Proposal: Trade Rumors/Proposals Thread 2013-2014 | Part VI

[TheBradyBunch]

I bet we could get a 1st because of the weak draft class.

Agreed, I think a team like Pittsburgh would easily give up their 1st.

 

[Benjamin]

beauchemin(signed as free agent) - lupul, gardiner, pick?

edit: forgot about lebda -> franson

they keep getting players for free. we don't = difference

The difference being they can add salary without any care. While the Sens are desperate to shed salary while being a bottom 5 spender.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

The difference being they can add salary without any care. While the Sens are desperate to shed salary while being a bottom 5 spender.

No the difference is in order for Ottawa to make a deal, they have to get totally ripped off. In order for Toronto to make a deal, the other team that they deal with has to totally get ripped off. There's no more of a simple way to say it.

 

[Benjamin]

No the difference is in order for Ottawa to make a deal, they have to get totally ripped off. In order for Toronto to make a deal, the other team that they deal with has to totally get ripped off. There's no more of a simple way to say it.

Ottawa hasn't gotten completely ripped off since the Havlat trade.

 

[DrunkUncleDenis]

Ottawa hasn't gotten completely ripped off since the Havlat trade.

Well Bishop for Cony is looking pretty horrendous so far.

 

[Benjamin]

Well Bishop for Cony is looking pretty horrendous so far.

Murray had two options:

A) Take the only serious offer on Bishop

or

B) Let Bishop walk as a free agent

At least Murray got something for a player that was gone soon anyways. This is horrendous for the Oilers, not the Sens.

 

[Icelevel]

Murray had two options:

A) Take the only serious offer on Bishop

or

B) Let Bishop walk as a free agent

At least Murray got something for a player that was gone soon anyways. This is horrendous for the Oilers, not the Sens.

can't you re-sign the rfa bishop and hold on to him?

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

can't you re-sign the rfa bishop and hold on to him?

If that was the case why did he only sign for 1 year in the first place?

 

[Benjamin]

can't you re-sign the rfa bishop and hold on to him?

http://www.ottawasun.com/2013/12/04...ill-happy-with-ben-bishop-cory-conacher-trade

"I couldn't have signed (Bishop) to another contract and kept Robin and Craig (Anderson).

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

Ottawa hasn't gotten completely ripped off since the Havlat trade.

Every trade they make is a rip off...the only thing is they also get a good player in the deals that they make which makes it worthwhile. Why can't Ottawa get Lupul, Gardiner and a first for Phillips? Oh yeah because they're not Toronto. They probably wouldn't even get a 2nd rounder for Phillips if they traded him now, and Phillips is better than Beauchemin.

 

[Benjamin]

Every trade they make is a rip off...the only thing is they also get a good player in the deals that they make which makes it worthwhile. Why can't Ottawa get Lupul, Gardiner and a first for Phillips? Oh yeah because they're not Toronto. They probably wouldn't even get a 2nd rounder for Phillips if they traded him now, and Phillips is better than Beauchemin.

Kessel trade is not a rip off.

Rask for Raycroft...

Leafs trading a 1st(wich SJ used to trade up and select Couture) for Toskala.

They have had good trades recently because they could uncaringly take on a cap dump.

Also, saying Phillips is better than Beachamin is hilarious.

 

[stempniaksen]

Every trade they make is a rip off...the only thing is they also get a good player in the deals that they make which makes it worthwhile. Why can't Ottawa get Lupul, Gardiner and a first for Phillips? Oh yeah because they're not Toronto. They probably wouldn't even get a 2nd rounder for Phillips if they traded him now, and Phillips is better than Beauchemin.

You're wrong, and you should feel bad.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

You're wrong, and you should feel bad.

Beauchemin's season high is only slightly better than Phillips, while Phillips (playing for a weaker team) has a FAR BETTER career plus minus, and was drafted/ranked higher than Beauchemin. If Beauchemin winning 1 cup makes him better, than I suppose Chris Kelly is better than Ovechkin? Explain your logic please..........

PHILLIPS IS ALSO HAVING A FAR SUPERIOR SEASON THIS YEAR, AGAIN, ON A WEAKER TEAM. PHILLIPS IS HANDS DOWN BETTER.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

Kessel trade is not a rip off.

Rask for Raycroft...

Leafs trading a 1st(wich SJ used to trade up and select Couture) for Toskala.

They have had good trades recently because they could uncaringly take on a cap dump.

