Proposal: Trouba all encompassing trade thread

[Cerebral]

to EDM: Trouba, Connor
to WIN: Nurse, Puljujarvi

How is the value on this? Maybe a little more to Edmonton?

Laine-Scheifele-Puljujarvi would be a crazy line.

 

[SaskCanesFan]

It's a fair enough argument. And yes, Slavin looked awesome when I saw him last year, but Winnipeg doesn't have to take less. As an Oiler fan, I personally wouldn't part with Nurse (for different reasons, obviously), but that doesn't mean Winnipeg wouldn't force your hand.

In what way can the Jets "force" the Canes hand? The Canes don't have to make a trade, they can walk away and be fine on D. There's zero reason to trade the player that will be their #1LHD for a player that will be their #2RHD. Especially considering Slavin is expansion draft exempt, and has 2 more ELC years. The contract situation is much better for Slavin.

 

[GoJetsGo55]

Lets just clear things up quickly.

Here's all the things that Winnipeg needs. If you are not including something on this list, don't bother.

1) Late round picks
2) Cap dumps
3) A player that is somewhat skilled but nobody really cares about
4) Overage prospects
5) Lupul

Bonus points if you keep bringing up debunked rumours about him wanting $7 mil a year.

 

[The Podium]

Lets just clear things up quickly.

Here's all the things that Winnipeg needs. If you are not including something on this list, don't bother.

1) Late round picks
2) Cap dumps
3) A player that is somewhat skilled but nobody really cares about
4) Overage prospects
5) Lupul

Bonus points if you keep bringing up debunked rumours about him wanting $7 mil a year.

Toronto offers Lupul (LTIR - won't count against the cap) + Michalek (to work out the salary since he wants 7+ a year) + Bozak + Leivo + 6th

 

[GoJetsGo55]

Toronto offers Lupul (LTIR - won't count against the cap) + Michalek (to work out the salary since he wants 7+ a year) + Bozak + Leivo + 6th

What if we add a 2017+2018 2nd and you add Horton?

 

[LondonKendrick]

Lets just clear things up quickly.

Here's all the things that Winnipeg needs. If you are not including something on this list, don't bother.

1) Late round picks
2) Cap dumps
3) A player that is somewhat skilled but nobody really cares about
4) Overage prospects
5) Lupul

Bonus points if you keep bringing up debunked rumours about him wanting $7 mil a year.

Ummm.... do you look at the return players want a trade gets? Trouba is basically Phaneuf 2.0, no one is giving up a great asset for him.

 

[McMatthews]

He was one of my favourite prospects coming out of his draft but he's been tremendously underwhelming.

I wouldn't overpay for him.

 

[belair]

In what way can the Jets "force" the Canes hand? The Canes don't have to make a trade, they can walk away and be fine on D. There's zero reason to trade the player that will be their #1LHD for a player that will be their #2RHD. Especially considering Slavin is expansion draft exempt, and has 2 more ELC years. The contract situation is much better for Slavin.

JR: We want Trouba, here's Fleury.

KC: We don't wan't Fleury, we want Slavin.

JR: We don't want to trade Slavin.

KC: Well we don't want to trade you Trouba.

JR: But we want Trouba.

KC: Then we want Slavin, not Fleury.

...and so on.

 

[howkie]

Toronto offers Lupul (LTIR - won't count against the cap) + Michalek (to work out the salary since he wants 7+ a year) + Bozak + Leivo + 6th

Bozak and Leivo for the 2 contracts, so a 6 th Trouba... pass...

 

[La Bamba]

to EDM: Trouba, Connor
to WIN: Nurse, Puljujarvi

How is the value on this? Maybe a little more to Edmonton?

Laine-Scheifele-Puljujarvi would be a crazy line.

Hell na, Pulju ain't going anywhere unless Laine is a piece coming back

 

[The Podium]

Bozak and Leivo for the 2 contracts, so a 6 th Trouba... pass...

