Lol so this board wants to trade Callahan and/or Girardi to have something new to talk about? Uh huh.
I think many make valid pts, but I don't agree with them for a few reasons.
-I think it's easier to win than many realize. I don't believe that a team like Chicago is that great, they have just done the right things. Towes isn't that great, just really clutch. Their D is strong, but more than anything they have realized how you gotta play and move the puck than anything else. Keith isn't a freak of nature. Hjalmarsson-Oduya? Leddy-Rozi? Sure, Kane is super slick and can open things up. Boston is really solid. STL is hard to beat. But like look at Anaheim, they are ***** slapping the entire league. I just don't think they are that good of a team. Flawed defense, little secondary scoring etc.
-When you have a structure, pieces tends to always work. Look at like Bickell in Chicago. When you don't, it's the opposite. 4 top 1-2 picks fails like in EDM. You know. We have a structure in NY. It's not like in Chicago, but it's not like in EDM or Fla either. That is obvious. We got something. Pieces are starting to fit in. What that structure is, what changes you can make etc., that is hard to pinpoint. But it in itself is more important than everything else.
I am a bit afraid that loosing core guys like G and Cally could mess with it.
-I think it's extremely obvious that nothing hurts teams more than bad moves while good moves really seem to have no price tag in hindsight.
Take Prust for example, I don't think I made one post on us letting him go. How could you match that contract? 2.5m per? You know. Now I think we should have resigned him. It seems hard to ever be able to replace him. Fighting, PKing and he scored some goals playing with Boyle. The second we didn't want him, Slats just could have picked up the phone and dealt him for a 3rd rounder at least.
I just don't believe that you should give up something that works. Yes I think G can be a top 3 D on a SC team and Cally a core 2B RWer.
Hence I am not saying that we should write them a blanc one, but if it's a mil too much, a mil and a half, you know. Odds are that five guys making a mill too much is better than one bad acquisition. It wasn't long ago we paid Wolski 5 mill. Cally and G makes a lot of sense for us in a lot of ways.
-I don't get why people are afraid of long term deals. Hossa is signed untill he is 43. We are afraid of resigning players till they are 34. Bringing in like a new guy, like say a Statsny, to be our No 1 C for 7 y 7m, that scares me too. But we know what we have in G and Cally.
Long term deals brings down the AAV. The AAV scares me, not y 5-7...