Toggle sidebar

HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #84: Off-Season edition

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Scriptor said:
Can use the pick, or pick + to land a player that helps right now from elsewhere. a trade with Montreal would not be the end all to WIN's musings or situation.
Click to expand...

Sure they can, but that still might not be what they are looking for in the end.
I mean, according to many, Anderson is worth a 1st +.....
According to many PLD would cost something along those lines.
That's an example.

Pacioretty was a 65-70 points guy that didn't get an actual 1st round pick in the return (Yes Suzuki was an ex-1st, but we do have some of that too). All I'm saying is that it's not a given that it would actually take that Florida pick to get him.
 
sampollock said:

Post-Game Talk: - ITS OVER- Did we make a huge mistake on Pierre-Luc Dubois Thread?

Here's my attempt at a single thread to discuss PLD so he doesn't take over every single other thread. Consider this like a safe space. A trust tree if you will -a place where we can ask questions like: Does he really want to come here or is he just saying he does? Should we? or Shouldn't we...
forums.hfboards.com forums.hfboards.com
Click to expand...
You said 'attempt', so, obviously, you knew it wouldn't work, right?

Milhouse40 said:
Sure they can, but that still might not be what they are looking for in the end.
I mean, according to many, Anderson is worth a 1st +.....
According to many PLD would cost something along those lines.
That's an example.

Pacioretty was a 65-70 points guy that didn't get an actual 1st round pick in the return (Yes Suzuki was an ex-1st, but we do have some of that too). All I'm saying is that it's not a given that it would actually take that Florida pick to get him.
Click to expand...
All I'm saying is that it's not a given that it would actually take that Florida pick to get him.

Agree. It might not.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Miller Time
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
 
  • Haha
  • Wow
Reactions: HabsMD97 and jrom
Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...
He’s hitting his career high at age 33/34. Interesting but who knows how soon he will hit his decline.

If we sell Anderson I’d be all over hometown boy Alex Killorn on a front loaded deal that has him retire before it’s over. But so would many other teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Runner77
Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...
After Hoffman, Armia, Dvorak, Gallagher, Anderson, Drouin,

Not only should we sign Killorn, but i think we should also be in Gustav Nyquist and Jason Zucker !
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: The Gr8 Dane, Boss Man Hughes and Svart
Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...
$6M for a 34-35 yo Killorn? No thank you.

Getting career highs playing for Tampa, does not equate to him getting anywhere close to that playing on this version of Canadiens.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Gr8 Dane, Kudo Shinichi, The Nightman and 5 others
Proposal:

Florida 1st plus Evans, Harris and Primeau for Swayman and 2023 2nd.

Boston is in a bit of a cap crunch and could use cost controlled players.

Habs giving up above-average depth players who nevertheless will not be part of a core-11.

Habs then trade Allen for a mid-round pick and sign Dichow and Vrbetic to get organizational depth and callup options.
 
ReHabs said:
He’s hitting his career high at age 33/34. Interesting but who knows how soon he will hit his decline.

If we sell Anderson I’d be all over hometown boy Alex Killorn on a front loaded deal that has him retire before it’s over. But so would many other teams.
Click to expand...
A front-loaded deal would have to be overblown for him to retire before the end of the contract because the second year of a two-year contract can't be less than half of the first year.

So, a 12M total contract canMt be more than 8M in the first year and 4M in the 2nd year.

If he wanted to play one more year for 8M, fine...
 
BaseballCoach said:
Proposal:

Florida 1st plus Evans, Harris and Primeau for Swayman and 2023 2nd.

Boston is in a bit of a cap crunch and could use cost controlled players.

Habs giving up above-average depth players who nevertheless will not be part of a core-11.

Habs then trade Allen for a mid-round pick and sign Dichow and Vrbetic to get organizational depth and callup options.
Click to expand...

Swayman isn't very good.. that's an extremely friendly goalie system in Boston.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoelWarlord, nhlfan9191, MarkovsKnee and 1 other person
BaseballCoach said:
Proposal:

Florida 1st plus Evans, Harris and Primeau for Swayman and 2023 2nd.

Boston is in a bit of a cap crunch and could use cost controlled players.

Habs giving up above-average depth players who nevertheless will not be part of a core-11.

Habs then trade Allen for a mid-round pick and sign Dichow and Vrbetic to get organizational depth and callup options.
Click to expand...
That's too much to give up for Swayman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Gr8 Dane, Boss Man Hughes and Sterling Archer
BaseballCoach said:
Proposal:

Florida 1st plus Evans, Harris and Primeau for Swayman and 2023 2nd.

Boston is in a bit of a cap crunch and could use cost controlled players.

