I actually liked the Edmundson who played against us vs the Habs. But I haven't really watched him since so need to see him in person. I am shocked he is only 30.
One day I am going to write a list of all the crap the Leafs have traded picks for who played for us for 2 months and did almost nothing to help. Almost none of them re-signed and contributed in any meaningful way. Let alone all the draft capital they have given up for retention or even worse getting rid of cap (Marleau / Mrazek)....
The Foligno/ROR trades for rentals that played like 20 games for us as ~33-34 year olds or whatever were each about the same trade value, or even significantly less trade value (and in some cases SIGNIFICANTLY less trade value), then what teams in the past have traded for top 4 dmen in their 20s who stuck around multiple years. A few examples:
-Hamilton for a 1st + two 2nds
-Hronek + 4th for a 1st + 2nd
-Toews for two 2nds
-Montour for a 3rd
-Durzi for a 2nd
-DeMelo for a 3rd
-Marino for Smith and a 3rd
-Skjei for a 1st
I'd take any one of those players in their 20s for multiple years over Foligno or ROR as rentals. We also have the most expensive scouting / management group in the league, so our ability to look at a guy like say Montour on Buffalo, and realize he could play 20 minutes a night for us and that he's undervalued, should be better than other teams ability to do that.