It wasn't a serious proposal I was playing along with the joke in the post I quoted

 

[howkie]

It wasn't a serious proposal I was playing along with the joke in the post I quoted

Well if it was a 5 you had a deal, since Trouba is crap apperntly =)

 

[DonskoiDonscored]

Timo Meier not practicing at scrimmages today. Starting up the rumor train

 

[LiveLongandProspal]

JT Miller, Dylan McIlrath and Ryan Graves for Jacob Trouba. Fair?

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

Jack Johnson + Gabriel Carlsson + Sonny Milano for Trouba

 

[Maukkis]

JT Miller, Dylan McIlrath and Ryan Graves for Jacob Trouba. Fair?

Not in the slightest. You can't just assume that we are doing you favours.

 

[SaskCanesFan]

JR: We want Trouba, here's Fleury.

KC: We don't wan't Fleury, we want Slavin.

JR: We don't want to trade Slavin.

KC: Well we don't want to trade you Trouba.

JR: But we want Trouba.

KC: Then we want Slavin, not Fleury.

...and so on.

Suddenly it becomes much more apparent why you weren't familiar enough with Slavin or the Canes situation to suggest that they should move him for Trouba so easily

Good for JR, he can do whatever he wants. But since Ron Francis has actually been running the team for two years now, he can say "thanks, but we don't want Trouba badly enough to give up our #1LHD on his entry level deal with expansion draft exemption and more years of cost control, so good luck dealing him somewhere else." Because like I said, the Canes don't need Trouba by any stretch, the D is solid without him.

 

[Hunter368]

Scrap yard in here.

Yup, a bunch of low ball offers, fans who don't know any of the facts around the situation or team needs, fans who know zero about Trouba progression each year and only look at his points suddenly experts, scraps, dumps and crappie offers.

Did you expect anything more from HFB?

When Trouba is traded he will get a very good return and many will be surprised at the return.

 

[Hunter368]

to EDM: Trouba, Connor
to WIN: Nurse, Puljujarvi

How is the value on this? Maybe a little more to Edmonton?

Laine-Scheifele-Puljujarvi would be a crazy line.

Yes that line would be crazy and our defence would be brutal with Nurse on it. Jets don't need forwards we need quality defence.

 

[belair]

Suddenly it becomes much more apparent why you weren't familiar enough with Slavin or the Canes situation to suggest that they should move him for Trouba so easily

Good for JR, he can do whatever he wants. But since Ron Francis has actually been running the team for two years now, he can say "thanks, but we don't want Trouba badly enough to give up our #1LHD on his entry level deal with expansion draft exemption and more years of cost control, so good luck dealing him somewhere else." Because like I said, the Canes don't need Trouba by any stretch, the D is solid without him.

Brainfart on my part.

 

[scan15*]

Ummm.... do you look at the return players want a trade gets? Trouba is basically Phaneuf 2.0, no one is giving up a great asset for him.

More agile but the otherwise the comparison fits.

 

[Toggel]

From the oilers this is what I would offer.

Nurse and small plus. Don't Forget that nurse is expansion draft exempt so this would let the jets either protect 5 D or do the 7-3 split. That value has to be taken into account.

Reinhart/Davidson + Pouliot/Yak + 1st. Here you get a lesser LHD a top 9 winger and a decent first round pick (it's the oilers it would probably be top 5)

The other option is something around Sekera but he has a no move clause but I think he would fit nicely as the jets 2LD.

I don't think the oilers would trade JP, Klefbom, RNH at this point in time.

 

[BenningHurtsMySoul]

Tanev for Trouba.

 

[MrBoJangelz71]

Would a Trouba for Rasmus Ristolainen have any merit with Sabres?

 

[allan5oh]

I'd much much rather trade Tyler Myers. As far as his "major surgery" that some hf doctors blab about there's this:

http://www.sportsnet.ca/hockey/nhl/myers-says-hes-coming-jets-camp-pain-free-surgery/

He was skating after 10 weeks. Acl surgery can be 4-6 months in comparison.