Proposal: Trouba to Montreal for Sergachev+1st

[elite1prospects]

Trouba to Montreal for Sergachev+1st

weber-trouba
markov-petry
beaulieu-emelin

Flame and Grill it....

Click to read more...

 

[JetsHomer]

Trouba to the Jets for a 8 year 5.5m contract

 

[ottawa]

Trouba to Montreal for Sergachev+1st

weber-trouba
markov-petry
beaulieu-emelin

Flame and Grill it....

Weber is a RD

 

[Curufinwe]

Trouba to Montreal for Sergachev+1st

weber-trouba
markov-petry
beaulieu-emelin


Flame and Grill it....

Look at Montreal's cap

 

[Pongs21]

I'm going to go with the short and polite response. No thank you.

 

[Drew4u]

Trouba's terribly overrated. People acting like he's a top pairing defencemen... Not a chance

 

[UnicornONtheCOBB]

Trouba's terribly overrated. People acting like he's a top pairing defencemen... Not a chance

I'd say he's a 3 know (top 90 in the league), and easily has the talent to become a top pairing dman (top 60 in the NHL).

 

[The Zetterberg Era]

Montreal has their top 4 RD spots locked in.

When Trouba is eventually moved, I don't think Jets fans are going to be happy with the return. Like most players, he doesn't have the value we all hope for on our team when we look to make deals. It applies to more than half the league around here. Even though Trouba is a good asset, I don't think he is worth what has been thrown around all summer.

 

[Mr Hockey*]

Uh, yeah lol

I pull the trigger on that trade.

 

[Hunter368]

Montreal has their top 4 RD spots locked in.

When Trouba is eventually moved, I don't think Jets fans are going to be happy with the return. Like most players, he doesn't have the value we all hope for on our team when we look to make deals. It applies to more than half the league around here. Even though Trouba is a good asset, I don't think he is worth what has been thrown around all summer.

Depends what "offers" you're referring to of course, like any player for any team you have a minority who are very high on the player. I've seen some very decent offers for him also, biggest things is the return reflective of our needs? Most offers aren't, just a bunch of random pieces thrown together that the respective team doesn't need or want anymore so they offer them up with very little thought of the Jets needs.

 

[buttman*]

I'd say he's a 3 know (top 90 in the league), and easily has the talent to become a top pairing dman (top 60 in the NHL).

You'd say. His play says otherwise. Top 90 -- haha -- is that something to be proud of?

 

[LiveLongandProspal]

Trouba to the Rangers for JT Miller and Dylan McIlrath

 

[JetsHomer]

Montreal has their top 4 RD spots locked in.

When Trouba is eventually moved, I don't think Jets fans are going to be happy with the return. Like most players, he doesn't have the value we all hope for on our team when we look to make deals. It applies to more than half the league around here. Even though Trouba is a good asset, I don't think he is worth what has been thrown around all summer.

'Eventually moved'

 

[Vatican Roulette]

Trouba to the Rangers for JT Miller and Dylan McIlrath

I don't think the Rangers have the space to sign Trouba if they get him.

 

[rockinghockey]

Trouba to Montreal for Sergachev+1st

weber-trouba
markov-petry
beaulieu-emelin

Flame and Grill it....

I would want Trouba on my team but people are way over rating him. Trouba is not worth two 1st

 

[Drew4u]

I would want Trouba on my team but people are way over rating him. Trouba is not worth two 1st

Especially considering there's a good chance Sergachev will be better than Trouba.

 

[Advanced stats]

Trouba to the Jets for a 8 year 5.5m contract

Guaranteed to never happen.

Either he settles for a bridge or signs at least a 6x6.

 

[LiveLongandProspal]

I don't think the Rangers have the space to sign Trouba if they get him.

Good point. I think the Rangers have like 2 million in cap space.

 

[Nickel eye Heel hers]

Guaranteed to never happen.

Either he settles for a bridge or signs at least a 6x6.

You think Trouba is worth 6x6 with so many RFA years?

Is Lindholm going to get 7 million x 6 years ?

Even 5.5M x 6 is pretty rich for Trouba with RFA years involved.

 

[TML1967]

Leafs fan coming in peace!

Trouba for TML 2017 1st (top 10 protected pre lottery), Tobias Lindberg/Josh Leivo, Frank Corrado/Martin Marincin?

Corrado/Marincin can play bottom pairing this year for Winnipeg, Marincin looked ready to step into the top 4 when the opportunity was there, though he is a LHD and Corrado is a RHD.

Lindberg/Leivo both look like pretty solid prospects, nicely looking to become top 9 guy, Leivo probably next year.

2017 1st round pick top 10 protected. With Trouba, I for sure see the Leafs finishing outside the bottom 10.

Thoughts? Is the value off?

 

[Whileee]

Leafs fan coming in peace!

Trouba for TML 2017 1st (top 10 protected pre lottery), Tobias Lindberg/Josh Leivo, Frank Corrado/Martin Marincin?

Corrado/Marincin can play bottom pairing this year for Winnipeg, Marincin looked ready to step into the top 4 when the opportunity was there, though he is a LHD and Corrado is a RHD.

Lindberg/Leivo both look like pretty solid prospects, nicely looking to become top 9 guy, Leivo probably next year.

2017 1st round pick top 10 protected. With Trouba, I for sure see the Leafs finishing outside the bottom 10.

Thoughts? Is the value off?

Yes, the value is off.

Also, the pieces are of very little interest to the Jets. They don't need quantity for quality. Their prospect pipeline is brimming full of everything except top D, like Trouba.

 

[Cleatus]

As a fan of both the Leafs and Jets, if the Jets feel they really have to trade Trouba (I'd rather they trade Myers), I think an offer based around Gardiner and a conditional 2017 1st round pick would be beneficial to both sides.

Condition on that pick being if the Leafs end up drafting in the top 5, Winnipeg gets their 2018 1st instead (10-15 overall range by my estimations).

 

[JetsHomer]

You'd say. His play says otherwise. Top 90 -- haha -- is that something to be proud of?

Yes who would want a 22 year old top 3 defenceman, another solid post from the buttman

 

[TML1967]

Yes, the value is off.

Also, the pieces are of very little interest to the Jets. They don't need quantity for quality. Their prospect pipeline is brimming full of everything except top D, like Trouba.

Totally fair! Was just looking to see what kind of package was being looked for, both high and low end.

I like Trouba, see him as being a top 100 defender right now (id have him close to the 80-95 ish spot) and see him being able to develop into a top 60 in the league guy. Never expect him to be top 10 or even 20, but thats less based on his absolute potential and more on the fact that few players hit their peak potential.

From the Leafs, unless were giving up a JVR type, which I dont think they will, I cant see much more than a 20171st + prospect+ D thats not Zaitsev, Gardiner, Reilly being what they can do.

I hope he signs with WPG as I want them to succeed but thats allot of money tied up in 3 RHD, who are all easily top 4 guys for the long haul.

 

[Gavy]

As a fan of both the Leafs and Jets, if the Jets feel they really have to trade Trouba (I'd rather they trade Myers), I think an offer based around Gardiner and a conditional 2017 1st round pick would be beneficial to both sides.

Condition on that pick being if the Leafs end up drafting in the top 5, Winnipeg gets their 2018 1st instead (10-15 overall range by my estimations).

Lol no.