressive still, but I don't think warrants a comparison to Skinner's rise.
 
Last edited:

Ad

Ad

Ad