Why 5 seasons?
Over the last 4 he's 10th.
Over the last 3 he's T12th.
Over the last 2 he's T19th.
This season he's T77th.
Notice a trend? Calling him a top 5 goal scorer implies he's going to be a top 5 goal scorer in the foreseeable future. Do you expect that to be the case?
He's a 30/65 winger. Which is good, very good even. But let's calm down with the hyperbole.
The trend you present has a bit to do with the talent Patch plays with in our top 6 and our center depth but I get your point. The only trend I see is a slight up/down in each year. This year he likely does not score 30 and it has a lot to do with our top 6 talent.
2011-2012: 33 goals in 79 games (Ranks 17th)
2012-2013: 15 goals in 44 games, which prorates to 28 goals (Ranks 43rd)
2013-2014: 39 goals in 73 games (ranks 4th)
2014-2015: 37 goals in 82 games (ranks 5th)
2015-2016: 30 goals in 81 games (ranks 19th)
2016-2017: 35 goals in 81 games (ranks 8th)
2017-2018: 16 goals in 53 games which prorates to 25 goals so far.
Compared to Benn who is tied with Patch with 157 goals over the last 5 years including this year...
- Over the last 4 years, Benn is ranked 7th (Patch 10th)
- Over the last 3 years, Benn is ranked 8th (Patch tied 11th)
- Over the last 2 years, Benn is ranked 26th with 47 goals (Patch is 18th)
I think Patch is a legit goal scorer in this league. He could be top 5 one year or top 20 another year but he has proven over a few seasons that he is a top 5 or top 10 NHL goal scorer. Of course there will be some who passes him as the young kids start to prove themselves but the point is he has a elite level shot and can score from anywhere.