I love the fans who need to try and justify a W or L, like it even matters in a pretty even fight like that. Seriously, what difference does it even make who got the slight W? Is it a big insult to the guy throwing down that he slightly lost a fight, or a chest pounding achievement if they slightly won the fight?
The point is you have yo deal and answer to these players. Whether your tough guy wins or loses. The team still has to deal with these players.
Neither one of these players randomly grab players and start swinging. So props to them both for actually confirming to throw down before having to do it.