Sorry if this was posted elsewhere but I couldn’t find a similar thread. No doubt a thread about the parking garage itself exists, but I want to talk about the “hype” around it.
Yes, it’ll hold over 1400 cars. Yea, it’s pretty close to the arena. It’s sure gonna be expensive. But how in the holy hell do they think funneling that many cars to a single building will work? This isn’t a big deal for a shopping mall where people come and go randomly. But having a large majority of the fans arriving within a 1.5 hour window is going to be chaos.
If you think getting in is bad, wait until it’s time to exit after the game. Anyone ever park in one of the parking garages near yankee stadium? Yeah, not something you want to do. Getting out takes an hour + easily.
All I hear is “thank goodness the garage will be open”, “it’s going to solve so many issues”, “fans will no longer park on the streets”. This is a huge ticking time bomb.
Please correct me if they have figured out some innovative way to unload the garage after the game. Has anyone in the media even thought of this issue? Judging by my google searches, it doesn’t seem so.
And the train for MSG is brutal itself.A ticking time bomb? Oh please.
You know what folks? I get that everyone would like things to be like Madison Square Garden, where you can just go up a couple of escalators from your train to the arena and never have to go outside. But this is what we (along with everyone except the Bruins) have.
If the driving-parking situation becomes untenable, take the train. Take a rideshare. That was the idea when UBS Arena was built.
Let’s face it. With our “loyal” Islanders fans supporting the team at the box office, how often do you expect there to be 17,000 fans at the games this year? We only host the Rags once this season.And the train for MSG is brutal itself.
I hate these dramatic threads, people love to complain.
You mean to tell me that 17K people leaving a place at once results in traffic congestion? Who would have guessed!!!!!!!
They have a garage on one side, parking on another and a train line. That eases it about as well as you can. Figure it out.
This thread really doesn’t deserve to live.It's holding a fraction of the cars, I can't imagine that'll be a big deal. If they put every car in the same garage with a single entrance and exit there'd be an issue. This isn't one, and couldn't you just choose a different place to park?
Sure glad I didn’t start this thread. No mercy for the OP. Ouch!This thread really doesn’t deserve to live.
There's several issues involved here. #1 idles fans had easy life dealing with coliseum. #2 most fans are from long Island. Paying to park, driving around expensive conjested parking garages is not something we ever deal with
#3 alot of games are after people already had a whole day of work and other driving. It's not easy to deal with. Never mind how many people drink at games. I couldn't believe how many people were drinking at the devilsnpreseason game last week. Alot more than most heavy metal concerts I go to. They should of built this next to the coliseum and tore the coliseum down or made it next to the Hicksville train station so everyone could take the train. The average fan in Smithtown or Ronkonkoma is looking at 4 hrs of being in the car to go to a game. 95% of the peoplemat games live east of the building. Terrible location
This thread really doesn’t deserve to live.
There's several issues involved here. #1 idles fans had easy life dealing with coliseum. #2 most fans are from long Island. Paying to park, driving around expensive conjested parking garages is not something we ever deal with
#3 alot of games are after people already had a whole day of work and other driving. It's not easy to deal with. Never mind how many people drink at games. I couldn't believe how many people were drinking at the devilsnpreseason game last week. Alot more than most heavy metal concerts I go to. They should of built this next to the coliseum and tore the coliseum down or made it next to the Hicksville train station so everyone could take the train. The average fan in Smithtown or Ronkonkoma is looking at 4 hrs of being in the car to go to a game. 95% of the peoplemat games live east of the building. Terrible location
This thread really doesn’t deserve to live.
Of course you heard lots of complaints. This is what Islanders fans do best...COMPLAIN.The train drops you off nearly 3/4 of a mile away. I’ve heard lots of complaints about their shuttle busses. The train stop at the racetrack only has 2 trains to and from on game days and can only be accessed via Jamaica. From Ronkonkoma that’s a 1:40 to 1:50 trip.
The entire point to my original statement was that this will not be the savior we are told it will be. If you thought getting out of the south lot was bad, this will be much worse.
There's several issues involved here. #1 idles fans had easy life dealing with coliseum. #2 most fans are from long Island. Paying to park, driving around expensive conjested parking garages is not something we ever deal with
#3 alot of games are after people already had a whole day of work and other driving. It's not easy to deal with. Never mind how many people drink at games. I couldn't believe how many people were drinking at the devilsnpreseason game last week. Alot more than most heavy metal concerts I go to. They should of built this next to the coliseum and tore the coliseum down or made it next to the Hicksville train station so everyone could take the train. The average fan in Smithtown or Ronkonkoma is looking at 4 hrs of being in the car to go to a game. 95% of the peoplemat games live east of the building. Terrible location
It’s the South Garage now.Is south lot parking still an option?
