A key in this deal is that the leafs are getting 2 guys who will slot lower in their lineup than they did in colorado, and the avs are getting a player that will slot higher in their lineup than he did in ours.
beyond telling us something about the quality of the two teams, this should also make it easier for the leafs' adds to look good relative to role, while it might make it tougher for kadri to do the same.
Much of the Avs' fans frustrations with Kerfoot was seeing a kid who looked real good as a 23yr old rookie then struggle when asked to play a bigger role in year 2 - they needed a legit 2nd line center and were hopeful Kerfoot could be it, but he couldn't handle that kind of offensive responsibility in his 2nd year at age 24. They needed another offensive catalyst beyond their top line and nobody, including kerfoot, was able to do that. That likely led to a bunch of frustration from the fans. For us, we don't need Kerfoot to be a 2nd line impact type player - he'll slot in our 3rd line and will have to dominate down there to even get consideration to move up higher in the lineup. Here we don't need an offensive catalyst, just a solid possession player with quality complimentary offense. He won't even be the best offensive guy outside the top 6, let alone a top 6 offensive player like he was in colorado.
With Barrie, too - Avs fans loved him, and for good reason. But they also had to deal with the frustration of him not being a guy they could really put in the tough matchups, like we do with Rielly. Here in toronto, Barrie will have less responsibility, which should allow us to enjoy his strengths without getting as frustrated by his weaknesses.
Now Kadri is a very interesting case, because while he wasn't very good in a depth role last year, and while he's going to be asked to fill a much bigger role for the Avs going forward......kadri may be one of the rare players who actually thrives (and needs?) bigger responsibility to shine. It certainly would help explain why naz was such a nonentity much of last year with his demotion, and is definitely a more pleasing explanation that he's hitting an early decline like other small gritty players have in the past. I love Naz, and was super disappointed with him last year - so hopefully the bigger role rejuvenates him and he gets back to being the impact two-way player he was the previous 2yrs.