Also, saying Phillips is better than Beachamin is hilarious.

every trade OTTAWA makes

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

Beauchemin's season high is only slightly better than Phillips, while Phillips (playing for a weaker team) has a FAR BETTER career plus minus, and was drafted/ranked higher than Beauchemin. If Beauchemin winning 1 cup makes him better, than I suppose Chris Kelly is better than Ovechkin? Explain your logic please..........

PHILLIPS IS ALSO HAVING A FAR SUPERIOR SEASON THIS YEAR, AGAIN, ON A WEAKER TEAM. PHILLIPS IS HANDS DOWN BETTER.

What nobody wants to reply instantly to this message? Come on, show me how ridiculous my last statements were!!

 

[Qward]

every trade OTTAWA makes

How is Rundblad doing? Turris is doing well.
How much are we paying Lee to have surgery on both his knees?
Sure am glad we are paying Heatley 7.5M to be a 4th liner.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

How is Rundblad doing? Turris is doing well.
How much are we paying Lee to have surgery on both his knees?
Sure am glad we are paying Heatley 7.5M to be a 4th liner.

Coyotes got Rundblad AND a 2nd rounder, which ended up being Vermette. Put those 2 together and I think the Yotes did quite well and Ottawa technically did overpay, even though Turris is my favorite player on the team.

and the Heatley comment? He was first/ second line while he was here, and was playing better than Michalek, Cheechoo are now when we still had him. Just saying....

 

[Slow Hands]

http://www.ottawasun.com/2013/12/04...ill-happy-with-ben-bishop-cory-conacher-trade

Pretty sure Murray meant that from a moral standpoint - besides, who knows, maybe we should have kept Bishop and moved Andy. He's seen a ton of regression this year. Maybe Bishop gives us the goaltending we've been lacking this year.

 

[God Says No]

How is Rundblad doing? Turris is doing well.

He's doing ok, but his career is still young. Right now the trade is in our favour, but it could change in the next couple years. We also gave up a 2nd in that trade.

How much are we paying Lee to have surgery on both his knees?

As much as we enjoyed Gilroy on the ice.

Sure am glad we are paying Heatley 7.5M to be a 4th liner.

No, we're only paying 6M.

 

[R2010]

Well Bishop for Cony is looking pretty horrendous so far.

Don't know why you hate the bishop trade.

We traded a mid-2nd round pick for a 23-year old (at the time) 3rd line NHLer... Do you know that only 1/4 of all 2nd round picks even become a regular NHLer?

Not to mention adding Bishop gave us wins, helped lehner and also netted us a 4th round pick that became Lindberg/Harpur (depending on who we would have picked).

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

Don't know why you hate the bishop trade.

We traded a mid-2nd round pick for a 23-year old (at the time) 3rd line NHLer... Do you know that only 1/4 of all 2nd round picks even become a regular NHLer?

Not to mention adding Bishop gave us wins, helped lehner and also netted us a 4th round pick that became Lindberg/Harpur (depending on who we would have picked).

Yeah Lindberg seems somewhat promising, although he's a long term project.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

Dear Benny ftw and Stempniaksens,

Chris Phillips is better than Francois Beauchemin. Speak now or forever hold your peace.

 

[Gothenburg 40*]

The truth is, if Ottawa is going to make a trade, they will more than likely have to overpay (in order for it to be worthwhile). That has been the trend for the last few years or so....

 

[Rals]

Don't know why you hate the bishop trade.

We traded a mid-2nd round pick for a 23-year old (at the time) 3rd line NHLer... Do you know that only 1/4 of all 2nd round picks even become a regular NHLer?

Not to mention adding Bishop gave us wins, helped lehner and also netted us a 4th round pick that became Lindberg/Harpur (depending on who we would have picked).

The hate for the Bishop trade comes from not keeping him and Trading Andy; when you hear CC is the best you're going to get you say no.

 

[WhiteLight*]

Beauchemin's season high is only slightly better than Phillips, while Phillips (playing for a weaker team) has a FAR BETTER career plus minus, and was drafted/ranked higher than Beauchemin. If Beauchemin winning 1 cup makes him better, than I suppose Chris Kelly is better than Ovechkin? Explain your logic please..........

PHILLIPS IS ALSO HAVING A FAR SUPERIOR SEASON THIS YEAR, AGAIN, ON A WEAKER TEAM. PHILLIPS IS HANDS DOWN BETTER.

Dear Benny ftw and Stempniaksens,

Chris Phillips is better than Francois Beauchemin. Speak now or forever hold your peace.