HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #86: 2023-2024 Season

[HuGort]

Hes been healthy for a while now. But yes theres a concussion history.

I think deal be off for me then. We have hands full of injury problems now. I didn't know about the concussion thing.

 

[sampollock]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

 

[morhilane]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

I doubt there is a single team in the league ready to take Campbell's multi-year contract at $5m and only get a 1st first for it.

 

[bcv]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

I’m not even sure Bourgeault and their 1st is enough to take on Campbell’s contract let alone give them Monty on top of it. Why would the Habs do the Oilers a favor?

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

Not enough.

I'd want the 2025 1st, too.

 

[BoneHutson]

Not enough.

I'd want the 2025 1st, too.

Id be willing to do Soup, Holloway, 2024 first (top 3 protect) and 2025 first (top 16 protect) for Monty and Kovacevic but not worth it otherwise.

Youd have to hope for the oilers to stay bad so that we get an extra top 10 pick, maybe making the dream of reuniting Celebrini and Eiserman (two best friends) together real.

 

[Habitant#1]

Habs got a 1st rounder for taking on Matheson's 1x$6M. Surely taking on 4x$5M is worth at least 3x that.

 

[sampollock]

I doubt there is a single team in the league ready to take Campbell's multi-year contract at $5m and only get a 1st first for it.

agreed... see IF this is real or not.. Make Ken H pay Kent

 

[Sterling Archer]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

Not enough. Habs got a 1st for taking one year of Monny. 5 years of useless Campbell is worth the value of at least three 1sts IMO. Add Monty to the deal and that's more.

a 1st and Bourgeault is a no go for me.

 

[sampollock]

Not enough. Habs got a 1st for taking one year of Monny. 5 years of useless Campbell is worth the value of at least three 1sts IMO. Add Monty to the deal and that's more.

a 1st and Bourgeault is a no go for me.

They would buy Jack C out for sure
But they need to bleed EDM

But really, would one of the hab goalies really help them?

 

[417]

I doubt there is a single team in the league ready to take Campbell's multi-year contract at $5m and only get a 1st first for it.

Especially not this team that has to do cap gymnastics every year with Price 10.5M contract every year

Unless the Oilers are making a SIGNIFICANT overpay, there's no chance the Habs are tying up that many salary dollars on goalies.

I’m not even sure Bourgeault and their 1st is enough to take on Campbell’s contract let alone give them Monty on top of it. Why would the Habs do the Oilers a favor?

The Habs would be paying Allen + Campbell + Price over 18M annually.

What the Oilers would have to add on top of that to make even fathomable can't even be imagined without anyone dying of laughter.

 

[HabzSauce]

Man what a sad team the oilers are lol

Have to spend multiple 1sts just to get a slight upgrade in net lmao. Holland really f*cked them

 

[Sterling Archer]

They would buy Jack C out for sure
But they need to bleed EDM

But really, would one of the hab goalies really help them?

That will be a looong buyout so yes, it’s gonna be expensive for Edmonton to move or they can buy him out themselves if n the off-season and further screw their cap with McJesus and Drai contracts coming up in the next couple years.

 

[MarkovsKnee]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

I'd want Holloway over Bourgault, although both are so-so prospects, but I think Holloway has an NHL game.

Definitely want more than a 1st in draft picks. Monty is cheap. We take on a huge contract AND we free up $2,5m in cap space for the Oilers.

I guess technically you can call Holloway plus a 2024 1st, two 1sts, but then I want two 2nds along with that.

Holloway, 2024 1st, 2025 & 2026 2nds.

 

[morhilane]

Man what a sad team the oilers are lol

Have to spend multiple 1sts just to get a slight upgrade in net lmao. Holland really f*cked them

Technically, Holland would be spending multiple 1st to get cap space and not to get a slight upgrade in net.

 

[salbutera]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

Yes as long as 1st rounder is unprotected

 

[HuGort]

Just his theory but.......
Dreger revealed that the two general managers are in frequent communication at the moment.

He added that regarding a trade involving goaltender Jack Campbell 's big contract , Dreger stressed that he would be surprised if discussions had not taken place between the two teams.

He also clarified that the Oilers had considered offloading Campbell's contract, but that doing so required at least a first-round pick.

The question then arises: if Kent Hughes received an offer similar to the one discussed below, would you be in favor of this trade?

In Montreal: 1st round 2024 + Xavier Bourgault + Jack Campbell

In Edmonton: Samuel Montembeault

I pass personally. Bourgault I have no use for. He's Drouinish. Monty is worth a 2nd. So we are getting an upgrade from Oilers 2nd to their first for eating a Gallagher type contract? Pass, hard pass.

 

[Ezpz]

I pass personally. Bourgault I have no use for. He's Drouinish. Monty is worth a 2nd. So we are getting an upgrade from Oilers 2nd to their first for eating a Gallagher type contract? Pass, hard pass.

Yeah gotta be more assets than that to take Campbell.

 

[Sterling Archer]

Edmonton down 5-2. Carolina hit a post and had one called back. Could’ve been 7-2.

 

[Deus ex machina]

I'd want Holloway over Bourgault, although both are so-so prospects, but I think Holloway has an NHL game.

Definitely want more than a 1st in draft picks. Monty is cheap. We take on a huge contract AND we free up $2,5m in cap space for the Oilers.

I guess technically you can call Holloway plus a 2024 1st, two 1sts, but then I want two 2nds along with that.

Holloway, 2024 1st, 2025 & 2026 2nds.

That seems like a fair price.

2024 1st and a 2nd to dump Campbell since the 1st will probably be top 20.
Holloway and a 2nd for Montembeault.

But i don't see EDM doing that.

They can always shop Campbell to other teams and see if they can dump him for less.
And they don't absolutely have to dump Campbell to fit Montembeault at only 1M.
They can wait the offseason to buy him out and keep their picks.

 

[The Gr8 Dane]

Kent was watching that entire oilers game like
this

 

[The Great Weal]

Monahan came with a 1st for a one year cap dump. At the very least the Oilers 1st needs to be unprotected if they want to dump Campbell.

 

[waitin425]

Oilers are going to be super desperate. It's time to take them to the cleaners!

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

Raanta left the game ad a precautionary reason.

Monty to Edmonton

Allen/Primeau to Carolina

 

[Runner77]