I'm going to do a little stat hunting here. Curious what teams that won the Cup the last 10 years had as far as offensive talent. Let's take a look at the top 90 forwards and see how many were on each Cup team according to PPG and the number after is how many forwards the Preds had in the top 90 that same season.
2013 - Chicago 4/1
2012 - Los Angeles 3/2
2011 - Boston 3/1
2010 - Chicago 4/1
2009 - Pittsburgh 2/3
2008 - Detroit 2/4
2007 - Anaheim 3 (That didn't include Getzlaf or Perry)/7 (including Forsberg)
2006 - Carolina 6/3
2004 - Tampa Bay 5/2
2003 - New Jersey 0/1
So 4 out of the 10 years we had more top 90 scorers than the team that won the Cup. The 2007 season was the one that was the amazing stat. 7 top 90 scorers? Pretty remarkable. Now granted, this doesn't take into account defensemen scoring as well but that 2007 team had the firepower to do damage and was eliminated in 5 games. The other years we had more top 90 scorers was only by 1 each year and one of those years we didn't make the playoffs. The years we had more than Pittsburgh and Detroit, well the 4 guys that were top 90 scorers were Crosby, Malkin, Datsyuk and Zetterberg. Enough said.
Now here's the one stat that really rung true through all of this, only one top 30 scorer judged by PPG in that 10 year sample. One. Even in the year we had 7 top 90 scorers, we didn't have one in the top 30. The one time we did have one in the top 30, Sullivan, he missed about 25 games. so would he have kept up his pace over a full season? Who knows but regardless if he did or didn't, that screams to me we have never had the game changers, elite players or even great forwards up front. I'd have to go back and check for sure but I think Erat hit the list the most of any Preds player in that time frame.
I could've gone nuts with this but it's been a long day and I'm in a lot of pain but just wanted to illustrate what this team has done with good offensive talent yet we've never had upper echelon players that you need to have to compete for the Cup. I'm sure we can find reasons why it never happened as to our playoff failures but to me, the lack of game breakers up front has been an achilles heal for many years and until we draft and/or develop, trade for or sign via free agency or some combo of all those, we will struggle mightily. I find it hard to believe in 15 years we haven't been able to develop one forward who could make the top 30 scorers at the forward position. That's really sad and for all the accolades Trotz gets for being the coach he is, this is one thing he has not been able to do. His resume with defensemen and goalies is stellar. Forwards, not so much. The thing is, you have 12 forwards on most nights, you'd think someone would take that leap. Well, it hasn't happened and won't happen as long as he's around. We can hope that it will happen but until it does, his resume is massively incomplete. Yes, we haven't had high picks but that shouldn't matter, guys develop from different draft positions every single year yet we haven't hit on any of them. This is on Poile too but to me this is mostly on Trotz and his insistence on his forwards playing a complete two way game.
You play to guys strengths and if a guy is better offensively than defensively, sure, we'll give up goals with him on the ice but hopefully his offensive stats are better and we score more when he's on the ice than give up. If we would let Wilson or Smith or Forsberg play their games, would we be worse off than we are now? Let them go out and have fun and play offensively. Let them do what they do. We might be surprise by the results. It's not like we're not giving up 5 or 6 goals on any given night. Couldn't hurt right?
Any way, we need top 3 talent up front. Until we do, we won't be very good.