Just went through the first 3 pages of the '#5 overall pick' thread...not a single negative post, everyone very happy. Nobody upset that we didn't get Seider....funny how that works.
Ok and your point? Other than maybe Thomas Hickey most every first round pick, whether it was Anze Kopitar or Colten Tuebert were liked by the majority here.
Also, there were plenty of people who wanted other players picked. Zegras had his fans, Caufield, Byram, Cozens, Dach etc. And yes there was someone who wanted Seider, I didn’t remember it either but
@KingsHockey24 did say in the lead up to the draft that is who they wanted.
If you are saying people are contradictory or move the goal posts that isn’t untrue, but at least call it all out. There were plenty of posts in that discussion that had **this years** team lead by Vilardi as the 1C and Turcotte as the 2C with Kopitar playing the veteran 3C role. Now that wasn’t unrealistic, when you take one guy #11 it’s a reasonable expectation you have a 1st line performer in D+5, a few guys taken after are first liners bordering on stars, and when you take another at #5 it’s a reasonable expectation to expect a 2nd liner in D+3, plenty of guys taken after in that draft are at that level. So based on what was said in that thread and what the reasonable expectations were for those players is or fair to call those two guys big disappointments considering neither has really done anything at the NHL level? I said both were and get my head ripped off by those same people who had those projected lists. That is just as contradictory as what you are complaining about.
No one saw Turcotte being injured this much, no one saw the poor offensive season at UW or the lack of offensive ability at the pro level. But just because no one saw it doesn’t mean it can’t be discussed now. If Turcotte isn’t an NHL regular by the end of next season you can basically throw in the towel on him being anything more than a depth player. Unless you think he can do what very few players taken they high have ever done.