If they had built the arena in the area across from Citi Field where the junkyards were cleared out people would be complaining about the longer walk to the LIRR and the fact that only the Port Washington line goes to Citi Field.UBS is a breeze compared to City Field after an afternoon game when you are leaving during rush hour and Yankee stadium is no better trying to get out of the garage near the stadium.
All it takes is one feneder bender and that drive is going to be an hour longer. I know people can be sensitive if you critize their kid, I mean their home, but with the very fast increasing population on long Island, you don't know how much worse driving will be in 2 yrs or 8 yrs. It's safe to say, if there's not another covid it will be much worse..traffic is already reduced at least 25% due to covid still if you take a look at how crowded the lirr parking lot in Ronkonkoma is now compared to before covid. In fact with the population increase there's probably 30% less cars on tje roade with alot people still working from home. Fans who go to games, are going to saybits not a pain..but there's gota be fans who would go more often if it was in a easy driveable spot. The lirr thing is going to add up to alot money for some people, someday like in 10 days they won't have any trains foe the game. Its going to be 20 degrees in the winter on some games..so you can't make the argument that a arena built in the city is ideal when the fans almost all live on longisland.If they had built the arena in the area across from Citi Field where the junkyards were cleared out people would be complaining about the longer walk to the LIRR and the fact that only the Port Washington line goes to Citi Field.
All it takes is one feneder bender and that drive is going to be an hour longer. I know people can be sensitive if you critize their kid, I mean their home, but with the very fast increasing population on long Island, you don't know how much worse driving will be in 2 yrs or 8 yrs. It's safe to say, if there's not another covid it will be much worse..traffic is already reduced at least 25% due to covid still if you take a look at how crowded the lirr parking lot in Ronkonkoma is now compared to before covid. In fact with the population increase there's probably 30% less cars on tje roade with alot people still working from home. Fans who go to games, are going to saybits not a pain..but there's gota be fans who would go more often if it was in a easy driveable spot. The lirr thing is going to add up to alot money for some people, someday like in 10 days they won't have any trains foe the game. Its going to be 20 degrees in the winter on some games..so you can't make the argument that a arena built in the city is ideal when the fans almost all live on longisland.
They should have built a floating arena in Long Island Sound like I suggested. No traffic or parking issues there.The population growth is out east and won't impact Belmont. If traffic gets bad, more people will take the train. The arena is on Long Island and isn't in the city. What in the world are you even talking about?
I guess Malkin should build another arena out in Ronkonkoma for everyone who lives in the Town of Brookhaven for when they can't deal with a trek to Elmont anymore.All it takes is one feneder bender and that drive is going to be an hour longer. I know people can be sensitive if you critize their kid, I mean their home, but with the very fast increasing population on long Island, you don't know how much worse driving will be in 2 yrs or 8 yrs. It's safe to say, if there's not another covid it will be much worse..traffic is already reduced at least 25% due to covid still if you take a look at how crowded the lirr parking lot in Ronkonkoma is now compared to before covid. In fact with the population increase there's probably 30% less cars on tje roade with alot people still working from home. Fans who go to games, are going to saybits not a pain..but there's gota be fans who would go more often if it was in a easy driveable spot. The lirr thing is going to add up to alot money for some people, someday like in 10 days they won't have any trains foe the game. Its going to be 20 degrees in the winter on some games..so you can't make the argument that a arena built in the city is ideal when the fans almost all live on longisland.
BTW if you park at Hicksville and take a 12 minute LIRR ride to Elmont the fare is $3.25. Park at Mineola and it's a 5 minute train ride.All it takes is one feneder bender and that drive is going to be an hour longer. I know people can be sensitive if you critize their kid, I mean their home, but with the very fast increasing population on long Island, you don't know how much worse driving will be in 2 yrs or 8 yrs. It's safe to say, if there's not another covid it will be much worse..traffic is already reduced at least 25% due to covid still if you take a look at how crowded the lirr parking lot in Ronkonkoma is now compared to before covid. In fact with the population increase there's probably 30% less cars on tje roade with alot people still working from home. Fans who go to games, are going to saybits not a pain..but there's gota be fans who would go more often if it was in a easy driveable spot. The lirr thing is going to add up to alot money for some people, someday like in 10 days they won't have any trains foe the game. Its going to be 20 degrees in the winter on some games..so you can't make the argument that a arena built in the city is ideal when the fans almost all live on longisland.