Maple Leafs president Brendan Shanahan and GM Kyle Dubas shouldn’t think they’re done ahead of the NHL trade deadline. That defence still needs addressing.
www.thestar.com
Yes, the Leafs’ defensive group, led by 39-year-old Mark Giordano’s calm demeanour, has collectively had a very good analytical stretch this season. But since Christmas, nothing screams that this blue line is ready for a deep playoff run. And if we go back to the moment Jake Muzzin went down mid-October, the defence core has yet to look big, mean or physical — components that are essential in any championship run.
If the defence stays as is, envisioning any of Reilly, T.J. Brodie, or Giordano getting hurt isn’t a pretty picture. Who steps in for those minutes? Timothy Liljegren? Rasmus Sandin? Timmins? It doesn’t seem very reassuring. Does trading for a bottom-pair guy like Vancouver’s Luke Schenn ease one’s mind? I’m not sure that does the trick, either.
As much as I hate to say it, Dubas and Brendan Shanahan shouldn’t think they’re done pushing the team’s poker chips to the middle of the table.
The way I see it, giving up another first-round pick or top prospect Matthew Knies has to be considered. This may be the only move to get someone capable of logging a solid 20 minutes per night without stressing the forward group or unproven goaltender Ilya Samsonov.
With the Leafs making it official Wednesday that defenceman Jake Muzzin will miss the rest of the season and playoffs due to his cervical spine injury, it gives them a green light to finally go and replace him on the back end and use up some of the $4-million-plus available in salary cap space. One call Dubas should be making is to Nashville GM David Poile for the availability of defenceman Mattias Ekholm, who wouldn’t be a rental. The 32-year-old still has another three years remaining after this season at $6.25 million on the cap. Centre the deal around the Leafs’ 2024 first-round pick or, if you must, move Knies.
We’ve all heard the hype around Knies. Yes, he’s promising, but I also recall the hype surrounding Rangers forward Jimmy Vesey six years ago. At six-foot-one, 200 pounds, Vesey was the can’t-miss NCAA college star coming out of Harvard. With multiple teams chasing him, he declared himself a total free agent. The Bruins, Rangers and Devils were all drooling back then for this front-line star.
Even the keen eye of Mark Hunter and the Maple Leafs were desperate to sign him. They strategically offered Vesey’s brother, Nolan, a contract — having drafted him in the sixth round in 2014 — even though he was never in their plans. The added incentive didn’t work. Vesey declined Toronto’s attempt to entice him with family ties and signed with the Rangers. Now closing in on 30, Vesey is still a serviceable player in his second stint in New York but is certainly light-years away from the star player everyone once thought he would be.
My point is this: There are no guarantees with Knies either.
I get that Dubas and Leafs Nation are nervous to trade him or another first-round pick to get the blue line the help they need, but this team is close — and much closer with O’Reilly and Acciari. So why stop now? They’ll be better off throwing their remaining chips into the blue line than to under-commit at the deadline.
It’s time to go bigger or go home.