Still can't believe that if we hadn't won game 82 against the Leafs in 2021 then we'd have picked 8th and Ottawa-born Sens fan Clarke would probably be a Senator right now.
I absolutely agree with the reasons, but it really what it does to a players mental state. CHL overage players by and large do not make the NHL. Of course there are exceptions, Kastelic being one, but he was also a late bloomer not drafted until he was 20.
If near every player in your graduating class move onto pro hockey next year, and you are held back, its just not good mentally. Even if it is best for you.
He should be told not to treat it like an overager season. He's missed basically 2 out of the last 3 seasons.
It would be more of a concern if he were perfectly healthy through his draft, draft+1 and draft+2 years yet still got send back.
I would be concerned about how much offensive time he'd get with how little development he's had since his 16YR old season. Easy to see him falling into a situation where he's playing very limited minutes in Belleville's bottom 6 and isn't able to develop enough of an offensive game to make the NHL.
Would rather he plays against kids, hopefully gets healthy and plays a full season in offensive situations while he recovers his game.