Rumor: Trade Rumors and Proposals: Will Chia get us an Xmas gift?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ritchie Valens

Registered User
Sep 24, 2007
29,882
43,081
main trade board is saying the oilers add to any deal for Jones--I disagree

I would be willing to do a one for one deal--I am not willing to add

Not even if the add was Schultz? :laugh:

I took a spin by the main board and saw an interesting proposal...I think it was RNH & Schultz for Jones & Gaustad.
 

GRadio

Energy Line
Aug 16, 2014
393
197
Edmonton
Stamkos' contract was the least compromised one to exist for a star player.
He took as much money as possible and term to take him to free agency and a NMC. He gets precisely what he wants. He'll do the same thing again.
You guys gotta remember that the reason Stamkos demands so much money is because he's unhappy and doesn't like it in Tampa.

If he was happy and in an ideal situation, he'd ask for less. Who wouldn't? He's demanding so much because he wants out. He wants to play in Canada. He wants to play in a hockey city.

See? It's not just us that go through it. I would bet that if an offer was made to play here, in a new arena and with mcdavid, he might be inclined to play in Edmonton over Tampa Bay, Florida. Imagine that.

Not that I want him, or think the oilers should go after him.
 

Jet Walters

Registered User
May 15, 2013
7,438
3,181
Is it possible to have success with such a young group of defensemen? Nurse, Klefbom, Davidson, Reinhart, Jones. Even with the veteran Sekera, that would have to be the youngest defense in the league. I'm really on the fence regarding a RNH for Jones trade, but I have not seen Jones play enough to have a strong opinion on him. For those who have seen him a lot, is he very physically assertive?
 

dustrock

Too Legit To Quit
Sep 22, 2008
8,494
1,421
main trade board is saying the oilers add to any deal for Jones--I disagree

I would be willing to do a one for one deal--I am not willing to add

I'm not even doing one-for-one. Jones is sheltered as heck , RNH isn't. Jones is also an RFA.

No thank you very much.
 

Soundwave

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
74,014
30,129
Jones is actually not having that great of a year, the main board always undervalues our players anyway.

I'd probably do RNH + Fayne (I'd try to get them to take Fayne on instead) for Jones + Hodgson.

That way we can let Schultz walk or trade him as well for whatever and have free cap room in the summer.
 

ChaoticOrange

Registered User
Jun 29, 2008
51,522
31,360
Edmonton
Preds fans on their board seem to think they could get RNH or Johansen without giving up any of Weber, Josi, or Jones. Spitballing Fiala, Ellis, + as the package.

Blech. I wouldn't be at all happy with Ellis being the best piece.
 

Soundwave

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
74,014
30,129
Preds fans on their board seem to think they could get RNH or Johansen without giving up any of Weber, Josi, or Jones. Spitballing Fiala, Ellis, + as the package.

Blech. I wouldn't be at all happy with Ellis being the best piece.

They're dreaming. Oilers hang up in 10 seconds.
 

rasarhdasd

Registered User
Apr 12, 2013
2,846
0
Is it possible to have success with such a young group of defensemen? Nurse, Klefbom, Davidson, Reinhart, Jones. Even with the veteran Sekera, that would have to be the youngest defense in the league. I'm really on the fence regarding a RNH for Jones trade, but I have not seen Jones play enough to have a strong opinion on him. For those who have seen him a lot, is he very physically assertive?

My guess is he wouldn't hesitate to move Reinhart for a veteran D or forward. He acquired and traded players in Boston really quickly and Nurse, Klefbom, Jones would all play above him, then I'm sure there would be another veteran plus Sekera, then Davidson to round out the roster.
 

scb23

Registered User
Jan 5, 2012
509
2
Edmonton
Word is Jones isn't even on the table... He's getting 17-21 min a night so still very sheltered minutes.

I think Jones will be a great player, but his age is my biggest concern. We already have a lot of youth on the blueline:

Klefbom - 22
Reinhart - 21
Nurse - 20

Add Jones - 21 - and that's a lot of youth. A lot.
 

ChaoticOrange

Registered User
Jun 29, 2008
51,522
31,360
Edmonton
Word is Jones isn't even on the table... He's getting 17-21 min a night so still very sheltered minutes.

I think Jones will be a great player, but his age is my biggest concern. We already have a lot of youth on the blueline:

Klefbom - 22
Reinhart - 21
Nurse - 20

Add Jones - 21 - and that's a lot of youth. A lot.

If Jones isn't on the table, Preds fans won't be happy with the calibre of center coming back. They just don't have the pieces otherwise.
 

McDrai

Registered User
Mar 29, 2009
24,706
20,046
Preds fans on their board seem to think they could get RNH or Johansen without giving up any of Weber, Josi, or Jones. Spitballing Fiala, Ellis, + as the package.

Blech. I wouldn't be at all happy with Ellis being the best piece.

No offense to Nashville fans but they're probably the worst (at least on hfboards) in terms of overvaluing their own players. I remember one of them saying that they wouldn't do Josi for Mcdavid
 

BarDownBobo

Registered User
Oct 19, 2012
6,562
3,368
City of Champions
I wonder if Poile might be getting pressure from ownership to go for that young high end C. They're sliding lately, and Colorado is suddenly only 3 points behind them now. They need those playoff games for the extra revenue.
 

McAsuno

Registered User
Jul 10, 2013
27,465
37,839
Edmonton
So Paile wants the likes of Ryjo and RNH but unwilling to trade back Weber, Josi, or Jones. Too bad then.
 

LTIR

Registered User
Nov 8, 2013
27,588
14,801
No offense to Nashville fans but they're probably the worst (at least on hfboards) in terms of overvaluing their own players. I remember one of them saying that they wouldn't do Josi for Mcdavid

Yeh every team has those fans. Can paint the whole fan base with the same brush.
Josi is red hot right... toughest minutes and production wise only behind Hall and Drai in Edmonton.
He is also just hitting his prime.

Would the Oilers fans be the worst if ONE of them prefers Draisatil over Weber or Crosby?
 

ChaoticOrange

Registered User
Jun 29, 2008
51,522
31,360
Edmonton
So Paile wants the likes of Ryjo and RNH but unwilling to trade back Weber, Josi, or Jones. Too bad then.

Yeah, if Ryan Ellis, picks, prospects, and the likes of Colin Wilson is all you're willing to deal and you're after a #1 center, than it just isn't getting done.
 

McAsuno

Registered User
Jul 10, 2013
27,465
37,839
Edmonton
Yeah, if Ryan Ellis, picks, prospects, and the likes of Colin Wilson is all you're willing to deal and you're after a #1 center, than it just isn't getting done.

That won't get RNH; let alone Ryjo. Poille's delusional if he thinks Ellis, picks, prospects, Wilson, other pieces will get Ryjo or RNH. Its either Weber, Josi, or Jones that will get the deal done. If not, then the oilers will look elsewhere for Dman rather than getting fleeced.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad