Off Sides
Registered User
- Sep 8, 2008
- 9,755
- 5,585
I don't know why you think that's the case. We don't even know why or to what extent there's a problem with DeAngelo. However, we obviously don't have some rock-solid commitment to character at all costs or else we wouldn't have taken the gamble on acquiring DeAngelo in the first place.
You're making it out to be an either/or choice, like the Rangers have to choose character or talent. They can choose both. How many incredibly talented guys play in the NHL without characters concerns? Probably 100x more than those who have documented character issues. I mean sure, you can find a handful of stars who have done bad things either before or after they made it, but you can find tons more who haven't. I don't think it's a problem that the Rangers are focused on the latter group.
Patty Kane is a tool. He was also an established star when he ran into issues. Detroit got rid of Avery pretty early on because they said he didn't respect the game; LA eventually moved on after the bullying and refusing to practice. Downie is a dirtbag, and should have been thrown out of the NHL years ago--I would not take him on my team under any circumstance. Carter got traded to a place he didn't want to be right before his NTC kicked in, sulked and loafed through his tenure in Columbus, so they had enough and got rid of him. Richards was a star when the sex and partying stuff picked up. Then after turning it around in LA, he gets terminated for drugs. Evander was an established player long before the assault stuff.
From those examples, Downie is the only guy who wasn't already being a productive player established in the league when his issues cropped up (and he's just awful). He's the only parallel to DeAngelo (far worse though). Kane(s), Carter, Richards, even Avery--they all had "made it." And even then, the latter three were given up on, some multiple times. DeAngelo hasn't made it as a productive regular. He doesn't get the same leeway.
Who was Washington's bad boy? Wilson? Dirty player, but there were never character or work ethic concerns with him. Ovechkin is lazy at times. He's also possibly the greatest goal scorer ever. Pittsburgh before that? Sestito is a thug, but same thing, not a "difficult" player. And then your guys--Chicago with Kane, LA with Richards. Established stars who got into ****. I have no doubt that Rangers would be playing the Patty Kane or Mike Richards of 2009, despite their issues. Either way, it's not like you need "troubled players" to win. You can win with a good character group.
We've also drafted Lakatos, who has issues, and they've ruined his chances of every getting a deal. We took Sean Day, a guy known, right or wrong, for being fat and lazy and not committed to practicing. They only got rid of Robin Kovacs because he asked to be released. A couple years prior they took Duclair. They have no problem taking chances on guys, or working with guys with problems. Just because some people feel it's wrong to sit out DeAngelo for whatever issues he's having without even knowing what those issues are, doesn't make it so.
How does DeAngelo make it as a regular if they are not going to play him?
Rangers played Duclair, and traded him.
Philly played their players, before and even after that dry island thing was going on and then traded them. LA seemed to deal with them just fine.
Evander Kane was played before and after they threw his tracksuit into the shower. San Jose seems to be dealing with him fine so far.
Even Detroit played Avery, at least enough to put him into a trade.
Rangers gave Jared Stoll more of a chance than they are giving DeAngelo, Ryan Malone, Carcillo, Purinton, Avery.
Either DeAngelo has done something so bad that the Rangers are rightfully not giving him a chance, or he has not and the Rangers are applying a different standard to him than they have in the past.
It's not like I am saying DeAngelo should be played and stay on the Rangers, I am saying more of less that could be an option or they could at least play him enough to do with him what they did with Duclair.