Habs giving up above-average depth players who nevertheless will not be part of a core-11.

Habs then trade Allen for a mid-round pick and sign Dichow and Vrbetic to get organizational depth and callup options.
Click to expand...
Nobody would take Allen for free right now. And why are people so anxious to do something that involves getting rid of that Florida first round pick. We need prospects, not another backup goalie. We had basically nothing to sell this year so we need every prospect we can get.
 
Hughes has already said no UFA signings this summer, and hopefully he stays true to that. We need to move players as it is. Stay out of it.

Even if we do nothing but re-sign RFAs, and let UFAs walk (except Laval's captain), we still have too many signed players for next year.

Heineman - Suzuki - Caufield
Slafkovsky - Dach - Anderson
Hoffman - Dvorak - Gallagher
RHP - Evans - Armia
Ylonen, Pezzetta

Pitlick waived
Gurianov traded, or not qualified
Farrell AHL

Matheson - Xhekaj
Guhle - Savard
Harris - Kovacevic
Barron

Edmundson traded
Wideman waived

We're in transition between MB's shit team, and Hughes bringing in young players, and the older guys are taking up space still.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paddy17, Runner77 and Weltschmerz
nhlfan9191 said:
Nobody would take Allen for free right now. And why are people so anxious to do something that involves getting rid of that Florida first round pick. We need prospects, not another backup goalie. We had basically nothing to sell this year so we need every prospect we can get.
Click to expand...
Getting a 24 year old NHL goalie with a career .920 SVP in 85 games is at least as good as a middle of the 1st round pick plus non-core NHL roster players.

Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...
Pass on Killorn, unless it is a cheap one year deal near end of camp, if we need him, and if no one signed him yet.
 
BaseballCoach said:
Proposal:

Florida 1st plus Evans, Harris and Primeau for Swayman and 2023 2nd.

Boston is in a bit of a cap crunch and could use cost controlled players.

Habs giving up above-average depth players who nevertheless will not be part of a core-11.

Habs then trade Allen for a mid-round pick and sign Dichow and Vrbetic to get organizational depth and callup options.
Click to expand...
Horrific for MTL
 
  • Like
Reactions: nhlfan9191, The Gr8 Dane, Whalers Fan and 2 others
BaseballCoach said:
OK, how about our second instead of
the first with a second coming back.

Swayman is not 25 yet and has good career numbers, even in college - .939 SVP his final year.
Click to expand...
Boston isn't giving him up barring overpayment. Alot of teams for years are doing 1a, 1b situation. In what world do you think Boston will add anything?
 
Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...

If the Habs eventually opt for signing Killorn, it should be as a short-term middle-6 LW to help shelter the development of a young NHL center.

So unless the Habs draft a center that could reasonably play top-9 next season (Bedard, Fantilli, Carlsson) - and both Hoffman and Dvorak are dealt this summer! - I don’t see a plausible reason to target Killorn, especially since Slafkovsky/RHP/Heineman/Farrell could in principle fill the bottom-9 LW spots behind Caufield next year.
 
Joseph Nathan said:
Boston isn't giving him up barring overpayment. Alot of teams for years are doing 1a, 1b situation. In what world do you think Boston will add anything?
Click to expand...
Swayman is RFA and will command a big increase. Boston has cap issues and needs cheap cost controlled depth players.

Swayman can be the 1A for Montreal with Monty while Dobes and Dichow play AHL and Vrbetic ECHL.

Habs have more of a need for core players (they are not at 11 yet) than depth players, and we already have Monty, Dvorak, RHP, Ylonen, Gallagher, Armia, Xhekaj and Savard for eight of the nine depth slots, and Pezzetta and Kovacevic for two of the three spare spots.

For 2023-24 then our top 11 are:

7 forwards -
Suzuki​
Caufield​
Dach​
Anderson​
Unknown (2023 draft pick or Dubois?? or other trade target?)​
Hoffman (one final year, then is replaced with better)​
Heineman (on 3rd line)​
​
3 defencemen -
Matheson​
Guhle​
Barron (that's a stretch, really need someone better)​
​
Starting Goalie
Swayman​
 
Last edited:
Stompin Paul Peller said:
Killorn be good UFA signing this summer. A left shot, 25 goal scorer with size and grit. Make a nice fit in Caufield line. At 34 he's not getting long term contract anywhere. Habs 2 years, 12 million be ideal.
Click to expand...
I'm thinking we can do much better than this. Killorn was pretty bad last year although he seems to have picked it up this season. I actually think he's the perfect age for the Pittsburgh Penguins.:sarcasm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boss Man Hughes
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom