HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #86: 2023-2024 Season

[Runner77]

I Just can't

I hadn’t ordered one since last summer. Wolfed down 3 slices yesterday, guess I was due.

 

[Kiss Under the Guy]

I'm not around here as much as I used to so sorry if it had already been discussed, but in the Sortie de zone podcast this week, Simon-Olivier Lorange said he felt Montembeault could be traded, since he'd fetch more than the others. He also said that so far, there never was a clear vote of confidence towards him.

Honestly, as much as I am behind the full rebuild, I don't think I'd be happy with this trade (unless it was for a A+ prospect, of course, but at market value....)

 

[The Great Weal]

If we do trade Monahan at the deadline, hopefully he will resign with us in the offseason Plekanec style.

 

[Miller Time]

Then, since he is probably going to be a 70 point forward,, the only question about Robertson is health.

Interesting... I'd say it's very questionable that he becomes a 70pt player. But certainly if one felt he was a lock to be a first line winger of that caliber, the price they'd be willing to pay is considerably more than a late 1st... Though not sure why anyone would expect the Laffs to trade him at all, let alone just to unload an expiring contract

 

[Vachon23]

If we do trade Monahan at the deadline, hopefully he will resign with us in the offseason Plekanec style.

I’m not sure I want to sign Monahan on a long term deal with his injuries issues

 

[HuGort]

I’m not sure I want to sign Monahan on a long term deal with his injuries issues

With Monahan Habs have to weight out what they can get for him. Against his value on the ice and his character in young dressing room.

 

[Mrb1p]

With Monahan Habs have to weight out what they can get for him. Against his valve on the ice and his character in young dressing room

Characters nice and all but teams will absolutely throw the sink at you for a 2m top 6 c. Especially a versatile vet like Money.

Avs: allen+Monahan vs Byram, Cogliano and Provetsov.

We can then flip Matheson and use Guhle/Byram/X.

Arizona, Minny, Edmonton, Boston, florida, detroit, nyr, tb, winnipeg and arizona also have an open window and need a 2c upgrade.

 

[nhlfan9191]

With Monahan Habs have to weight out what they can get for him. Against his value on the ice and his character in young dressing room.

It’s tough because when he’s healthy he’s a great player. But I’m not sure we can rely on that. If he’s healthy enough and the return is good, I think we have to take it.

 

[HuGort]

Characters nice and all but teams will absolutely throw the sink at you for a 2m top 6 c. Especially a versatile vet like Money.

Avs: allen+Monahan vs Byram, Cogliano and Provetsov.

We can then flip Matheson and use Guhle/Byram/X.

Arizona, Minny, Edmonton, Boston, florida, detroit, nyr, tb, winnipeg and arizona also have an open window and need a 2c upgrade.

No way Habs do that deal. Habs going to want high to move Monahan. A first and solid prospect. Hughes will want to try and use his own pick on a MBN or Lindstrom. Another first on Ryder or Greentree type. If he can't, likely trade it similar to Dach or Newhook.

Habs have no interest in vets like Cogliano. Provetsov Habs already have similar in Primeau. Byram Habs already over stacked on D. You just pushing somebody ice time out while losing Monahan.

 

[Mrb1p]

With some cap dumping picks and players added, we could acquire guys like this for Monahan, just gotta get creative:

Geekie or Guenther in Arizona.
Swayman Or Lysell in Boston.
Edvinsson or Kasper in Detroit .
Holloway and Bourgeault in Edmonton .
Sawchyn and Samoskevich in Florida.
Wallstedt, Yurov, Heidt or Ohgren in Minny.
Othmann in NY
Lambert or Lucius in Winnipeg.

Id rather those guys that are a bit further ahead in their development than a 20-30 range pick thats gonna be useful 5 years from now.

No way Habs do that deal. Habs going to want high to move Monahan. A first and solid prospect. Hughes will want to try and use his own pick on a MBN or Lindstrom. Another first on Ryder or Greentree type. If he can't, likely trade it similar to Dach or Newhook.

