It was in that we used a 10th overall pick on a guy with physical upside but who hadn't shown much more than a limited offensive potential.
It was COVID etc. so I'm more than willing to give the scouts and Dorion a break, it wasn't ever not going to be a crapshoot.
I get it was a 10th overall pick, but due to the nature of the draft, and how limited the Senators in particular might have been, I don't think we should view it like a regular 10th overall pick. There didn't seem to be the same level of certainty that usually comes with picking that high.
From 2018 to 2023, the Senators gave up multiple high picks while only getting one back via San Jose. So I think the fact that they gave up a 4th OA, 7th OA, and 12th OA over that time frame makes people even more upset over not getting a top end offensive talent at 10th overall. Which may not have even been reasonably possible with the way that draft was, but they saw Sillinger come in and have a strong rookie year, and it only made the criticism of the pick stronger.
We don't know how little info the Sens were working with, what kind of budget they were granted for scouting during COVID vs other teams. The pick is not working out due to injuries, but I am fine with the logic of the pick. We also don't know what the market was trade wise for that pick. Could the Senators have traded it for a 2022 1st Round pick? Could they have traded it for a good player or prospect? Or did nobody want 2021 picks, even one as high as 10?
People bring up scouting lists, but it is clear that there was a disconnect because there is no way he would have been available at the back half of the second round.