This seems pretty fair. I'd be basing this on no retention which I think you all have mentioned in the past is not really your thing, and I can understand that with there being multiple years left on the deal. The Canes are in a decent position to take on full salary of Duchene. at least for this year. We have *some* bigger decisions to make in the next 2 years so theoretically if we were able to get $1-2 retained and up the offer.
But as is I'd say 1st + 3rd/4th + prospect(s) would work.
Morrow and Nikishin are off limits for us, but Drury, Suzuki, Rees, Honka, Bokk, Gunler, etc. are up for grabs. We've got a pretty good array of forwards. I'd say less so for D, just because Morrow and Nikishin are our two best prospects and they are both D so it falls off more after that.