Habs have no interest in vets like Cogliano. Provetsov Habs already have similar in Primeau. Byram Habs already over stacked on D. You just pushing somebody ice time out while losing Monahan.

Honestly Im pretty sure the Avs say no anyway, Byram is way too good.

Id much rather get a prospect or young player than a low end first. Cogliano is just a stop gap vet, Provestsov is an AHL goaltender. Running with Montambeault and Primeau in the NHL.

 

[HuGort]

With some cap dumping picks and players added, we could acquire guys like this for Monahan, just gotta get creative:

Geekie or Guenther in Arizona.
Swayman Or Lysell in Boston.
Edvinsson or Kasper in Detroit .
Holloway and Bourgeault in Edmonton .
Sawchyn and Samoskevich in Florida.
Wallstedt, Yurov, Heidt or Ohgren in Minny.
Othmann in NY
Lambert or Lucius in Winnipeg.

Id rather those guys that are a bit further ahead in their development than a 20-30 range pick thats gonna be useful 5 years from now.


Honestly Im pretty sure the Avs say no anyway, Byram is way too good.

Id much rather get a prospect or young player than a low end first. Cogliano is just a stop gap vet, Provestsov is an AHL goaltender. Running with Montambeault and Primeau in the NHL.

Habs already set on L defense. Just pushing Hutson out. No gain. Pretty sure Guhle and Wifi are solid for future.

 

[Mrb1p]

Habs already set on L defense. Just pushing Hutson out. No gain. Pretty sure Guhle and Wifi are solid for future.

As of now, Hutson is struggling to defend in the NCAA. Hes still 2 years away minumum. We can worry about the embarrassment of riches then. Trade the odd man out, cash out and fill a void.

Not trading for another Guhle because we have Hutson would be beyond silly.

 

[The Great Weal]

I’m not sure I want to sign Monahan on a long term deal with his injuries issues

Not longterm, but like a 3 year deal. He's a key part of the team and is only 29 years old, will be hard to replace him. I don't think we should completely remove all the talent of the team.

 

[HuGort]

As of now, Hutson is struggling to defend in the NCAA. Hes still 2 years away minumum. We can worry about the embarrassment of riches then. Trade the odd man out, cash out and fill a void.

Not trading for another Guhle because we have Hutson would be beyond silly.

Hutson has high enough liking among prospect pundits on this board

 

[Vachon23]

Not longterm, but like a 3 year deal. He's a key part of the team and is only 29 years old, will be hard to replace him. I don't think we should completely remove all the talent of the team.

Yes but Monahan will want more then 3 years and someone desperate is gonna give more then 3 years on the FA market

 

[Sterling Archer]

The only way I’d keep Monahan is if Habs can trade Dvo for a 1st or high 2nd. Otherwise gimme da loot for Mony!

 

[Joseph Nathan]

With some cap dumping picks and players added, we could acquire guys like this for Monahan, just gotta get creative:

Geekie or Guenther in Arizona.
Swayman Or Lysell in Boston.
Edvinsson or Kasper in Detroit .
Holloway and Bourgeault in Edmonton .
Sawchyn and Samoskevich in Florida.
Wallstedt, Yurov, Heidt or Ohgren in Minny.
Othmann in NY
Lambert or Lucius in Winnipeg.

Id rather those guys that are a bit further ahead in their development than a 20-30 range pick thats gonna be useful 5 years from now.


Honestly Im pretty sure the Avs say no anyway, Byram is way too good.

Id much rather get a prospect or young player than a low end first. Cogliano is just a stop gap vet, Provestsov is an AHL goaltender. Running with Montambeault and Primeau in the NHL.

Lol dude most of those prospect are untouchable, Minnesota doesn't trade prospects or 1st round picks, Minnesota has no contract to dump and they won't ever trade for Sean Monahan whose hated by their gm bill Guerin! Minnesota also doesn't need a C!

If you think alot of these team are giving up top prospect you like in fantasy world

Characters nice and all but teams will absolutely throw the sink at you for a 2m top 6 c. Especially a versatile vet like Money.

Avs: allen+Monahan vs Byram, Cogliano and Provetsov.

We can then flip Matheson and use Guhle/Byram/X.

Arizona, Minny, Edmonton, Boston, florida, detroit, nyr, tb, winnipeg and arizona also have an open window and need a 2c upgrade.

NPR sean Monahan doesn't ever get teaded to Minnesota, these has been talked about for years, and jpel Eriksson Ek is one of the best two way C in the game as 2c, Marco Rossi has ascended to 1c and Hartman has now become 3c.

 

[Mrb1p]

Lol dude most of those prospect are untouchable, Minnesota doesn't trade prospects or 1st round picks, Minnesota has no contract to dump and they won't ever trade for Sean Monahan whose hated by their gm bill Guerin! Minnesota also doesn't need a C!

If you think alot of these team are giving up top prospect you like in fantasy world


NPR sean Monahan doesn't ever get teaded to Minnesota, these has been talked about for years, and jpel Eriksson Ek is one of the best two way C in the game as 2c, Marco Rossi has ascended to 1c and Hartman has now become 3c.

Those are all 2Cs. Monahan is producing.

 

[Joseph Nathan]

Those are all 2Cs. Monahan is producing.

Once again your delusional! Minnesota wouldn't ever trade any of those prospects and their gm bill Guerin literally doesn't like sean Monahan lol. Rossi, Hartman and Joel Eriksson Ek are better than Monah/ Eriksson Ek and Hartman are under long term contract and Rossi has become so amazing, he's ascended to 1c,

Their gm has never traded any top prospects and those players you listed are untouchable for them, Monahan isn't better than them

 

[Vachon23]

their gm bill Guerin literally doesn't like sean Monahan lol.

You talk to him ?

 

[Joseph Nathan]

You talk to him ?

This was reported in Minnesota for years and their beat reporters made it clear it was a person thing about Sean Monahan. Lol they also made clear their gm wouldn't take him on before he was traded to Montreal with a 1st, that's just a fact

Most of those teams will never trade those prospects, Minnesota prospects are especially untouchable lol dude, their gm bill Guerin doesn't trade prospects and has never traded 1st round picks, he traded a 2nd round pick once in 6 years and it was for Fleury

 

[sampollock]

I agree with posters here, love to keep Sean M but the valve of a trade may be to good to refuse.

but I would really like a good scoring prospect rather then a pick. this team needs a young guy now, not in 3/4 years away. Might be hard to get but I trust Kent is the man to do it.

 

[Sterling Archer]

With Calgary likely losing 3 or their top defenders this year, they’d make great trading partner for the Habs, given their depth. Wonder if Hughes goes back to that well.

 

[Miller Time]

This was reported in Minnesota for years and their beat reporters made it clear it was a person thing about Sean Monahan. Lol they also made clear their gm wouldn't take him on before he was traded to Montreal with a 1st, that's just a fact

Most of those teams will never trade those prospects, Minnesota prospects are especially untouchable lol dude, their gm bill Guerin doesn't trade prospects and has never traded 1st round picks, he traded a 2nd round pick once in 6 years and it was for Fleury

Wild recently gave up on Addison... he had been a Guerin pick and one of their top prospects before he fell out of favor in the last 12 months or so.

will be interesting to see what Monahan goes for, but if he stays healthy and as productive as he's been, i think there will be at least a few GMs competing to acquire him, and the "winner" will undoubtedly have to part with some prospects/picks they'd rather not move.

i think the Jets are a sneaky bet to make a hard push for him... and they have a few fwd prospects that could be of interest to Hughes (and getting our 2nd back may be of interest should there be an RFA offer sheet target out there worth exploring)

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

With Calgary likely losing 3 or their top defenders this year, they’d make great trading partner for the Habs, given their depth. Wonder if Hughes goes back to that well.

Lindholm, probably their best forward is also UFA